CHAPTER 2: Early Exploration
Nor was the presence of indigenous peoples in northern Alaska a surprise to Europeans. The centuries-old trade between the Chukchis and Eskimos of eastern Siberia and their Alaskan cousins had spurred the interest and avarice of eastward moving Cossacks long before Russian explorers actually sailed to the Great Land. As early as 1648 a disputed Russian reconnaissance may have sailed from the trading center of Nizhne-Kolymsk, on Siberia's north coast toward the strait between Asia.and America. Subsequent probes toward Chukotsk Peninsula and the descriptions brought back by Chukchi and Eskimo traders gave glimmerings of a land known to lie eastward, but still a mystery. These portents inspired Peter the Great, just before his death in 1725, to plan a series of voyages that led to vitus Bering's fog-shrouded passage in 1728 through the strait that bears his name, and to his official discovery of Alaska in 1741. Between Bering's voyages, Mikhail Gvozdev and Ivan Fedorov were commissioned by their local commander in 1732 to sail from Siberia to explore islands and lands to the east. In their tiny ship Gabriel they briefly anchored off an Eskimo village at the later-named Cape Prince of Wales. Rising winds drove them back to sea before they could land. Though theirs was the first certain sighting of mainland Alaska by Europeans, their local venture was overshadowed by Bering's official discovery 9 years later. Bering's course in 1741 took him to the Gulf of Alaska and the Aleutian Islands, where sea otters and fur seals abounded. This wealth of furs along Alaska's southern rim occupied Russian hunters and traders for many decades, saving delineation of the northern coasts to later explorers.2 The next phase of north Alaskan discovery began with British Capt. James Cook's voyage of 1778. Passing through the Aleutian Islands and Bering Strait to Icy Cape, he was blocked beyond 70 degrees north latitude by ice "... as far as the eye could reach ... as compact as a Wall."3 His venture and subsequent ones by Russians and Britons were moved by the quest for an Arctic Ocean passage between Europe and the Pacific. Imperial rivalry and traditions of naval exploratory prowess played no small part in this quest. Nor, as trade opportunities opened, was competition for furs a minor motive. Governments, scientific academies, and government-chartered companies--the Russian-American Company and the British Hudson's Bay Company foremost--focused these forces in a series of expeditions that by 1837 had charted Alaska's northern coasts and named its capes and bays after European sponsors and the discoverers and scientists from many nations who carried out their wishes.4 Meanwhile, Russian traders in 1833 established a post at St. Michael near the mouth of the Yukon. They cautiously probed the lower Yukon and in 1838-39 erected a post at Nulato, just downstream from the Koyukuk River junction, whence they traded as far up the Yukon as the Tanana River. Expansion of the Hudson's Bay Company westward via the Yukon and Mackenzie drainages resulted in founding of the Fort Yukon post in 1847.5 Thus the middle Yukon marked the transfer zone for European goods flowing northward to the central mountains. Journals of official and company explorers mention random encounters with independent traders. For example, in July 1820 at Kotzebue Sound, Capt. Lt. Glieb S. Shishmarev of the Imperial Russian Navy hosted Capt. William J. Pigot of the American brig Pedler. Pigot had sailed from Hawaii to trade furs with the Natives.6 As charts improved and accounts of eager Native traders filtered to the outside world--where they quickly circulated amongst sea captains at Hawaiian and other wintering and refitting ports--the reach and pace of commercial activity increased. Various Royal Navy expeditions associated with Sir John Franklin's search for the Northwest Passage (beginning in the Alaskan arctic in 1826) and the subsequent expeditions that searched for him after his disappearance in 1847, opened up the arctic coasts and seas. Coastal Eskimo villages hosted first the explorers and searchers, eventually traders. Reports from the Franklin expeditions, describing great numbers of whales and walrus in arctic summering grounds, lured whaling captains north from the well-hunted Pacific. By the mid-1850s the arctic whaling industry was firmly established. In time, whaling ships would overwinter on the Arctic coast in places sheltered from the pack ice to get the jump on the migrating whales. In effect, the ships became winter trading posts, which, together with later shore-based whaling and trading stations, irrevocably altered Eskimo lifeways and social arrangements. Dependence on white man's trade goods and foods, acquisition of modern rifles, working as crewmen and caribou hunters for the whalers, and the devastating impacts of diseases and liquor, paired with the decline of caribou and sea mammal populations, variously attracted, repelled, and killed the heretofore isolated Eskimos.7 By the time of the American purchase of Alaska in 1867, the perimeter of northern Alaskan geography was well mapped and well trafficked. But straight lines between the Mackenzie River on the east and Kotzebue Sound on the west, between the Yukon to the south and Point Barrow to the north traversed vast stretches of unknown ground. Tentative probes from these outer limits had been made:
The American purchase of Alaska in 1867 ushered in a series of government-sponsored reconnaissance expeditions designed in part to consolidate United States authority in the new possession. One of these, led by Capt. Charles Raymond of the Corps of Engineers, wrought portentous changes on the Yukon. Appropriately, on July 4, 1869, he departed St. Michael aboard the 50-foot-long paddle-wheel steamer Yukon; entering the mouth of the Yukon, he started the era of river steamboating that would dominate Interior Alaska transportation until World War II. His celestial observations at Fort Yukon, placing it well west of the 141st meridian, convinced the Hudson's Bay Company factor to evacuate the post. Its purchase by the Alaska Commercial Company, which had already taken over the St. Michael and lower Yukon posts of the Russian-American Company, gave the A.C. Co. initial control of Yukon River transportation and trade.11 Far to the north, First Lt. Patrick Henry Ray in 1881-83 operated a Signal Service meteorological station at Point Barrow. This was the last effort in a short-lived attempt by enlightened army officers to give the army a major role in the scientific study and development of Alaska. In early 1883 Ray traveled by sled up the Meade River, reaching the northern limit of the arctic foothills. This was the deepest inland penetration toward the central mountains up to that time. His account and that of his naturalist-observer Sgt. John Murdoch provided a wealth of information about the coastal Eskimos and their relations with inland Eskimos and Indians.12 The last fringing expedition of note before commencement of direct exploration of the central mountains was that of First Lt. Frederick Schwatka. His Alaska Military Reconnaissance of 1883 was the first full-length traverse of what became the Gold Rush trail from Taiya Inlet and Chilkoot Pass to St. Michael, via the entire length of the Yukon River. His insistence upon the need for army posts and steamboat-transport capabilities if the army were to effectively operate in the Interior foreshadowed the army's Interior posts-and-communications system beginning in 1898.13 By 1883 the coastal and riverine fringes encircling the central mountains were known. Scattered outposts rimmed the region, serviced by ocean ships and a rudimentary river-boat transportation system. Explorers and traders, informed by Native travellers, dimly perceived a geography of mountains at the core and rivers draining outward to familiar terrain on the perimeter. The general pattern of Indian and Eskimo occupancy and trade relations could be inferred from the descriptions of informants and chance encounters along the rim. A backflash to one of these encounters serves to illustrate how events had early overleaped the staged progression of civilization's march, and how the Natives, pursuing their own ends, could jar the already stereotyped expectations of arctic explorers. In late April 1854, Cmdr. Rochfort Maguire of Plover, a Royal Navy depot ship winter-based at Point Barrow to aid the Franklin search, took a sled party eastward toward Beechey Point. Along the way,
Maguire's main purpose at Point Barrow was to provide succor to Capt. Richard Collinson of Enterprise, a search vessel trapped by ice in the Canadian Arctic. In July 1854, Collinson finally broke free and made his way westward through the leads between pack ice and shore. Near Barter Island a group of Eskimos accompanied by Interior Indians visited him with letters from the Hudson's Bay Company agent at Fort Yukon: Plover was still on station at Point Barrow. Maguire's notices, given to the Indians at the mouth of the Colville in April, had reached Fort Yukon in June. From there, Indian messengers veered north to intercept Collinson on the Arctic coast in July. Of course he rewarded them with ample gifts.15 The Indians' use of established travel routes as messengers and recipients of prestigious gifts paralleled traditional practice. In this case golden opportunity beckoned in the form of coveted European goods, and the Indians employed their skills and interior lines to meet it. Such prodigies of aboriginal travel were not unusual. For too long white men had watched Natives disappear into bordering woodlands or fade from sight over rolling tundra only to reappear hundreds of miles from their starting points. There seemed to be a great deal going on in the intervening unknown. Inevitably, blank spaces and speculative tracings on maps must be filled in and confirmed. Russians and Britons, and now Americans, had peered in from Alaska's rimlands. They had yet to traverse vast reaches of the center. By the 1880s machinery was in place to drive geographic exploration into all major unknown spaces. In the far north, the three military services--Army, Navy, and Revenue Marine (now the Coast Guard)--would sometimes combine, often compete for the honors of discovery. Brig. Gen. Nelson A. Miles, whose Northwestern Department of the Columbia included Alaska, was a competent, vain, and ambitious man with imagination. Despite opposition from an antagonistic, pinch-penny Congress and the rival ambitions of civilian scientific bureaus, Miles promoted a dominant role for the Army in Alaskan geographic exploration, as in the trans-Mississippi West a few decades earlier. Though the Army had been withdrawn from Alaska in 1877--replaced by the Navy in Southeast Alaska, the Revenue Marine along the western and northern coasts--Miles insisted that he must learn about this territory for which he was militarily responsible. Because he was a man of vision, energetic young officers rallied to his standard. Miles' persistence and the dedication of his junior officers allowed one last chapter in the history of original geographic discovery by the Army.16 Lieutenant Schwatka's 1883 trek over Chilkoot Pass and down the yukon was the first of the Miles-sponsored expeditions. Another, led by Capt. William R. Abercrombie in 1884, bogged down in the Copper River delta, failing its larger purpose to ascend the Copper and cross the Alaska Range to the Yukon drainage. It fell to Lt. Henry Tureman Allen to accomplish that purpose, and exceed it so far as the upper reaches of the Koyukuk. Allen's trek of 1885 inspired Morgan Sherwood to characterize it as "...the most spectacular individual achievement in the history of Alaskan inland exploration."17 Given mounting opposition to his designs, Miles' hopes for a systematic Army exploration of Interior Alaska could not be realized. But Allen's heroic journey gave the general great personal satisfaction and moved him to compare it to the achievement of Lewis and Clark, with which it certainly ranked: 1500 miles of unexplored country traversed: three major river systems mapped, the Copper, the Tanana, and the Koyukuk; a geographic framework that served later explorer-scientists for decades, with maps prepared under the most trying circumstances that "...remained for a dozen years the only source of topographical information on the regions he investigated and were found 'marvelously correct' ..." by a later explorer who retraced parts of his route.18 The outlines of Allen's trip to the Yukon, where he paused to refit before making the final push to the northern mountains, are these: In late March 1885, Allen, Sgt. Cady Robertson, and prospector Peder Johnson began the ascent of the Copper River, transported initially by Indians in their canoes where the water was open, pulling sleds through ice and slush where it was not. They carried a minimum of map-making instruments, rations, and camp gear. Pvt. Frederick W. Fickett soon joined them with additional supplies. But already the difficulties of travel forced a new logistical tactic. They quickly cut their supplies and equipage to the bone, abandoning even their tent, to get down to the 50-pound packs that tested the strongest man in their situation. Allen knew that Abercrombie's failure the year before was partly due to too many men with too much baggage. This knowledge, plus a three-man limit on Army personnel and a grudging budget of $2,000 imposed by Miles' nervous superiors, gave Allen the lean expedition he had recommended from the beginning. With recruitment of another prospector, John Bremner, found marooned and destitute at the Copper River Indian village of Taral, Allen was now ready to meet his charge to find out about the Indians and their country in the Copper and Tanana basins. Picking up new guides or directions as they moved from one Indian territory to the next, often subsisting on roots and maggot-infested meat, tracking upriver in a moose-skin boat they had built--with many side adventures and near disasters--they reached the Copper River headwaters. They then passed over the Alaska Range, and, with a new boat made from caribou hides, ran down the raging Tanana to the Yukon. Some shoeless, some sick, all destitute, starved, and exhausted from the hardships endured, they staggered into the Nuklukayet trading station at the Yukon-Tanana confluence on June 25, nearly a thousand miles from their starting point. His mission completed, Allen could have floated down the Yukon and sailed home, already a hero. Instead, he made a quick trip by canoe down the Yukon past Nulato to meet the steamboats New Racket and Yukon. Returning by steamboat to Nuklukayet with reviving food and supplies, he paid off his prospector companions, and sent the sick Sergeant Robertson to St. Michael. Then, with Fickett, Indian guides and packers, and pack dogs, he prepared to head north through the woods for the Koyukuk.19 ***** Allen's account of Yukon River trading, transportation, and Indian relations during the one-month interval between his arrival at Nuklukayet and departure for the Koyukuk gives a microcosmic view of pre-Gold Rush conditions on the river. It is a dynamic scene of flux and change as whites and Natives adjust to new realities. Many Natives still engage in traditional fishing at river camps as the various species of salmon arrive on scheduled runs. Others from the better trapping locales flock to the trading stations where traders compete for their furs. The designs of the Alaska Commercial Company to monopolize trade and close inefficient trading substations are resented by hold-over Russian Creoles, who, unemployed by these actions, tell the Natives of the exorbitant prices charged by A.C. Co. agents. Indian tyones or chiefs threaten to resist the closing of trading posts that would inconvenience them and consolidate the A.C. Co.'s prices and control. Prospectors are ranging the Yukon tributaries, laying the groundwork for later rushes that will soon sweep the country. Indians from the Tanana, Fort Yukon, and the Koyukuk gather at the Tanana's mouth, the historic boundary between British and Russian spheres of influence in the Yukon fur trade. Trading, games, dances, feasting, and fishing combine function and pleasure for Natives and whites alike, including patriotic salutes on July 4. New Racket, owned by old Yukon hands Arthur Harper, Al Mayo, and LeRoy Napoleon "Jack" McQuesten is hauling miners' supplies--the first such cargo to go up the river, but not the last. The A.C. Co.'s boat Yukon brings the usual supplies for Natives, catering to the fur trade, the older pattern of river commerce. Here, nascent but building, are all the patterns, complaints, and ventures that will rule the river for 50 years to come. To this arterial river, en route from one unknown to another, comes an explorer accompanied by prospectors. He canoes down the Yukon with another, Joe Ladue, and the local Tyone's son. He transfers then to a steamboat, the hooting herald of a new technology that will strip the river's banks in insatiable lust for the wood fuel that powers paddlewheels and steam whistles. Allen shakes off rumors of Koyukon treachery, for he is traveling to their country and only they can guide him. His own pre-expedition research into Russian, British, and American accounts, the spoken embellishments of his trader and prospector companions, and witnessed threats of Indian violence over the changing trade regime, confirm the danger. He has heard many versions of Russian Nulato's burnings and killings by Koyukon Indians trying to protect their own trade monopoly. So be it. More important, these sources of information tell Allen of trading ventures and trails to the Koyukuk. He knows of Zagoskin's progress to the Kateel, and of a later American post there that failed in the plot to intercept Indian traders with Nulato-bound furs. From the Canadian engineer of Yukon, Allen has just heard of a trading trip that the boatman and Al Mayo took the year before to a small village on the Konootena (Kanuti) River, a tributary of the Koyukuk, and he knows he has a choice of portage trails to this place.20 He also knows that time is short for first exploration of the Koyukuk by the Army. Mayo's trading venture is one signal, but there is another. The Revenue Marine and the Navy are closing in from the Kobuk River side. Allen's July 23 entry in his field notebook--written during the steamboat passage back up the Yukon to Nuklukayet--includes this intelligence: "[Lt. John] Cantwell of Cutter Corwin wanted to cross over to Koyukuk but Capt. [Michael] Healy did not desire it, but wanted him to ascend Stoney [Kobuk River] as far as he could then return."21 The time has come to go. After dickering and delay, Koyukon guides are finally hired, supplies packed. The riverine strip of relative civilization is left behind. The woods briefly part then close as the explorer's party leaves the Yukon. And the other world, not quite trackless, begins again. ***** Allen chose the portage route used by the Koyukuks. He and his party (Fickett, 4 Yukon River Indians, 3 Koyukuks, and 5 pack dogs) barged down the Yukon 7 miles with a Russian trader, then headed generally northeast across the Yukon Mountains "of the present charts," then corrected to a northerly course following the divide between the Tozitna and Melozitna rivers. His notebook entry for July 28--the day of departure--states a prime objective, a pointed reminder of past hardships: "Will certainly try not go hungry on this trip." The average pack of the Natives held 50 pounds; each dog carried 25. Fickett and Allen "...were in light marching order, carrying only our instruments and weapons. The bedding for both of us consisted of a piece of waterproof linen, the remnant of a sleeping-bag used on the Copper River, and a single blanket."22 The Indians stayed on the ridges as much as possible, where high ground, sparsely vegetated or bare, was "fair for walking." But by the third day they descended from the mountains to swampy ground "...where the footing is miserable, the hummocks or tetes de femmes offer a very uncertain hold for the feet. To walk between them is to walk continually in water of uneven depth, which consequently is very tiresome." Hordes of mosquitoes and gnats brought more misery, but were displaced by other discomforts--days of cold wind and fog--which drove the insects to cover and were therefore welcomed. At night the wind died and the mosquitoes returned in force. To allow nightly repose, Allen and Fickett, following Native practice, rigged a 2-man "wickyup" covered with strips of cloth and sealed with moss. Except for an occasional displaced twig or bit of moss, caused by a group of Koyukons preceding them, the "trail" lay unmarked across the land. Allen admired the Indians' ability to follow it, their keenness of eyesight. One incident of the march impressed him greatly: Field glasses lost early in the forenoon: the loss discovered several hours later. An Indian backtracks many miles over the imperceptible trail to the surmised point of loss. He returns that night to their camp with the coveted glasses. Allen's references to the Indians' trail and camp knowledge, their astute avoidance of obstacles and discomforts, were mixed with notes of impatience. Lack of shared urgency over white man's schedules that disregarded bad weather and terrain, haggling over compensation for work performed, and waning enthusiasm as the yukon Indians progressed farther from home territory all caused delay and friction. Allen had learned to overcome these hindrances by tactics that transcended cultural differences. For example, when the Indians asserted that it would take 6 more days to reach the Koyukuk drainage, he informed them that rations would cease at the end of the fourth day. "They believed it. We reached the river at the end of the fourth day." On August 2, near Tatatontly (Todatonten) Lake, after a long march that would extend into the evening, the Indian packers issued their own challenge to the white men--a running race for a whole half hour, with packs on. Allen and Fickett hung on and finished the race, proving to the Indians that they could "...keep apace with them. Though I must confess that it was the most stubborn contest I ever engaged in..." The next day, after a 4-hour march over marshy ground following the outlet of Todatonten Lake, Allen's party reached the Kanuti River. They fired shots to inform the nearby villagers of their approach, and were shortly paddled in canoes up the river to the village. The camp of 13 people was about 120 trail miles from Nuklukayet. Allen had pushed across the portage from Yukon to Kanuti in 6 1/2 days. He attributed this swift march across mostly poor footing to cool weather and light packs.23 Within 2 hours Allen discharged his Koyukuk packers, obtained two birch canoes, and, with Fickett and the four Yukon Indians started downstream to the Kanuti's junction with the Koyukuk. After a l4-mile run they reached the big river--swollen with excessive rains, 300 yards wide, and flowing at 4 miles per hour. Allen's hopes of reaching the Koyukuk headwaters in 6 days from this point seemed impossible against such a volume and current of water. Accompanying the explorers from the Kanuti village were three young men and an old man and his family, en route to the uppermost village on the Koyukuk. The Koyukon men traveled alone in small canoes, with the women and children following in a large "squaw" canoe of the type that Allen and Fickett commanded. Allen observed how they stayed close to the bank in shallow water where the current was slower, pushing themselves over the firm bottom with a light stick in each hand. The explorers immediately adopted this form of propulsion and soon had the knack of it, steering and moving forward with dispatch. Allen marveled at their swift progress. Fickett and Allen each had a canoe with two Yukon Indians, "hence each canoe had three pairs of sticks for propellers." The river fluctuated radically with each rain shower. Allen attributed this to the combined effects of saturated moss on the ground surface and rocky or frozen layers immediately below, which shunted the rainwater directly into the streams. The old Indian was quite a traveler. More than once he had crossed over the Alatna portage to the Kowuk (Kobuk) River, where "plenty Mahlamutes [Eskimos] live."24 He mapped out the Allenkaket or Alatna River, tracing its five tributaries and describing the portage journey in days of travel under varying conditions. By August 6 the tandem travelers had reached the mouth of the Nohoolchintna River, the South Fork of the Koyukuk on today's maps. On its bank, a few miles from the main Koyukuk, lay the last settlement on the upper Koyukuk drainage, which Allen estimated extended another 200 miles into the mountains. Before the Indians split off toward the South Fork village, Allen probed their knowledge of the country one more time. The old man told him that 2 long days or 3 short days would bring him to the Ascheeshna (John) River. Allen doubted the old man's claim that 15 days would be required to reach a second tributary, the Totzunbitna (Wild River), but the old man insisted, "... strengthening his statements by holding up his bare feet and counting the days' marches on his toes." The claim of 30 days' march to the Koyukuk's source was relegated to "a matter for future explorers" by the increasingly skeptical Allen. As it turned out the old man was correct about the John River but spaced out the more remote places. Still, Allen used the old man's descriptions and names to sketch the upper course and tributaries of the Koyukuk beyond his own limit of travel. Departure of the Koyukuks and continued progress up the river disheartened the Yukon Indians. They became "...very timid, worked indifferently, and begged to be allowed to go back." They refused to eat until a visit by three South Fork villagers with salmon to barter relieved their dread of intruding strange country without local partners. Cold rain the next morning made them again "faint-hearted," reluctant to break camp. The Indians' sense of territorial limits and Allen's time-and-food supply limits combined to brake the northward journey. But the party pushed on toward the next big tributary, the Ascheeshna. As they worked up the river gradient, first glimpses of snow-covered peaks changed to a horizon-filling range bearing east west. The waters split into swift-flowing channels and the forest became marginal. With increasing elevation, effects of early frost tinged the leaves of deciduous trees. A cold wind from the snowy mountains cleared the sky of rain clouds, "much to my delight," allowing a position observation for the first time in several days. Finally, on August 9, they reached the Ascheeshna, named Fickett River by Allen, later named John River by prospectors in memory of Allen's former trailmate, John Bremner. Allen's matter-of-fact account of these few hours at the farthest-north point of his trek reveals by understatement the wild and remote nature of Brooks Range landscapes:
That same evening, having fled the mosquitoes and gnats of Lookout Mountain, the party started downstream, "bound for home." Within minutes they met an Eskimo--resident on the upper Kobuk--who had come down the Alatna, visited the South Fork Koyukons, and was now heading up the John and over the mountains where there were "plenty Mahlemutes." He asked for cartridges for his old-model Winchester rifle, "which had been furnished by the Arctic whalers." Allen suspected that this man had guided Cantwell into the Koyukuk country, but since the Eskimo could not understand his questions, "we parted none the wiser." His outfit, including a patched and much-worn canoe, was "a rather sorry one," but he did have a bag of iron pyrites, "doubtless imagining he had a treasure," which he gave to one of the Yukon Indians when told it was worthless. Allen traded some tobacco for the Eskimo's pipe and three dried salmon. Here was a veritable epitome of the traditional and early-contact cultural mix. The run down the Koyukuk was uneventful but long--and ever longer as the river matured into slow-flowing meanders through broad floodplains. Allen's field notebook filled up with bearings and topographical descriptions as he charted the river, its islands, and the environs. He was the first to do so for all but the lower reaches. Progress was marked by encounters with the river people and the changing natural scene:
So the adventures of Allen and Fickett were not yet at an end. They continued their canoe travels down the Yukon, hiked across the Kaltag portage, canoed down the Unalakleet River, and --lastly--paddled, sailed, and cordelled an Eskimo skin boat along 55 miles of Norton Sound's windy and surf-battered coast to St. Michael. On September 5 they departed for San Francisco aboard the Revenue Cutter Corwin, Capt. Michael A. Healy commanding.27 ***** Original exploration of the Koyukuk by Lt. Henry Allen and Private Fickett barely led the movement of white men into that river basin. Within months, during the depths of the 1885-86 winter, Engr. A.V. Zane of Lt. George M. Stoney's expedition portaged from the Kobuk to the Koyukuk, striking that river at mid-course, then proceeding downstream to the Yukon and St. Michael. He returned by essentially the same route, following established Native routes both ways.28 In a larger sense, the white man's presence in northern Alaska had preceded them, having already wreaked radical change in the fabric of Koyukuk Native society. Allen astutely documented these changes, both in his narrative of encounters with Native people and in his summary reflections. He found that even the remote villagers on the Kanuti and the South Fork had suffered death or impairment from epidemics carried by Native vectors from trading stations on the Yukon and the coast. In these far places Allen noted a number of deaf mutes among those who had survived the diseases. He commented on the skewed demographics--few men to hunt for disproportionately large numbers of women and children. He understood that in hunting and gathering societies this is a most distressing condition, particularly at a time of extreme game scarcity, as then existed. He viewed the Indians' poverty-stricken and miserable lives with compassion, urging charity: "If the Government desires that this people should continue to exist, some provision for them should soon be made."29 Exploration of the Kobuk River by the Revenue Marine Service and the Navy began in 1883 as the offshoot of a special mission of appreciation to Siberian Natives. After delivering gifts to the Siberians for rendering aid to shipwrecked sailors, Naval Lt. George M. Stoney proceeded to Kotzebue Sound aboard Captain Healy's Revenue Cutter Corwin. While Healy continued his cruise up the coast, Stoney, with a boat, rations, and a crewmember from the cutter, spent two weeks examining Hotham Inlet and the delta and lower course of the Kobuk. From a local Native he learned of an interior river (the Colville) that flowed to an ocean filled with ice, and of another major river (the Noatak) emptying into Hotham Inlet. His informant also told of portages and passes between the rivers. Thus was the basic geography of the western Brooks Range revealed. This initial and somewhat accidental collaboration of the two services led to rival claims of discovery of the Kobuk River by Stoney and Healy and impelled rival expeditions in following years. The Navy may have been out of bounds in pursuing interior exploration. But the upshot of competitive expeditions would be the rapid mapping of major rivers and travel routes in northern Alaska, thus integrating coastal, riverine, and mountain access until then known only to Natives.30 Upon Stoney's return from the lower Kobuk reconnaissance in 1883, he requested authority from the Navy to further explore the river the next year. For he believed it to be "...an excellent highway into the heart of Arctic Alaska." His request was granted and in April 1884 he sailed north from San Francisco commanding the schooner Ounalaska.31 Meanwhile, Captain Healy organized his 1884 summer cruise in Corwin for full-scale exploration of the Kobuk by the Revenue Marine Service. Captain Healy's long career in Alaskan waters, though marred by bouts of intemperance, brought him praise from Congress, the whaling industry, and missionary groups as a "... zealous and efficient officer in the discharge of his difficult and perilous duties in the Arctic."32 As the Corwin's commander Healy directed the 1884-85 explorations of his officers Lt. John C. Cantwell and Engr. S.B. McLenegan on the Kobuk and Noatak rivers. Upon Corwin's arrival at Kotzebue Sound, Third Lt. J.C. Cantwell took command of a steam launch and boat's crew and on July 8, 1884, began ascent of the Kobuk. His orders from Healy required survey of the river and description of its inhabitants and " ... in general, everything of interest to science and commerce" from mouth to source.33 Stoney entered the Kobuk's mouth in a steam cutter eight days later. Both parties proceeded upriver more than 300 miles, mapping the river and gathering valuable experience for the next year's effort. The small steamboats proved balky and underpowered for upper river travel, so Native skin boats, until then towed, carried the explorers on the final legs of their upstream journeys. Cantwell turned back first, being short of rations and plagued by the troublous steam launch. The expeditions passed each other in the neighborhood of Jade Mountain, Stoney still on the ascent. Neither party reached the headwaters in 1884, but Stoney proceeded a few miles beyond Cantwell's farthest point. Low water forced the Navy party to resort to laborious tracking of the skin boat, pulling it through rocks and riffles with a sealskin towline. Informed by an Eskimo that the river (called Putnam by Stoney, after a naval officer lost at sea) headed in a series of large lakes, Stoney took off across country to discover and name one of them, Selby Lake. Upon his return downriver to the schooner, Stoney assigned Ens. J.L. Purcell to a week-long survey of Selawik Lake near the Kobuk delta. Cantwell had also left the main river on a reconnaissance to Jade Mountain, where he gathered mineral specimens. Cantwell's relations with the Natives, whom he viewed as energetic if not attentive to personal hygiene, were mainly good. His ethnological notes of the 1884 expedition provide a valuable record of late-traditional, early-contact times on the upper Kobuk.34 For both explorers the 1884 expeditions had been valuable shakedown cruises. The difficulties encountered led to improved outfits for the coming year. In Stoney's case, planning and logistics revolved around an overwinter expedition that could take full advantage of both riverine and overland travel. They both wanted to reach the Kobuk headwaters and prove by their own travels the geography and travel routes described by Native informants, particularly connections between the Kobuk, Koyukuk, Noatak, and Colville rivers. Both recognized the importance of a land link across the mountains to the Arctic Ocean to allow succor or rescue of ice-bound whalers. They wanted to fill in the blank spaces and contact new Native groups in the mountains and north of them. Cantwell would seek more data on valuable minerals, whose signs he had noted along the upper Kobuk.35 The Revenue Marine expedition of 1885 aimed for the Kobuk River headwaters. Cantwell quickly reached the head of navigation for the improved steam launch, getting a few miles past Stoney's highest point of the year before. Leaving the launch in charge of Charles H. Townsend, whose natural science report helped make this expedition a scientific success, Cantwell proceeded upstream in a 28-foot skin boat. The Native crew led by Tah-tah-rok was faithful and hard working, often putting in 14-hour days. Their handling of the skin boat in what had become a swift mountain river of rocks and rapids elicited this praise from Cantwell: "...it is really marvelous what judgment and skill are shown by them in handling the skin boat...in this peculiar style of navigation."36 As they worked up the river Cantwell noted the abundance of game, particularly young geese not fully fledged, which they easily caught. The low banks of the river supported dense willow thickets, which made finding campsites difficult. Heavy timber clung to ridges and mountainsides. Many streams heading in small lakes flowed into the river. The topography indicated that they were approaching the watershed between the Kobuk and the Koyukuk rivers.37 On July 16 Cantwell and his Native crew passed the Ung-ee-let-ar-geeak (Reed) River and began the final push toward Big Fish Lake, called Car-loog-ah-look-tah by the Natives, now shown on maps as Walker Lake. The river became swifter as the mountains closed in on the valleys and canyons of the uppermost segment of the river. Big Fish Lake was the largest of the Kobuk's feeder lakes and symbolized for Cantwell the primary source of the great river. The struggle up the last 40 river- miles is best told by these excerpts from Cantwell's narrative: 38
***** Cantwell determined to get the boat as far upriver as possible, despite the barrier rapids. Using jammed logs to form "a kind of ways" over the rocks, Cantwell and his crew hauled the boat past the swift water. Shortly, they left the Kobuk's true headwater channel and tracked up Walker Lake's outlet stream. The shallows finally forced them to beach the boat and make camp. From this point they hiked to a hill from which they could see the lake:
Cantwell's downstream journey through the Kobuk canyons was nearly foiled by the patched and battered skin boat. Protecting it with a false keel made of a spruce tree and basketwork bumpers made of woven willows, the crew lined and portaged through the narrow passages, finally reaching deep water and the launch.39 While Cantwell steamed and boated up the Kobuk, another of Corwin's officers, Asst. Engr. S.B. McLenegan, and Seaman Nelson struggled up the Noatak River in a 3-hole kayak or bidarka 27 feet long. Theirs was an arduous journey through barren, rainy wilds with hardly any respite from hardship and suffering. During the month's ascent to a point more than 300 miles above the river mouth, they spent endless hours waist deep in the freezing current harnessed to the tracking line. Short rations, constant cold and wet, and grueling labor mark this heroic exploration.40 In characterizing the river, McLenegan stated that "...it was known only from native accounts, for there is no record of it ever having been visited by white men." Even the Yukon traders knew nothing of this river, beyond a vague conception of its being there, indicating "...how utterly blank was that vast region even to those best informed." McLenegan traced the river through alternating mountains and lowlands, ending in its upper midcourse "lying on the tablelands of the interior ... an elevated plateau, rolling occasionally into hills and then stretching away into vast tracts of moorland."41 A few paragraphs of McLenegan's narrative of exploration distill his and Seaman Nelson's hardships and hardihood:42
In 1885, as in 1884, the Revenue Marine had "upstreamed" the Navy, Cantwell on his return down the Kobuk again passing Stoney on the way up. But the more deliberate Stoney had compensated by organizing and equipping for a new kind of interior arctic exploration. Not satisfied with the limitations of summer reconnaissance, he had provisioned for a 20-month overwintering expedition manned by a large contingent of officers and men. His well-laid plans included two river steamers, one a flat-bottomed boat for low-water travel, and a portable steam-driven sawmill. This he used to build a winter camp, Fort Cosmos, some 250 miles up the Kobuk. From this base, near the location of the modern village of Shungnak, he could send out expeditions in all directions--using dogs for extensive winter travel through the mountains and toward the Yukon. He assigned his officers specific scientific and expeditionary responsibilities, maintaining strict military schedules and discipline.43 Under this regime an impressive list of accomplishments resulted, summarized here by Morgan Sherwood:
Stoney's full report with finished maps was never published, nor were the individual scientific reports of his officers. Stoney asserted that both the Secretary of the Navy and the Congress had approved report publication, but "In some way the papers have mysteriously disappeared."45 Historians attribute the loss to various causes: interservice rivalry, personal rivalry between Stoney and Healy, or the fears of Navy brass that Congress would charge them with "wasteful duplication" of effort on the Kobuk River.46 Alfred Hulse Brooks of the U.S. Geological Survey greatly admired Stoney's accomplishments and lamented that only Stoney's later abbreviated account, the expedition log, and the manuscript maps survived the suspected purge of records.47 That abbreviated account, first published in the Proceedings of the U.S. Naval Institute in 1899, remains the principal source for Lieutenant Stoney's 1885-86 Northern Alaska Naval Exploring Expedition. Manuscripts and the diary relating to Ensign Howard's northern Alaska crossing have recently been found and summarized by anthropologist Edwin S. Hall, Jr., allowing detailed insight into that momentous journey.48 From both Stoney's account and the log book of U.S.S. Explorer (the shallow-draft sternwheeler that served as expedition workhorse on the Kobuk) emerges a picture of detailed planning, logistics, and camp operations. Stoney knew the value of Native clothing; he traded tobacco and other goods for Native boots, pants, parkies, mitts, and skins as the charter schooner Viking conveyed the party up the coast to Kotzebue Sound. He used Native labor extensively in relaying his elaborate inventory of supplies up the Kobuk, using cache camps at intervals up the river, for his boats could not haul all the goods at once. (This deliberate and staged advance gave Cantwell the short-term lead on the Kobuk that year, but was the key to Stoney's staying power over the winter.) Camp buildings copied Native cold-weather building technology, being semi subterranean and covered with dirt like Native winter houses. Once established at Fort Cosmos, the race against winter commenced in earnest. The prime necessities were shelter, wood, meat, and fish--for heat and food, for man and dog. Both Natives and whites were employed in the many tasks according to Stoney's division of labor into specialized work gangs--fishermen, woodcutters, carpenters, and sawmillers. Native women dried salmon for winter use. Refined modes of water supply, heating, sanitation, and exercise, along with careful diet and food preparation, assured a healthy camp. Established routines, amusements, and technical instruction eased the psychological burdens of camp life. By late September the boats were laid out for the winter, beyond the reach of crushing winter ice. Supplies were cached. The men had moved into the large winter house and serious exploration could begin.49 From the central location of Fort Cosmos, well up the Kobuk River, "... we were able to strike across the several divides into the adjoining river-valleys by comparatively short routes...."50 As soon as ice and snow conditions allowed, beginning December 1st, individual exploring parties fanned out to the Noatak headwaters and across the Arctic Divide, to the Koyukuk and St. Michael, to the Reed River hot springs, and to Selawik Lake. Later Stoney set up a base line for triangulation of the Kobuk Valley: still later he proceeded from its head to the Alatna headwaters and over the Arctic Divide to Chandler Lake, named by Stoney for the Secretary of the Navy. On his trips across the divide where the streams flowed north into the Colville River, Stoney contacted mountain Eskimos. They refused to guide him to the Arctic Coast in winter because they would starve for lack of game, but they agreed to do so in the spring. This set up Howard's trip to Barrow. On June 15, 1886, Fort Cosmos was abandoned and the boats started downriver. In the general movement toward the coast, and later from Camp Purcell on Hotham Inlet, side expeditions to the lower Noatak, Jade Mountain, and Selawik Lake completed Stoney's survey goals. On the night of August 25 the entire party carne together on the Revenue Cutter Bear, which had earlier retrieved Howard at Barrow, and sailed next morning for San Francisco, courtesy of Captain Healy.51 Stoney's summary of the expedition's work testifies both to his leadership and to the devoted service of the whites and Natives who made his crew:
The following excerpts from Stoney's Explorations (including Howard's formal report of the Barrow trip) convey the discoverers' views of a new country. They also give a last view of interior Eskimo life at the break point between traditional ways and the new ways brought by traders, whalers, and other white men whom the Eskimos met each summer at the coast. By 1886, most of the Eskimo groups had been severely affected by the combination of caribou decline and the diseases and trade goods of the white man--particularly introduction of the rifle, which largely eliminated communal hunting patterns. Starvation, death from disease, and a desperate kind of mobility as people fought for survival and access to addictive trade goods had already disrupted normal seasonal rounds and wreaked social havoc. "Howard [and Stoney] traveled through an impoverished Eskimo world, shorn of many of its participants and contaminated by introduced traits, a world that would soon cease to exist."53 Lieutenant Stoney's account comprises summary reflections on conditions and techniques of travel, shelter, and the like, punctuated with interludes of direct experience and observation. He is a bluff, no-nonsense man, seemingly impervious to doubt or introspection. This sampler, including trips to the Noatak headwaters and up the Alatna River past the Arrigetch Peaks, which Stoney recorded for the first time, shows a leader of exploration at work:54
Stoney's trip to the Alatna River, providing the first recorded description of the Arrigetch peaks, occurred in March 1886:
Ensign Howard, by contrast to Stoney, had to overcome the normal human foibles of fear and uncertainty in strange places. With perseverance and growing confidence throughout his journey, he did overcome, brilliantly. A keen and respectful observer, he was willing to live off the country and follow the lead of the Natives, whose knowledge he admired. In short order, they incorporated him into their lifeways and seasonal rounds in a manner that transcended formal hospitality. On April 12, 1886, Howard left Fort Cosmos with Crewman F.J. Price and three Eskimos, en route to Barrow. As on the earlier trip with Stoney, the party ascended the Ambler River and crossed the divide into the Noatak basin in search of Owpuk, the Eskimo leader who in December had pledged to Stoney his guide services for the trip to Barrow. We pick up Howard's account as he proceeds through the villages of the Noatak and across the Arctic Divide to the Etivluk River in the Colville basin. What follows is a unique description of Eskimo life on the knife edge of tradition and transition. Howard's participation in and description of the traditional mountain Eskimo spring gathering and trade journey to the coast is one of a kind. There is no other first-hand record of this event, soon doomed to extinction.55
***** As a result of the military explorations of 1883-86 the geographic framework of the central mountains and upper rivers became available to experts on the Arctic and to the prospectors who now began to filter into the region. Given its remote location hundreds of miles up difficult and fluctuating rivers, this fringe land above the Arctic Circle offered little to white men. Even the Natives were few in number and scattered across vast distances. Gold mining in these early years centered on the upper Yukon, hundreds of miles away. Trading posts found no profit where only occasional prospectors roamed, where Native trappers and fur-bearing animals were spread thin. The explorers' search for a trans-mountain rescue trail from Kobuk or Koyukuk to Arctic Coast had died in the mountain topography and seasonally closed expanses of northern Alaska. Evidence of precious metals brought back by the explorers and the prospectors who followed them would bring miners in some numbers to the region, especially in the false rush of 1898-99, but never near the scale of the Yukon and Nome rushes. Remoteness and difficult access would hold the region essentially in trust until the airplane and the recent discovery of giant oil fields broke the barriers of distance and economic limbo. Thus, geographic discovery did not trigger an ordered progress of settlement and civilization in this region. Instead, excepting occasional short-lived gold-mining flurries, the country would remain largely a refuge for people who liked being on the edge of nowhere, Native and white person alike. Lacking the necessary critical mass of economic incentives and numbers of people, progress passed the region by. In this perspective, the history that ensued after 1886 is a story of minor booms and long busts, of tiny communities not quite getting there, struggling to keep alive such symbols of civilization as a post office or a school, or folding entirely--with the deserted sites then salvaged by the hard core of Natives and whites who dwelt in the distant camps of a marginal place. It is this concept of the margin, of the borderland, and of the kinds of people who by heritage or choice lived there that dominates the history. The fact is, until World War II the history of most of Interior Alaska was like this. The Gates of the Arctic region, being a margin of the margin, was until very recently the epitome of that earlier Alaska--a place where time usually stood still, then jolted forward a bit, and again fell back after the current boom ran its short course. In this arrested space-time environment, the evolving guard of old timers and a few new recruits who stayed after each boomlet kept alive until just yesterday traditions of both Native and frontier-American sort that had just about vanished in most of America at the very time this region's history started. The nature of this remote world and the responses to it and to each other of the people who lived and visited there form the central theme of this history. People were few, institutions practically nil. So this is personal history--biographical and anecdotal. Great movements and faceless masses did not surge this far north. Everyone who stayed more than a season hardened up and became a part of the country. The code of time and place allowed plenty of room for idiosyncrasy; it required self-reliance. But individualism was tempered by the notion that nobody would let down a neighbor when the chips were down. The selection process, a fine screen of demanding natural and social conditions, worked along these lines.
gaar/hrs/chap2.htm Last Updated: 28-Nov-2016 |