Endnotes
Chapter One
1. Nathaniel P. Reed to Undersecretary [of the
Interior], January 11, 1972, Bureau of Outdoor Recreation, Box 3, Alaska
Task Force General Files, Records of the National Service, Record Group
79, Federal Archives and Records Center (FARC), Seattle, Washington.
Additionally, other "interest areas" which could not be withdrawn
because they were reserved for other purposes were listed. The Alaska
Native Claims Settlement Act of 1971, and the National Interest Lands
Provision therein are discussed in Chapter two.
2. Ibid. The total in the January 11 package
included 54,190,000 acres identified for study for possible inclusion in
the National Refuge System administered by the Bureau of Sport Fisheries
and Wildlife (later United States Fish and Wildlife Service), and
9,000,000 acres for study as potential addition to the Wild and Scenic
Rivers System. Some 6,090,000 acres of this total were areas of "mutual
interest."
3. "Natural Areas in Alaska," July 19, 1971, History
of NPS in Alaska, Personal Papers of Theodor R. Swem, Evergreen, Colo.;
William C. Everhart, The National Park Service (New York:
Praeger, 1972), pp. 252-60. The acreage of parks in Alaska amounted to
two percent of Alaska's land mass, but twenty-six percent of the total
acreage of the 284 units of the National Park System.
By 1972 the Bureau of Sports Fisheries and Wildlife managed eighteen
areas in Alaska totaling 19,819,221.3 acres. The Bureau had a detailed
knowledge of the wildlife values of Alaska gained through its role as
the wildlife managing agency during territorial days, and had only
recently completed a comprehensive survey that identified critical
waterfowl habitats throughout the state. "Annual Report of the Lands
under control of the Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife as of June
30, 1972," Xerox copy from Division of Realty, Regional Office, Region
6, United States Fish and Wildlife Service; Interview of Roger Allin by
Theodor Swem, January 21, 1979, tapes in Mr. Swem s possession; United
States Department of the Interior (USDI), Bureau of Sport Fisheries and
Wildlife (BSF&W), An Evaluation of Alaska Habitat For Migratory
Birds, by James C. King and Calvin J. Lensink (Washington, D.C.,
1971); USDI, BSF&W, To Have and to Hold, Alaska's Migratory
Birds (Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office, 1971).
4. "Report on a Proposed National Monument at Sitka,
Alaska," April 9, 1910, File 1215, Part 1, 3/5/1910-12/5/1910, Parks,
Reservations and Antiquities...Sitka, Records of the National Park
Service, Record Group 79, National Archives (N.A.), Washington, D.C.;
Presidential Proclamation No. 959, March 3, 1910, in U.S., Department of
the Interior, National Park Service, Proclamations and Orders
Relating to the National Park Service up to January 1, 1945,
compiled by Thomas A. Sullivan (Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1947), pp.
299-300. Sitka and Old Kasaan were the only historical areas in Alaska
before 1976.
5. Presidential Proclamation No. 959.
6. 39 Stat. 938, February 26, 1917; Annual Report
of the Director of the National Park Service to the Secretary of
Interior for the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 1917, and the Travel Season,
1917 (Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1917), p. 24; 1922, p. 83. On
January 30, 1922, the boundaries were enlarged by 284,800 acres. On
March 19, 1932, an additional 246,693 acres were added.
7. USDI, NPS, A History of Mount McKinley
National Park, by Grant Pearson (1953), pp. 24-27, 60-66.
8. Ibid.; Charles T. Sheldon, The
Wilderness of Denali: Explorations of a Hunter-Naturalist in Northern
Alaska, introduction by C. Hart Merriam (New York: Charles
Scribner's Sons, 1960), p. 212; Charles Sheldon to Stephen T. Mather,
December 15, 1915, Proposed National Parks-Mt. Mckinley, Central
Classified Files, RG 79, N.A.; National Park Service, "Mt. Mckinley
National Park, Alaska," typescript, n.d., Mt. McKinley History, General,
1927-31, Central Classified Files, RG 79, N.A.; United States Department
of the Interior (USDI), National Park Service (NPS), Proceedings of
the National Parks Conference, January 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6, 1917
(Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1917), pp. 193-99. "Denali," the name Sheldon
preferred, was a Native name for the mountain"The Great One."
9. Pearson, Mount McKinley, pp 26-27, 60-66.
Apparently, much of the opposition had to do with a policy of the House
Committee on Public Lands that restricted the number of park bills that
would be reported favorably each session.
10. Horace M. Albright to John A. Hussey, July 10,
1971. Quoted in USDI, NPS, Historic Resource Study: Katmai National
Monument, by John A. Hussey (San Francisco: NPS [Western Service
Center], 1971) p. 412.
11. Ibid. Robert F. Griggs led National
Geographic Society expeditions into the area in 1915, 1916, and
1917.
12. Ibid. Mr. Albright told Theodor R. Swem
that he and Gilbert Grosvenor of the National Geographic Society wrote
the proclamation for Katmai. Discussion with Mr. Swem, August 9,
1984.
13. Ibid., pp. 412-16; Presidential
Proclamation No. 1487, September 24, 1918; Annual Report of the
Director of the National Park Service, 1931, p. 102. See also, USDI,
NPS, Katmai National Monument, Alaska: A History of Its Establishment
and Revision of Its Boundaries, by John M. Kauffmann (Washington,
D.C.: NPS, 1954). In 1931 the monument was enlarged by 1,609,590 acres.
The enlargement reincorporated a small, ten-acre tract removed in 1923
by Executive Order 3897. The purpose of removal of that earlier tract,
was, according to Kauffmann, to allow John J. Fulstad to obtain a permit
to mine coal.
14. Thomas Riggs, Jr. to Stephen T. Mather, Nov.
18, 1918, Box 159, Monuments, Katmai, 12/31/1917-12/16/1924, Central
Classified Files, RG 79, N.A.
15. Juneau Empire, April 18, 1924,
Monuments, Glacier Bay, Part 2, 3/21/24-4/29/24, Central Classified
Files, RG 79, N.A. Similar protests are cited in USDI, NPS, Glacier
Bay National Monument, Alaska A History of Its Boundaries, by John
M. Kauffmann (Washington, D.C.: NPS, 1954), p. 35.
16. Presidential Proclamation No. 1763, February
26, 1925. Detailed information on the legislative history of Glacier Bay
National Monument is in USDI, NPS, "History of Glacier Bay," by Bruce
Black, typescript, 1957, Library, Glacier Bay National Park/Preserve,
Gustavus, Alaska; Dave Bohn, Glacier Bay: The Land and the
Silence (San Francisco: Sierra Club, 1967), pp. 94-96; and
Kauffmann, Glacier Bay.
17. Presidential Proclamation No. 1763, February
26, 1925. In 1939 President Franklin D. Roosevelt added 904,960 acres to
the monument and in 1955, 14,925 acres were deleted. Presidential
Proclamation No. 2330, April 18, 1939; Presidential Proclamation No.
3089, March 31, 1955; Kauffmann, Glacier Bay, pp. 13-33; Black,
"Glacier Bay," pp. 76-77.
18. Statement of Dr. W.S. Cooper, Juneau
Empire, 1924. Quoted in Kauffmann, Glacier Bay, p. 58.
According to Cooper, some eighty of the "principal institutions of the
country devoted to scientific research and the cause of conservation"
approved and actively supported the proposal.
Interestingly, the Canadian Parks Association supported and lobbied
for the proposal. Arthur O. Wheeler to Hubert C. Work, June 13, 1924,
Monuments, Glacier Bay, Part 3, 5/1/24-9/2/24, Central Classified Files,
RG 79, N.A.
19. "Recommendations submitted by the Ecological
Society of America with regard to the Establishment of a National
Monument at Glacier Bay, Alaska," n.d. [1924], National Monuments,
Glacier Bay, part 1, 12/24/1923-3/20/1924, Central Classified Files, RG
79, N.A.
20. Presidential Proclamation No. 1351, Oct. 25,
1916. President Wilson acted at the request of the Alaska Cruise Club,
an organization dedicated to publicizing Alaska. Old Kasaan,
6/30/1913-3/24/1926, Box 596, Central Classified Files, RG 79, N.A.
21. USDI, NPS, Administrative History, Expansion of
the National Park Service in the 1930s by Harlen D. Unrau and G. Frank
Williss (Denver: NPS, 1983), p. 68. Until 1933, when Executive Order
6166 transferred control of all national monuments to the NPS, the
department having jurisdiction over the land from which the monument was
withdrawn would administer that monument.
22. Dorr C. Yeager to Verne Staphenhorst, August
25, 1955, Historical Files, William E. Brown Files, Alaska Regional
Office, Anchorage, Alaska.
23. Annual Report of the Director of the
National Park Service, 1925, pp. 56-59. By 1972 the boundary
adjustments mentioned had made Glacier Bay (2,803,840 acres) the largest
unit in the Park System with Katmai (2,792,137 acres) a close second.
Everhart, The National Park Service, pp. 253-54.
The size of Glacier Bay and Katmai blurred even more a vague
distinction between national parks and monuments. Unrau and Williss,
Expansion of the National Park Service, p. 12.
24. 39 Stat. 938. On May 21, 1928, the hunting
provision was repealed (45 Stat. 622).
25. From time to time, individuals or organizations
in Alaska, even the territorial and state legislatures, requested
national park or monument status for some area. Among the areas
mentioned were Ice Bluffs of Kotzebue Sound (1929), Shake Island (1939),
Imuruk Lava Beds (1963), Serpentine Hot Springs (1970), and Point Barrow
(1963). It is believed, however, that these were isolated instances, and
do not change the general conclusions. "Alaska wants Ice Bluffs at
Kotzebue Sound made a National Park," March 9, 1939, 0-32, Proposed
Park, General, part 9, 1/12/29 - 4/28/30; [_____] to Anthony J. Diamond,
State Files-Landmark Program, History Division, Washington Office
(WASO); Ben Thompson to Esther McCoy, September 4, 1963, L 58, Volume 2,
Alaska, 1/1/61-12/31/63, Box 42, Records of the Office of the Regional
Director, Region 4, RG 79, Federal Archives and Records Center (FARC),
San Bruno, California; Walter Hickel to Theodor R. Swem, May 22, 1970,
Document No. 002608, ANILCA Papers, Center for Information and Library
Services, United States Department of Interior, Washington, D.C.; Oscar
Dick to Regional Director, Western Region, February 21, 1963, L58,
Proposed areas, Park Files, Denali National Park and Preserve, Alaska.
The ANILCA Papers are a collection of Department of the Interior agency
files relating to the legislative history of the Alaska National
Interest Lands Act. At this point, not all documents are on the computer
index. When finished, however, documents listed under this reference may
be retrieved by referring to the index.
26. A number of works describe management (or lack)
of parks and monuments before 1916. Information here is from Unrau and
Williss, Expansion of the National Park Service, pp. 14-16.
27. USDI, Report of the Commissioner of the
General Land Office to the Secretary of the Interior for the Fiscal Year
ended June 30,1916 (Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1916), p. 62. The
situation was similar in the Department of Agriculture where the Forest
Service was the responsible agency.
28. Annual Report of the Director of the
National Park Service, 1918, p. 90.
29. Ibid., 1925, p. 15.
30. Pearson, Mt. McKinley, p. 34. Horace
Albright visited in 1931, as well.
31. "Organization, National Park Service, October
10, 1935," In Unrau and Williss, Expansion of the National Park
Service, p. 249. In Alaska, after 1937, the Superintendent of Mt.
McKinley was also responsible for Katmai, and the custodian of Sitka was
responsible for Glacier Bay. Superintendent's Monthly Report, January 1,
1937, Park Archives, Denali National Park/Preserve.
32. Grant Pearson to Regional Director, May 28,
1948, National Monuments, Sitka, Central Classified Files, RG 79, N.A.;
Newton B. Drury to Assistant Secretary Warner, October 13, 1947, 3041,
Alaska Development, Records of Newton B. Drury, RG 79, N.A. Pearson
recommended the appointment of Alfred Kuehl, a landscape architect to
supervise the office.
33. Unrau and Williss, Expansion of the National
Park Service, p. 29.
34. Pearson, Mt. McKinley, p. 32.
35. USDI, NPS, Public Use of the National Parks:
A Statistical Report 1904-46. (Reprint, 1963). It is perhaps a bit
unfair to compare Yellowstone, which had the highest visitation in the
system, with Alaska. It is believed, however, that such a contrast most
vividly expresses the problem.
36. Unrau and Williss, Expansion of the National
Park Service, passim.
37. Superintendent's Monthly Reports, April and
June 1938, Park Archives, Denali National Park/Preserve. Among the jobs
undertaken by the CCC, which was in McKinley the next year as well, were
constructing new residences for park employees, moving the dog kennels,
building a sewer line, and maintenance of the telephone line.
38. Section G. This cap existed until 1927. John
Ise, Our National Park Policy: A Critical History (Baltimore,
Md.: John Hopkins Press, 1961) p. 229. In 1925, however, $11,920 was
appropriated and $11,533 spent. Annual Report of the Director of the
National Park Service, 1925, p. 70.
39. Annual Report of the Director of the
National Park Service, 1921, p. 96. The $8,000 included all
maintenance, protection, improvements in the park, the salary of the
superintendent and any assistants, as well as costs of surveys of the
boundaries.
The first superintendent was Harry P. Karstens, who had accompanied
Charles Sheldon during his stay in the area during the winter of
1907-1908. His first assistant was hired in November 1921 . As late as
1929 the permanent staff consisted of the superintendent and four
assistants. Pearson, Mt. McKinley, p. 30.
40. Annual Report of the Director of the
National Park Service, 1929, p. 55.
41. Pearson, Mt. McKinley, pp. 33-42;
Superintendent's Monthly Reports, Mount Mckinley National Park,
September 1925, November 1925, and passim, Park Archives, Denali
National Park/Preserve. Road construction was carried on by the Alaska
Road Commission under a cooperative agreement. Annual Report of the
Director of the National Park Service, 1929, p. 106.
42. Superintendent's Monthly Report, Mt. McKinley
National Park, March 1935, Park Archives, Denali National Park/Preserve;
Harry O. Liek to Alstan G. Gutterson, August 20, 1937, Superintendent's
Monthly Report, November 1937, Ibid.; Superintendent's Monthly
Report, Mt. McKinley National Park, July 1937, Ibid.; Pearson,
Mount McKinley, p. 36.
43. Annual Report of the Director of the
National Park Service, 1932, p. 92.
44. Robert Marshall in 1916, quoted in Unrau and
Williss, Expansion of the National Park Service, p. 17. Robert
Marshall was General Superintendent of the National Parks in 1916.
45. Arno Cammerer to Ruth Reat, February, 1930,
National Monuments, Katmai, 12/3/1917 - 12/26/1927, Box 591, Classified
Files, RG 79, N.A.
46. Frank T. Been, "Field Notes of Katmai National
Monument Inspection, November 12, 1940," Xerox copy in Brown Files,
Alaska Regional Office (ARO); Superintendent's Monthly Report, Mt.
McKinley National Park, October-November 1936, June 1937, Park Archives,
Denali National Park/Preserve; Hussey, Katmai, p. 423.
Chief Ranger Roger Corbey of Mount McKinley National Park had been
assigned a reconnaissance survey of Katmai in 1937. He was in the area
for a period in June (he left Mt. Mckinley on June 2 and returned on the
20th). According to Hussey, he was able to do little more than spend a
few hours in the monument when his plane landed at Lake Grosvenor and
Naknek Lake. The Superintendent's Monthly Reports (Mt. McKinley),
indicate, however, that he also made an inspection of the concessioner's
camps and operations, of a trail along Brooks River, and of a Fish and
Wildlife Service installation. Following, the superintendent recommended
that logs be gathered along Brooks Lake for any future buildings
constructed by the Service or concessioner, and that a small landing
strip be built near Brooks River.
47. Lowell Sumner, "Special ReportKatmai
Master Planning Field Study, September 5-13, 1963," Box 4, Alaska Task
Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Superintendent's Monthly Reports, Mt.
Mckinley National Park, September 1940, December 1945, October 1945,
July 1948, August 1948, June 1954; Hussey, Katmai, pp. 423-24.
Actually, Been and Cahalane spent most of September 1940 on foot in the
monument. Been and Alfred Kuehl visited the area in 1945, and the
regional director authorized sending a ranger from Mount McKinley to
Katmai for temporary duty as early as June 1948.
48. Earl A. Trager, "Glacier Bay Expedition, 1939,"
typescript in Archives, Glacier Bay National Park and Preserve; Black,
"Glacier Bay," p. 79; Superintendent's Monthly Report, Mt. McKinley
National Park, July 8, 1936. Associate Director Arthur E. Demaray
visited, or at least flew over the area in 1936. He planned on flying
over Katmai at that time, but was unable to do so.
49. Annual Report of the Director of the
National Park Service, 1921, p. 114; "Report on the Inspection of
Old Kasaan N.M., May 27, 1940," by Ben C. Miller [Custodian of Sitka
N.M.], Old Kasaan N.M., Brown Files, ARO. In the 1930s the Forest
Service removed a number of totem poles and placed them in the
reconstructed village of New Kasaan, and several more were taken by
Natives in Ketchikan, who said their families owned them. In 1970, long
after the area had been abolished, the U. S. Forest Service carried out
salvage work at Old Kasaan under an agreement with the descendents of
Chief Sonihat, who established the village. Alaska Geographic, V,
no. 2 (1978), p. 75.
50. Frank T. Been to Ike P. Taylor, June 19, 1941,
Box 65481, Records of the Alaska Road Commission, RG 30, FARC, Seattle;
Miller, "Inspection of Old Kasaan N.M." When Ernest Gruening visited the
site in 1939, he wrote that the area stood as a "monument to
administrative inefficiency and neglect". Gruening, Many Battles: The
Autobiography of Ernest Gruening (New York: Livenwright, 1973), pp.
258-59.
51. "Alaska Development Program," September 24,
1946, Box 1, Records of. Newton B. Drury, RG 79, N.A.; Conrad L. Wirth
to Asst. Sec. Lewis, March 18, 1954, D18, Alaska Development, R.G.79,
FARC, San Bruno; Interview of George Collins by Frank Williss, November
18, 1983. Dorr C. Yeager to Verne Stapenhorst, August 25, 1955, Old
Kasaan National Monument, Brown Files, ARO.
52. Superintendent's Monthly Report, Mount McKinley
National Park, June 8, 1940, Park Archives, Denali National
Park/Preserve.
53. Annual Report of the Director of the
National Park Service, 1921, p. 38; "Field Notes of Katmai National
Monument, Inspection November 12, 1940"; Hussey, Katmai, pp.
426-27; Superintendent's Monthly Reports, Mt. McKinley National Park,
June 8, 1940, July 1948, and September 1948. In 1940 the Alaska Game
Commission assumed protection operations at Katmai and in 1948 the
United States Fish and Wildlife Service agreed to provide that
service.
54. When President Franklin D. Roosevelt refused to
sign a proclamation establishing "Kennicott National Monument" in the
Wrangell mountains in 1941, he noted that the area already received some
protection by its remote location. Franklin D. Roosevelt to Harold L.
Ickes, January 21, 1941, Park Files, Wrangell-St. Elias National
Park/Preserve, Glenallen, Alaska.
55. The views of Alaskans toward the federal
government is developed in John Hanrahan and Peter Gruenstein, Lost
Frontier: The Marketing of Alaska (New York: W. W. Norton, Co.,
1977), p. 67.
56. In 1947 Alaska Delegate Bartlett introduced a
statehood bill (H.R. 206) that included a provision that would have
placed Sitka and Katmai under state control, and reduced Glacier Bay to
its original size. The reason was quite clearly Bartlett's displeasure
over the Service's failure to undertake any development at Katmai.
Newton B. Drury to Fred Packard, February 12, 1947 and Bartlett to
Packard, February 3, 1947, Katmai, 1/1940-4/30/1953, Box 117, Classified
Files, Records of the Regional Director, RG 79, FARC, San Bruno.
57. When the Interior Department discussed setting
aside Shishaldin Volcano in 1949, Ernest Gruening opposed it on the
grounds that the Service had "done nothing with the areas it has."
Gruening to William E. Warne, Jan. 31, 1949, National Parks and
Monuments, 9-1-13, Records of the Office of Territories, RG 126,
N.A.
58. Interview of George Collins, November 18, 1983;
Annual Report of the Director of the National Park Service, 1946,
in Annual Report of the Secretary of the Interior, 1946, p. 336;
Newton B. Drury to Ernest Gruening, November 4, 1949, Alaska
Development, Box 1, Papers of Newton B. Drury, RG 79, N.A. Collins was
one of the earliest and most influential advocates of an expanded
National Park Service presence in Alaska.
59. Black, "History of Glacier Bay," p. 68; John M.
Holzworth to John F. Kennedy, August 22, 1962, L-58, Admiralty Island,
Records of the Office of the Regional Director, Region 4, FARC, San
Bruno. Holzworth, a recognized expert on the brown bear, led the effort
to establish Admiralty Island as a preserve. This long letter to the
president details that effort. See also Lawrence Rakestraw, History
of the United States Forest Service in Alaska (Anchorage: Alaska
Historical Commission, 1981), pp. 113-16.
60. "Notes on Proposed Glacier Bay National Park,"
February 17, 1932, Monuments, Glacier Bay, part 5, 2/9/1927 - 1/3/1933,
Central Classified Files, RG 79, N.A.; "Report on Glacier Bay National
Park (Proposed), Alaska," December [1938], by John Coffman and Joseph S.
Dixon, 1-9-93, National Parks and Monuments, RG 126, N.A.; '"Report of
an Inspection of Admiralty Island Alaska," July 31, 1942, Admiralty
Island, Proposed National Parks, 0-32, Central Classified Files, RG 79,
N.A. Some, apparently, felt that the results of those reports were
dictated by political considerations rather than by an analysis of the
resources of Admiralty Island. Interview of George Collins, Nov. 18,
1983.
61. Conrad L. Wirth to F.E. Masland, Jr., Feb. 12,
1963, L-58, Admiralty Island, Records of the Office of Regional
Director, Region 4, RG 79, FARC, San Bruno.
62. John M. Holzworth to President Kennedy, August
22, 1963; A Bill to Establish Admiralty Island National Preserve in
the State of Alaska and for other purposes, 95th cong., 1st sess.,
1977.
The addition of 1,000,000 acres to Glacier Bay National Monument in
1939 was, in part, an alternative to establishment of an Admiralty
Island National Park. Black, "Glacier Bay," p. 68; Newton B. Drury to
[_____], January 6, 1947. L-58, Admiralty Island, Proposed National
Parks, Central Classified Files, RG 79, N.A. Additionally, the Bureau of
Sports Fisheries and Wildlife recommended establishment of an Admiralty
Island National Refuge as part of a general evaluation of critical
wildlife habitat in Alaska in 1971. 2050-Admiralty Island, ARO Central
Files, Inactive, ARO.
63. "Brief Chronology of Consideration for adding
Lake George, Alaska to the National Park System," October 3, 1958, L-58,
Proposed AreasLake George, Park Archives, Denali National
Park/Preserve; "Lake George Merits National Park Status," Anchorage
Daily Times, May 10, 1967, State Files, Office of Legislation,
WASO; "National Registry of Natural Landmarks Presentation, Lake George
Alaska," July 26, 1968, Alaska up to Native Claims, Swem Papers.
64. For greater detail on the history of the
Wrangell-Saint Elias mountain region, see Michael Lappen, 'Whose
Promised Land? A History of Conservation and Development Management
Plans for the Wrangell and St. Elias Mountains Regions, Alaska,
1938-1980" (M.A. Thesis, University of California, Santa Barbara,
1984).
65. Rakestraw, Forest Service in Alaska, p.
113; "International Park Proposed Between Alaska and Canada,"
Christian Science Monitor, July 17, 1937, File 0-30, Part 3,
Foreign Parks, Canada, General Classified Files, RG 79, N.A.; Lappen,
"Whose Promised Land," pp. 32-34; Gruening, Many Battles, p. 245.
Gruening, who like many Alaskans, and Americans elsewhere, saw parks as
a way of stimulating the economy of an area, was particularly concerned
here with economic problems that he feared would result from the
impending closure of the Kennicott Copper Mine near McCarthy.
66. "Report on Proposed Alaska National Park,"
September 1, 1938, by John D. Coffman and Harry J. Leik," Park Files,
Wrangell-Saint Elias National Park/Preserve.
67. Gruening to Newton B. Drury, Nov. 8, 1938,
Wrangell-Saint Elias National Park/Preserve files.
68. Franklin D. Roosevelt to Harold L. Ickes,
January 21, 1941, Wrangell-Saint Elias National Park/Preserve files.
69. Lappen, "Whose Promised Land?", pp. 43-44. It
did not kill NPS interest in the area, however.
70. Doris F. Leonard to Theodor R. Swem, Sept. 24,
1970, Historical Files, Wrangell/Saint Elias National Park/Preserve;
Interview of George Collins, Nov. 18, 1983; Data Book, Wrangell-Saint
Elias, vol. 2, Park Files, Wrangell/Saint Elias National Park/Preserve;
USDI, NPS, "Draft Environmental Statement, Proposed Alaska National Park
Alaska," February 10, 1972, History of NPS in Alaska, Swem Papers; USDI,
NPS, Parks for America A Survey of Park and Related Resources in the
Fifty States, and a Preliminary Plan (Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1964),
p. 350; USDI, NPS, Operation Great Land (Washington, D.C.: NPS,
1965), p. 11; "Alaska A Plan for Action," 1966, by Roger Allin Brown
Files, ARO; "The National Park Service Program in Alaska," October 1967,
History of NPS in Alaska, Swem Papers; Wrangell Mountains National
Monument," October 2, 1968, and "St. Elias Range National Monument,"
October 2, 1968, Historical files, Brown Papers, ARO; "Priority of
Alaska Areas," October 2, 1968, CPP-New Area Studies, Alaska State
Files, Office of Legislation, WASO; "Natural Areas in Alaska," July 19,
1971, History of NPS in Alaska, Swem Papers; F.E. Masland, Jr. to George
B. Hartzog, Jr., October 17, 1971, Alaska to Native Claims,
Ibid.
Additionally, other federal agenciesForest Service, Bureau of
Land Management, and Bureau of Outdoor Recreationdeveloped
proposals for the area. See Lappen, "Whose Promised Land?" pp. 61-67,
and "U.S. Forest Service, Recreational Plans, 1971. Maps in Personal
Papers of Bailey O. Breedlove, Division of Reference Services, Library
and Archives, Harpers Ferry Center (HFC), Harpers Ferry, West
Virginia.
71. "Alaska," Undated MS describing NPS interest
areas prior to 1956, Doc. no. 002218, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
72. Superintendent Lilley to Regional Director,
March 19, 1942, File 0-30, Foreign Parks, Canada, part 4,
12/1/38-12/1944, Central Classified Files, RG 79, N.A.
73. "Statement of National Park Service Activities
in Alaska", July 15, 1944, July 1, 1943-June 30, 1944," Alaskan
Development Program, Box 1, Director's Office Files, Drury, 1940-51,
Central Classified Files, RG 79, N.A.; Public Land Order 12, July 20,
1942, Alaska, Roads and Trails, British Columbia-Alaska Highway, 9-1-55,
Classified Files, 1907-51, RG 126, N.A.; T. A. Crerar to Ickes, Dec. 30,
1942, Box 26, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Ickes to Franklin D.
Roosevelt, Jan. 8, 1943, Conservation Zones, 1-9-55, Classified Files,
1907-51, RG 126, N.A.
74. Annual Report of the Director of the
National Park Service, 1943, pp. 214-15; Interview of Alfred C.
Kuehl by Herbert Evison, October 26, 1962, HFC. Conrad L. Wirth, NPS
chief of lands, had general supervision over the project as Chairman of
the Alaska Highway Land Planning Survey Committee.
75. USDI, NPS, Recreational Resources of the
Alaska Highway, and other Roads in Alaska (Washington, D. C.: GPO,
1944), pp. 4-70.
76. Warner W. Gardener to Drury, Dec. 13, 1945,
Alaska Roads & Trails, British Columbia-Alaska Highway, part 9,
9-1-55, Classified Files, 1907-51, RG 126, N.A.
77. Ann Lage, George Collins: The Art and
Politics of Park Planning and Preservation, 1920-1979: An Interview
Conducted by Ann Lage in 1978 and 1979, introduction by
Lowell Sumner, et. al. (Berkeley: University of California Oral
History Project, 1980), p. 177; Interview of Collins, Nov. 18, 1983.
78. USDI, NPS, Alaska Recreation Survey,
Part 1, Vol. 1: Economic Aspects of Recreation in Alaska, by
William J. Stanton (Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1953), p. 1.
79. Annual Report of the Director of the
National Park Service, 1950, in Annual Report of the Secretary of
the Interior, 1950, p. 320; Lage, George Collins, pp. 179-81
.
80. USDI, NPS, Alaska Recreation Survey,
Part 1, vol. 1, Economic Aspects of Recreation in Alaska, by
William J. Stanton; Part 1, Vol. 2; USDI, NPS, Analysis of Alaska
Travel with Special Reference to Tourists, by William J.
Stanton (Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1953); Landscapes of Alaska: Their
Geological Evolution, ed. by Howel Williams (Berkeley: University of
California Press, 1958); Victor Calahane, A Biological Survey of
Katmai National Monument (Washington, D.C.; Smithsonian Institution,
1959); USDI, NPS, Preliminary Geographical Survey of the
Kongakut-Firth River Area, Alaska-Canada, ed. by William C. Carnes
(Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1954); USDI, NPS, Alaska Recreation
Survey, Part 2, Vol 2, A Recreation Program for Alaska
(Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1955).
81. USDI, NPS, Alaska Recreation Survey,
Preliminary Statement, Arctic Wilderness Park (San Francisco: NPS,
1952); George Collins discussed the history of this area in Lage,
George Collins, pp. 188-200.
82. Pearson, Mt. McKinley; Kauffmann,
Katmai; Kauffmann, Glacier Bay; Interview of John
Kauffmann by Frank Williss, December 5, 1983; Typescript, San Francisco,
NPS, 1952; USDI, NPS, Special Study, Alaska History, 1741-1910,
Theme XXI, Political and Military Affairs, 1865-1890, The National
Survey of Historic Sites and Buildings, by Benjamin F. Gilbert and
Charles W. Snell (San Francisco: NPS, 1961). Gilbert provided the
historical background, and Snell surveyed the sites.
83. USDI, NPS, Mission 66: To Provide Adequate
Protection and Development of the National Park System for Human Use
(Washington, D.C.: NPS, 1956), passim. See also, Conrad L. Wirth,
Parks, Politics and the People (Norman: University of Oklahoma
Press, 1980), pp. 237-84.
84. Minutes of the meeting of the Alaska Field
Committee, June 17-18, 1960, Alaska Field Committee, 1/1/1960-3/31/1960,
A 2419, vol. 3, RG 79, FARC, San Bruno, California. Some $205,500 went
to Sitka, $1,823,800 to Glacier Bay, $1,150,000 to Katmai, and
$1,763,900 to Mount Mckinley.
85. USDI, NPS, Mission 66 Progress Report
(Washington, D.C.: NPS, 1966), p. 31; Interview of Richard Stenmark by
Frank Williss, July 26, 1983; Gruening, Many Battles, p. 456;
Superintendent's Monthly Reports, Mount McKinley National Park, May 1963
and December 1964, Park Archives, Denali National Park/Preserve.
86. Mission 66, p. 58; Annual Report of
the Director of the National Park Service, 1960, p. 276;
1961, pp. 363-64; Interview of Theodor R. Swem by Frank Williss,
June 8, 1983. Mr. Swem transferred to the Park Service's Mid-west
Regional Office in 1957 from the Bureau of Reclamation to work on a
Mission 66-sponsored identification of areas for inclusion in the park
system. Similar positions were established in all regions.
87. Interview of Roger Allin, Jan. 21, 1979. Allin
was responsible for preparing state recreation plans for all states
included in the NPS's Western Region. Allin had earlier (1959) completed
a survey of status and needs of recreation lands in Alaska. "The Status
and Need of Recreational Lands in Alaska," by Roger Allin and John F.
Bowles (Anchorage, 1959) and "The Need for Recreation Lands in Alaska,"
by Roger Allin (San Francisco, 1961), Breedlove Papers, HFC.
88. Parks for America, p. 350. Allin did
recommend protection for a large number of areas by the state and local
governments. Many of these would eventually be given protection under
the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act of 1980.
89. USDI, NPS, Investigation Report of
Wood-Tikchik Area, Alaska (Washington, D.C.: NPS, 1965); Interview
of Roger Allin, January 21, 1979; Interview of Theodor R. Swem, June 8,
1983; T. R. Swem to Assistant Director [Ben] Thompson, October 1, 1962,
Alaska up to Native Claims, Swem Papers.
90. Theodor R. Swem, "Outline History of National
Park Service Involvement in Alaska." April 1982, typescript in
possession of author; Interview of Theodor R. Swem, June 8, 1983. Olson,
a well-known author and conservationist, served as a special consultant
on wilderness for both Secretary of the Interior Stewart Udall and NPS
Director Conrad L. Wirth.
91. Interview of Theodor R. Swem, June 8, 1983;
Interview of Richard Stenmark, July 26, 1983; Minutes of the 1963 Annual
Meeting of the Governing Council of the Wilderness Society at Camp
Denali, Mt. McKinley National Park, Alaska, July 1 to July 6, 1963 . .
., Conservationists Involvement in Alaska, TWSthru 1975, Swem
Papers. At this date the Service only had one ranger on duty at
Katmai.
92. John M. Kauffmann to Norman C. Dyhrenfurth,
November 24, 1964, Alaska Travel, Swem and others, Swem Papers;
Interview of John Kauffmann, December 5, 1983; Mission 66 Project
Report, p. 53. The film, "Magnificance in Trust," was a Mission 66
project.
93. [John Kauffmann], "Blind Memo," [1964], copy
provided the author by Mr. Kauffmann. "Cheechako" is an Alaskan name for
newcomer. It is not intended to be endearing.
94. Mission 66 Progress Report, p. 2;
National Park Service Newsletter, December 29, 1966. Hartzog's
"Parkscape USA," was a long-range program designed to cope with
increasing public demand on the national parks, and to meet
responsibilities that President Lyndon B. Johnson called the "new
conservation".
95. Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr. by Frank
Williss, December 7, 1983.
96. Interview of Theodor R. Swem, June 8, 1983;
Interview of George Collins, November 18, 1983; Interview of Stanley
Albright by Frank Williss, June 29, 1984. As a member of the Governing
Council of The Wilderness Society, moreover, Swem had a particular
interest in protection of wilderness areas.
97. George B. Hartzog, Jr. to George L. Collins,
Nov. 13, 1964, Alaska Travel, Swem and others, Swem Papers; Interview of
George Collins Nov. 18, 1983. Similar task forces looked at other areas
in the country.
98. George Collins, who had retired from the Park
Service in 1960, served as chairman. Robert Luntey had worked with
Collins on the Alaska Recreation Survey. Other were Sigurd Olson and
Doris F. Leonard, who was Collins' partner in a private conservation
venture, Conservation Associates. John Kauffmann, who served as
editorial assistant, played a larger part than that title implies.
99. Operation Great Land, PP. 5, 6, 54, 63.
The cost of an adequate NPS role, they estimated, would be a minimum of
$150,000,000 over a ten-year period.
100. T.R. Swem to Assistant Director [Ben]
Thompson, Oct. 1, 1962, Alaska up to Native Claims, Swem Papers;
[Kauffmann], "Blind Memo," [1964].
101. "Alaska, A Plan for Action," 1966, typescript
in Brown Files, ARO. Allin called for establishment of four additional
areas, Wood-Tikchik (recreation area), Saint Elias-Wrangell mountains
(National Park), Alatna region (National Park), and Lake Clark Pass
(National Monument). Other recommendations included establishment of a
NPS "Office of Alaska Affairs," and early attention to the Landmark
Program.
102. U.S. Dept. of Commerce, Federal Field
Committee, Economic Development in Alaska A Report to the
President (Washington D.C.: GPO, 1966). A joint federal-state
committee, the Federal Field Committee was formed to assist the state in
long-range economic planning and development. It grew out of the Federal
Reconstruction and Planning Commission, established to assist in
rebuilding Alaska following the disasterous earthquake of March 27,
1964.
103. George B. Hartzog, Jr. to Robert S. Luntey,
January 21, 1965. ARO, Central Files, Inactive, ARO.
104. National Park Service Newsletter, 3,
no. 21 (Oct. 17, 1968), p. 1; Everhart, National Park Service
(1972), p. 239; USDI, NPS, The National Park Service Program in
Alaska (October 1967), Historical Files, Brown Files, ARO. In 1967 a
contemplated ten-year development program for Alaska included
$10,651,000 for Glacier Bay, $7,810,000 for Katmai, $23,768,000 for Mt.
McKinley, and $367,400 for Sitka.
105. Theodor R. Swem to Ray Freeman and Chet
Brown, June 14, 1966, Inter-office memoranda, sent, Swem Papers.
106. "Trip Report by Stanley A. Cain, Assistant
Secretary for Fish, Wildlife and Parks, Accompanying the Advisory Board
. . . on Field TripJuly 30 to August 10, 1965, in Alaska," Alaska
up to Native Claims, Swem Papers; "Press Conference, August 1, 1965,
Juneau, Alaska, Secretary Stewart Udall, and Governor William A. Egan,"
Ibid.; "Summary Minutes of Meetings held in Alaska on August 4,
1965, August 8, 1965," Ibid.; Interview of Theodor R. Swem, June
8, 1983; Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr., Dec. 7, 1983. The presence
of Secretary Udall for a part of the trip was an unexpected bonus. His
trip undoubtedly contributed to his interest in the state and in
establishing additional areas there.
107. Theodor R. Swem to George B. Hartzog, Jr.,
March 20, 1964, Alaska up to Native Claims, Swem Papers; Governor's
Briefing Book; October 10, 1967, Historical Files, Brown Files, ARO;
Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr., December 7, 1983; Interview of
Theodor R. Swem, June 8, 1983. The meeting was set up by Joseph
Fitzgerald, chairman of the Federal Field Committee for Development
Planning in Alaska.
108. Entry of Aug. 8, 1965, Swem Diary, Swem
Papers; Theodor Swem to George B. Hartzog, Jr., Sept. 21, 1965,
Follow-up slips, sent, Ibid.; Swem to William J. Briggle, Nov.
18, 1965, Personal Correspondence, Ibid.; Swem to Regional
Director, April 13, 1966, Alaska up to Native Claims, Ibid.;
Interview of Merrill Mattes by Frank Williss, June 21, 1983; Interview
of Bailey O. Breedlove by Frank Williss, Nov. 10, 1983. Smith was ill,
and died a short while later.
109. Swem to Senator Bartlett, Dec. 20, 1966, New
Area Studies, 1966-1967, Alaska State Files, Office of Legislation,
WASO; Harthon L. Bill to Regional Director, Western Region, May 25,
1967, Alaska Up to Native Claims, Swem Papers; Interview of Merrill
Mattes, June 21, 1983; Interview of Bailey Breedlove, November 10, 1983.
In the winter the superintendent of Mt. McKinley was in the Anchorage
Office as well.
110. Bill to Director, Western Region, May 25,
1967; Alaska News Review, February 16, 1970; National Park
Service Newsletter, vol. 6, no. 17, August 21, 1971; Anchorage Daily
Times, March 31, 1972, Robert Belous Clipping Files, Special
Collections Division, Denver Public Library (DPL). Although the Pacific
Northwest Regional Office had been established in early 1970, it was not
fully staffed until 1971 . In 1972 the Service established the position
of state director for Alaska, located in Anchorage. The state director
(Stanley T. Albright) had administrative control of all NPS affairs in
Alaska, save planning under the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act.
Under a 1975 reorganization, the Alaska Area Office assumed control of
that function.
111. John Rutter to George Hall, July 26, 1967,
L7019-General, ARO Central Files-Inactive, ARO. The state coordinator
program was a nationwide one. In terms of operation, superintendents of
Glacier Bay and Sitka had full responsibility for their areas.
112. Glen T. Been to Regional Director, Western
Region, June 19, 1967, Historical FilesOld Kasaan, Brown Files,
ARO; Harry B. Robinson to Bailey Breedlove and Richard Praesil, August
12, 1969, Historical FilesKobuk-Koyukuk, Ibid.; "Suggested
Program for Alaska submitted by the Park Planner for the Alaska Field
Office for 1967-1968 Calendar Years," October 1967, Alaska up to Native
Claims, Swem Papers; Interview of Merrill Mattes, June 21, 1983; Robert
S. Luntey to Bailey Breedlove, April 24, 1969, Historical Files-Alaska
General, Brown Files, ARO.
113. USDI, NPS, The Island of Attu Alaska: A
Study of Alternatives (San Francisco: NPS, 1968).
114. USDI, NPS, "A Master Plan for Mount Mckinley
National Park" (San Francisco: NPS, 1969 [draft], p. 46. The report was
never signed, but in May 1969, Representative John Saylor introduced
H.R. 11424, a bill that included the recommended changes. Ibid.,
Appendix B. Illustration 3 is a map showing the proposed additions.
Adolph Murie, whose work Wolves of Mt. McKinley (1944) remains a
classic, had long recommended boundary adjustments and in 1965 a chapter
of the Pioneers of Alaska recommended a 2,500-square mile boundary
extension. Murie, "An Important North Boundary Adjustment," undated MS
[1965], and Igloo no. 4, Pioneers of Alaska to Stewart Udall, September
20, 1965, L1417, Acquisition and Disposal of Lands, Park Files, Denali
National Park/Preserve.
15. USDI, NPS, Special Report on a
Reconnaissance of the Upper Kokuk-Koukuk Region Brooks Range, Northern
Alaska (San Francisco: NPS Office of Resource Planning], 1969), p.
32. The name suggested by Mattes"Gates of the Arctic"had
been, of course, coined originally by Robert Marshall, who explored and
did much to publicize the area. The term applies to two mountains along
the North Fork of the Koyukuk River.
116. Interview of Merrill Mattes June 21, 1983;
"Master Plan Brief for Katmai National Monument," 1967; USDI, NPS A
Master Plan for Proposed Old Kodiak National Memorial (San
Francisco: NPS, 1967); USDI, NPS, Alaska Cultural Complex A
Reconnaissance Report (San Francisco: NPS , 1969); Theodor Swem to
Russell Dickinson, May 11, 1967, follow-up slips, sent, Swem Papers;
Robert S. Luntey to District Director, Northwest District, July 15,
1969, Breedlove Papers, HFC; Interview of John Rutter by Frank Williss,
May 16, 1984.
117. Richard Prasil to Regional Director, Western
Region, June 6, 1966, Historical Files-Alaska General, Brown Files,
ARO.
118. Ibid; "National Landmark Studies,"
ANILCA Proposals, Natural Landmark Studies - Non-Park Service, Park
Files, Denali National Park/Preserve. Evaluation of the volcanic sites
were published as part of a nation-wide study, USDI, NPS, The Works
of Volcanism: Sites >Recommended as Potential Natural Landmarks, by
Robert H. Rose (Washington, D.C.: NPS, 1977).
119. Telephone Interview of Frank Ugolini, by
Frank Williss, June 23, 1983; "Establishment of Natural Landmarks and
New Units of the National Park System," undated MS, Natural Landmarks
Briefs, Library, Rocky Mountain Regional Office, Denver.
120. USDI, NPS, The arctic lowland region:
natural potential landform and lifeform national landmarks, by
Robert L. Detterman Washington, D.C.: NPS, 1977). Volcanic studies, as
mentioned, would be published as part of a nation-wide survey in
1977.
121. Federal Register, vol. 48, no. 4,
(March 1, 1983), pp. 8682-683; Interview of Theodor R. Swem, June 8,
1983; Interview of Richard Stenmark, July 26, 1983. Important in this
effort, too, would be knowledge of historical and archeological areas
identified by Charles Snell and Arthur A. Woodward in 1961.
122. United States Department of the Interior,
Press Release, June 27, 1969, Alaska National Parks Study Committee,
Swem Papers; Interview of Richard Stenmark, July 26, 1983; Stenmark to
Co-chairman/Files, August 31, 1977, L-48, Director of Professional
Services, Box 17, Alaska Task Force Files, FARC, Seattle; Ronald
Remykoff, "Preliminary Report, Alaska Parks and Monuments Advisory
Committee, Final Draft," undated report in APA-MAC Preliminary Report,
Richard Stenmark Files, HFC; "Proposals and Potential Areas in Alaska
for Study and Review," September 15, 1970, Alaska up to Native Claims,
Swem Papers. The Advisory Committee itself had no impact, and in fact,
never held a meeting. However, Stenmark's work would be an important
contribution to the Service's knowledge of Alaska.
123. Ernest J. Borgman to Director, Pacific
Northwest Region, January 21, 1971, Stenmark Files, HFC. The Park
Service was the lead agency in preparing the recreation and tourism
section of the land use chapter of the two-volume report, published in
1971 . Alaska Recreation and Tourism Resources, Land Use Chapter,
"Interim Economic Development Plan for Alaska", prepared for the Federal
Field Committee for Development Planning in Alaska by the Alaska Office,
NPS, February 5, 1971, Xerox copy in Technical Information Center,
Denver Service Center.
124. "National Park System Alaska Plan, Summary,"
November 17, 1971, Exhibit 48-a, Cook Inlet Lawsuit Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; USDI, NPS, National Park System Plan, 2 vols.
(Washington, D. C. GPO, 1970). The studies were done in accordance with
Secretary of the Interior Stewart Udall's Policy Guidelines for National
Park Service, June 18, 1969. The National Park System Plan
divided the system into historical and natural areas. Each category was
sub-divided into themes. It was hoped that this would provide for a more
orderly "rounding out" of the National Park System.
125. Press Conference, August 1, 1965, Juneau,
Alaska, Secretary Stewart Udall and Governor William A. Egan, Alaska up
to Native Claims, Swem Papers; Lewis A. [Sigler] to Senator Ernest
Gruening, February 14, 1967, W-38, Legislative Support Data, Glacier
Bay, ARO Central Files, Inactive, ARO; Richard Stenmark to
Co-chairman/Files, L-58, Division of Professional Services File, Box 17,
Alaska Task Force Files, FARO, Seattle; "Alaska," undated MS, document
002262, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Robert J. Branges to Files, April 30, 1969,
Alaska to Native Claims, Swem Papers; U.S. Congress, House, A Bill to
provide for the addition of certain lands to the Mount McKinley National
Park in the state of Alaska and for other purposes, H.R. 11424, 91st
Cong., 1st sess., 1969; and H.R. 11423, A Bill to Establish Gates of
the Arctic National Park . . .
126. Theodor R. Swem to James Hamilton, June 23,
1969, Alaska up to Native Claims, Swem Papers; Swem to James Hamilton,
June 23, 1969, Ibid; Whitehorse Star, Sept. 4, 1969,
Skagway through 1970, Park Files, Klondike National Historical Park,
Skagway, Alaska; "Outline of Program for Possible International Historic
Park in Alaska, British Columbia and Yukon Territory" confidential MS,
September 4, 1969, Xerox provided author by Theodor Swem. Sigard Olson
had mentioned a park in Skagway as early as 1963 and had lobbied with
the Secretary's Advisory Board since then to gain their support for such
a project.
127. Interview of Theodor R. Swem, June 8, 1983;
Russell E. Train to Secretary of Interior, September 15, 1969, Alaska up
to Native Claims, Swem Papers; Draft of letter to Speaker of the House,
January 28, 1972, Ibid.; George B. Hartzog, Jr. to Secretary of
the Interior, January 14, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, 1971-April 1972,
Ibid.; Department of State Briefing Papers, April 1972,
Ibid.; USDI, NPS, A Conceptual Master Plan (modified) for the
Proposed Alaska National Park (Denver: NPS, 1972). (Illustration 5 is a map of the proposed
park). The story of the proposed Alaska National Park is a fascinating
one, far too complex to be studied here. Hopefully, it will be examined
in depth at a future date.
128. Information on this complex series of events
is examined in USDI, NPS, "History of the Johnson Proclamations,
1968-69," by James A. Husted, Sept. 9, 1970, Alaska to Native Claims,
Swem Papers and Box 39, WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; "Five Versions:
Why LBJ Changed His Mind on Parks," Washington, D.C., Evening
Star, Jan. 27, 1969; Robert Cahn, "How National Park Plan Slipped
Away," Christian Science Monitor, Jan. 23, 1969, pp. 1-4; John P.
Crevelli, "The Final Act of the Greatest Conservation President,"
Prologue: The Journal of the National Archives VII (Winter 1980),
pp. 173-84; Interview of Theodor R. Swem June 8, 1983; Interview of
George B. Hartzog, Jr., Dec. 7, 1983.
129. Crevelli, "Greatest Conservation President,"
p. 176; Stewart Udall to Solicitor, Acting Assistant Secretary Clarence
Pautzke, and Director Hartzog, September 4, 1968. Quoted in Husted,
"Johnson Proclamations." p. l.
130. Husted, "Johnson Proclamations," p. 1 . The
original six Alaska areas proposed were Mount McKinley (lands adjacent
to park), Wrangell Mountains, St. Elias Range, Lake Clark, Gates of the
Arctic, and St. Lawrence Island. Other areas later considered were
additions to Katmai National Monument and the Wood-Tikchik area.
131. Husted, "History of the Johnson
Proclamations," pp. 15, 12; Interview of Theodor R. Swem, June 8, 1983.
The name, "Gates of the Arctic," not the resources in the area,
determined the configuration of that proposed monument. Accepting BLM
objections to the east unit, Secretary Udall decided on a single-unit
monument (west unit). When he learned that the geological formation
bearing that name was in the east unit, he reversed himself in order to
name the area "Gates of the Arctic." Otherwise the proposal would have
been a one-unit Arctic Circle National Monument.
132. So sure were Park Service officials that the
president would sign all seven proclamations they had mailed press
releases and information packets to all Park Service units and offices
on January 18. The next day Theodor Swem called each one telling them to
hold the material. A second call went out the following day instructing
each office to destroy the material, unopened. Husted, "Johnson
Proclamations," p. 15; Interview of Theodor R. Swem, June 8, 1983.
133. These are reasons given by authors listed in
footnote 128. George Hartzog accepts the last reason, on the basis of
discussion he had with Wayne Aspinall shortly thereafter. Interview of
George B. Hartzog, Jr., December 7, 1983.
134. Husted, "Johnson Proclamation," p. 15;
Crevelli, "Greatest Conservation President," p. 104. President Johnson
had already dressed for the inauguration when he signed the
proclamations. The Service had been interested in an extension to Katmai
that would have included Naknek Lake for some time. "Recommendations for
Boundary Revision, Katmai National Monument," by Lowell Sumner, October
21, 1952, HFC; George B. Hartzog to Walter J. Hickel, December 7, 1967,
Alaska up to Native Claims, Swem Papers.
Chapter
Two
1. PL 96-487, Dec. 2, 1980; "Alaska Summary, PL
96-487," January 26, 1981, Doc. 02686, ANILCA Papers, Law Library.
2. Mary Clay Berry, The Alaska Pipeline: The
Politics of Oil and Native Land Claims (Bloomington: University of
Indiana Press, 1975), pp. 29-30; Everhart, National Park Service,
pp. 252-54.
3. PL 85-508, July 7, 1958; Berry, Alaska
Pipeline, p. 27. Had Congress applied the formula used for other
western states--1,290 acres out of each township of the public domain
for the support of schools, Alaska would have received about 2,000,000
acres.
4. By the way of comparison, Montana received 10
percent of the public domain in its borders, Arizona 15.6 percent, New
Mexico 16.43 percent, Nevada 3.8 percent, Utah 13.8 percent, and
Colorado 16.43 percent. "Land granted to states from the public domain,"
January 7, 1975, Background Briefs, Harry Crandell Papers, Conservation
Library, Denver Public Library.
5. PL 85-508, July 7, 1958; Berry, Alaska
Pipeline, p. 28. Other states received 37.5 percent of the revenues.
The federal government received 10 percent, and the remainder (52.5
percent) went to the federal reclamation fund. Since Alaska is not a
reclamation state, the state received ninety percent of the mineral
lease revenues.
6. Robert D. Arnold, et al., Alaska Native
Land Claims (Anchorage: Alaska Native Foundation, 19), p. 94.
7. Quoted in Ibid., p. 103. A bill to settle
Native claims to the land had been introduced as early as 1940.
8. Barry, Alaska Pipeline, p. 31. Natives
later won compensatory payment from the United States in one of those
cases--the Tlingit-Haida case.
9. P.L. 85-508.
10. Lappan, "Whose Promised Land?", p. 51.
11. John V. Krutilla and Sterling Brubaker,
Alaska National Interest Lands and Their Opportunity Costs
(Washington, D.C.: Resources for Future, 1976), p. 3; "Brief Chronology
of Events Related to State Selections," February 14, 1978, Box 14,
Papers of the Alaska Coalition, Conservation Library, Denver Public
Library; State of Alaska, Department of Natural Resources, "Alaska State
Land Selection Program, Its History and Guidelines," May 15, 1978, Box
7, Albert Henson Papers, Conservation Library, Denver Public Library.
Less than 5,000,000 acres had been patented to the state by the end of
the decade.
12. RWA [Roger Allin], "Note," December 18, 1961,
Breedlove Papers, HFC; Berry, Alaska Pipeline, p. 33; Arnold,
Native Land Claims, pp. 100-101.
13. Berry, Alaska Pipeline, p. 43.
14. Arnold, Native Land Claims, pp.
94-95.
15. Quoted in Lappen, "Whose Promised Land?" p.
68.
16. The story of the organization of Alaskan
Natives, which is a remarkable one, is told in Arnold, Native Land
Claims.
17. Arnold, Native Land Claims, p. 102.
18. Ibid., p. 103; [Philleo] Nash to
Legislative Council, May 10, 1963, ANILCA before 1969, Rights Protection
Division, Bureau of Indian Affairs, USDI. The latter is a draft of a
bill similar in most respects to the recommendations of Secretary
Udall's Task Force. The bill, unlike the report, included guarantees for
mineral rights on lands for which the Natives would have assumed title,
and would have given them cause for action in the U.S. District Courts
"for the value of rights and occupancy of which they have been deprived
by laws of the United States."
19. Berry, Alaska Pipeline, pp. 49, 61;
Arnold, Native Land Claims, pp. 117, 125. Secretary Udall
formalized the 'freeze' in Public Land Order 4582 on February 17, 1969.
Federal Register, 34 (January 23, 1969), p. 1045.
When Walter J. Hickel, who as Governor of Alaska had vociferously
opposed Udall's action, was nominated as Secretary of the Interior, he
intimated he would overturn the "freeze," saying, "what Udall can do by
executive order I can undo." To gain support of Natives and
conservationists for his nomination, however, he promised to retain the
freeze. It was extended on Dec. 7, 1970 (Public Land Order 4962), June
24, 1971 (Public Land Order 5081), and December 7, 1971 (Public Land
Order 5146).
20. Arnold, Native Land Claims, p. 119.
21. Memo to Commissioner Bennett, Irving Senzel,
Frank Hutchinson, July 26, 1971, ANILCA before 1969, Rights Protection
Division, BIA, USDI.
22. Arnold, Native Land Claims p. 119.
23. John McPhee, Coming into the Country (New
York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1977), p. 152; Quoted in Arnold,
Native Land Claims, p. 136.
24. Hanrahan and Gruenstein, Marketing of
Alaska, p. 95; State of Alaska, Legislative Affairs Agency,
Alaska National Interest (D-2) Lands A History and Review of
Legislation, (Juneau: Legislative Affairs Agency, 1977), p. 1. In
1970 a federal district court judge ruled that the pipeline could not be
laid across the Yukon River Valley until the land claims of the Natives
there were satisfied.
25. Minutes of the 1963 Annual Meeting of the
Council of the Wilderness Society at Camp Denali . . . July 1 to 6, 1963
. . ., Conservationists Involvement with AlaskaTWS thru 1975, Swem
Papers.
26. Robert Cahn, The Fight to save Wild
Alaska (Washington D.C.: The Audubon Society, 1982), p. 10;
Interview of Bailey Breedlove, November 10, 1983; Interview of David
Hickock by Frank Williss, November 10, 1983; Interview of Celia Hunter
by Frank Williss, November 7, 1983; Statement of Mark Ganapole, in U.S.
Congress, House, Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, Subcommittee
on General Oversight and Alaska Lands, Inclusion of Alaska Lands in
National Park, Forest, Wildlife Refuge, and Wild and Scenic Rivers
Systems, Hearings on H.R. 39, et al., 95th Cong., 1st
sess., August 12, 1977, XI:100-103. The group, which met evenings and
weekends at the urging of Mark Ganapole (now Mrs. David Hickock), called
themselves the "The Living Room Floor Map and Debating Society."
One area that the Alaska Wilderness Council recommended was a
7,767,600-acre park in the Brooks Range. "Gates of the Arctic National
Park A Proposal for a National Park in the Brooks Range," 1971,
A58-GAAR, ARO Central Files, Inactive, ARO.
227. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 10; Edgar Wayburn
to George B. Hartzog, Jr., August 10, 1970, Alaska up to Native Claims,
Swem Papers; Telephone Interview Doug Scott by Frank Williss, May 10,
1984.
When the Sierra Club presented its suggestions for
possible national monuments to the Interior Department in 1968, the
twenty-seven potential areas included none in Alaska. Husted, "History
of the Johnson Proclamations," p. 7.
228. Wilderness Report, VI (September 15,
1969), Historical FilesOld Kasaan, Brown Files, ARC; Interview of
Celia Hunter, November 7, 1983; Interview of Merrill Mattes, June 21,
1983; untitled MS by Richard J. Gordon, March 12, 1969, ARC Central
Files - Inactive ARO. Gordon recommended among other things, a two-unit
park of 8,600 square miles (approximately 5,504,000 acres) in the Brooks
Range that would become the first preserve in the National Park
System.
Mattes, who was in Fairbanks when news of discovery of oil on the
North Slope was announced, remembers discussing with his collegues that
preservation of wilderness areas would be more urgent than ever.
229. Interview of Celia Hunter, November 7, 1983;
Interview of David Hickock, November 10, 1983; Interview of Chuck Clusen
by Frank Williss, December 6, 1983.
30. Jack Hessian, "D-2 Lands Originated with
Federal Field Committee," September 17, 1974, Alaska Regional Office
Clipping File, Special Collections Division, DPL; Interview of David
Hickock, Nov. 10, 1983.
31. Federal Field Committee Economic Development
in Alaska, p. 27. Similar sentiments were at least implied in the
Committee's 1968 report, Alaska Natives and the Land (Washington,
D.C.: GPO, 1968), prepared by the committee at the request of the Senate
Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs for use in Congressional
deliberations on Alaska Native claims.
32. Interview of David Hickock, November 10,
1983.
33. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 11; Interview of
David Hickock, November 10, 1983. Cahn indicates that Hickock wrote the
provision in 1970. However, Hickcock said that the date was 1969.
Whatever the year, it was not included in the bill as introduced on
April 15, 1969. U.S., Congress, Senate, A Bill to provide for the
settlement of certain land claims of Alaska Natives, and for other
purposes, S. 1830, 91st Cong., 1st sess, 1969.
34. Congressional Record, Senate, January
15, 1970, p. 24424.
35. Mary Berry offers a fascinating view of events
in the House committee during the final days. Alaska Pipeline,
pp. 134-37.
36. George Alderson (for the Alaska Coalition) to
Dear Senator, October 28, 1971, form letter in support of an amendment
proposed by Senator Alan Bible, H.R. 10367 (S 35), Legislative Files,
Papers of Alan Bible, Special Collections Library, University of
Nevada-Reno, Reno, Nevada; Statement of Dr. Edgar Wayburn, in U.S.,
Congress, Senate, Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, Alaska
National Interest Lands, Hearings on S. 1687 . . . et al., 94th
Cong., 1st sess., 1975, p. 191.
Organizations listed in the Alderson letter were Environmental
Action, Friends of the Earth, the Wilderness Society, National Wildlife
Federation, Sierra Club, Zero Population Growth, Alaska Action
Committee, and Trout Unlimited. Dr. Wayburn listed the Alaska
Conservation Society, Alaska Wilderness Council, Alaska Center for the
Environment in Anchorage, Fairbanks Environmental Center, National
Audubon Society, National Parks and Conservation Association, Defenders
of Wildlife, Friends of the Earth, American Rivers Conservation Council,
Wilderness Society, and Sierra Club.
37. "Statement on H.R. 3100 and Related Bills to
Provide for Settlement of Certain Land Claims of Alaska Natives by
Stewart M. Brandborg, House Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs,
May 3, 1971," Conservationists Involvement in AlaskaTWS Thru 1975,
Swem Papers; U.S., Congress, House, Committee on Interior and Insular
Affairs, To Provide for the Settlement of Certain Land Claims of
Alaska Natives, Hearings on H.R. 3100, H.R. 7038, H.R. 7432, 93rd
Cong., 1st sess., May 1971, pp. 335-41; Berry, Alaska Pipeline,
p. 166; Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 11; Telephone Discussion with Harry
Crandell, March 20, 1984.
Congressman John Dingell, moreover, asked the Bureau of Sports
Fisheries and Wildlife to develop "an optimum refuge system for Alaska,"
and that bureau had undertaken an effort to inventory and document
waterfowl and wildlife areas in the state. Congressman Wayne Aspinall
opposed Dingell's efforts. "Notes on Meeting with Congressman John
Dingell and Legislative Committee Counsel Ned Everett--October 28,
1971," Fish and Wildlife Service, Swem Papers; Gordon Watson to All
Project Leaders, June 4, 1971, Ibid.; R.L. Means, "Materials
transmitted to Aspinall", October 19, 1971, Ibid.
38. U.S., Congress, House, Hearings on H.R.
39, . . ., 1977, V: 16.
39. Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr., December
7, 1983; Interview of Richard Stenmark, July 26, 1983. Hartzog had
intended to go to Alaska in any case, at the urging of staff of the
Alaska Office.
40. Trip Itinerary, August 7-22, 1971, "H.R. 10367
(S. 35), Amendment to Alaska Native Claims Settlement for review by
Secretary of the Interior, of classified and public lands," Legislative
Files, Bible Papers; Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr., December 10,
1983; Interview of John Rutter, May 16, 1984. Pacific Northwest Regional
Director Rutter, and Sierra Club President Edgar Wayburn traveled with
the group for a time, as did Deputy Director Thomas Flynn.
41. Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr., December
7, 1983; Theodor R. Swem, Personal Notes, January 18 and 27, 1972, Swem
Papers; George B. Hartzog, Jr. to Rogers C. B. Morton, March 6, 1972,
ANCSA Implementation, 1971-April 1972, Swem Papers; George B. Hartzog,
Jr. to Nathaniel P. Reed, November 22, 1971, Ibid; Interview of
John Cook by Frank Williss, January 26, 1984. Mr. Cook, who received his
information from a discussion with Senator Bible, substantiated Mr.
Hartzog's account.
42. Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr., December
7, 1983; Hartzog to Assistant Secretary for Fish, Wildlife, and Parks,
November 22, 1971, ANCSA Implementation, 1971-April 1972, Swem Papers;
Hartzog to Rogers C.B. Morton, March 6, 1972, Ibid.; Interview of
Harry Crandell by Frank Williss, December 7, 1983; "Potential National
Parks and Monuments in Alaska," undated map in Swem Papers; Diary of
Theodor R. Swem, entries for November 15 and 19, 1971, Swem Papers. The
map, which is included as Illustration 3 was prepared for Mr. Hartzog's
use between November 15 and 19, 1971.
43. Bernard R. Meyer to Director, August 26, 1971,
L-58-170 (N), Alaska State Files, Office of Legislation, WASO. This
memo, which explained what actions the secretary could take to implement
Hartzog's suggestion, described the August 14 memorandum.
44. Information given by Mr. Hartzog to Edwin C.
Bearss, Chief Historian, National Park Service; Interview of Theodor R.
Swem, June 8, 1983. Apparently, for some unexplained reason, two
different versions of an amendment were prepared. No copy of either was
found.
45. Comments by Senator Bible on amendment to S.
35, Congressional Record, Senate, November 1, 1971, p. 38451;
Telephone discussion with Harry Crandell, March 20, 1984; Cahn, Wild
Alaska, p. 11; Telephone Interview of Doug Scott, May 10, 1984.
Wayburn, who approached Senator Bible after the September 1971 Sierra
Club Biannual Wilderness Conference, had traveled for a time with
Senator Bible and George Hartzog in Alaska in August.
46. Material consulted, as well as individuals
contacted did not provide a definitive answer to this question. Among
those contacted were George Hartzog, Thomas Flynn, Theodor Swem, James
M. Lambe, Doug Scott, Senator Bible, and three former congressional
staff membersBill Van Ness, Roy Whitacre, and Dwight Dyer.
One version of the events suggests that Park Service
staff prepared a draft amendment, but did not give it to Senator Bible
when it was learned that the conservation community had previously
submitted one. It has not been possible to confirm this version.
47. Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr., December
7, 1983; Personal Notes of Theodor Swem, January 18 and 27, March 9,
1972; Hartzog to Rogers C.B. Morton, March 6, 1972, ANCSA
Implementation, 1971-April 1972, Swem Papers.
48. Congressional Record, Senate, November
1, 1971, p. 38453. Director Hartzog and Senator Bible visited all three
areas the previous >August.
49. Congressional Record, Senate, December
14, 1971, p. 2156.
50. Virtually everyone has agreed that Senator
Bible's amendment was directly related to the trip. See, for example,
comments by Morris Udall, Congressional Record, House, December
13, 1971, p. 12462; Comments by Henry Jackson, Congressional
Record, Senate, December 14, 1971; and comments by Ted Stevens,
Congressional Record, Senate, November 1, 1971, p. 38453.
51 . "Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act, Public
Law 92-203, December 18, 1973," by Robert E. Price, January 13, 1972,
ANCSA, Box 20, Alaska Task Force Files, FARC, Seattle.
52. Berry, Alaska Pipeline, p. 185;
Telephone discussion with Paul Kirton, April 27, 1983; U.S., Congress,
House, Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, Providing for
the Settlement of Land Claims of Alaska Natives: Report Together with
a Dissenting View to Accompany HR 10367, 92d Cong., 1st sess.,
September 28, 1971. The committee accepted arguments that the provision
was not germane, and defeated it by a vote of 26-10.
53. The Kyl amendment excluded Native and state
selections, as well as land for the oil pipeline from Prudhoe Bay to
Valdez. Berry, Alaska Pipeline, p. 186; Congressional
Record, House, October 20, 1971, p. 37075.
54. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 12; Interview of
Harry Crandell by Frank Williss, December 7, 1983; Interview of Chuck
Clusen, December 6, 1983; Interview of David Hickock, November 10, 1983.
There is some disagreement as to the amount of land agreed upon at the
meeting. Cahn indicates that Udall decided upon 100,000,000 million
acres, 50,000,000 less than that proposed by Stewart Brandborg. Dave
Hickock recalls that an 80,000,000-acre figure was reached at that
time.
Regardless, negotiations between Udall and Saylor regarding the
amount would follow. After these negotiations, 100,000,000 acres was the
agreed upon amount. Telephone interview of Doug Scott, May 11, 1984.
Scott acted as a go-between in the negotiations between Udall and
Saylor.
55. U.S., Congress, House, A Bill to Provide for
the Settlement of Certain Land Claims of Alaska Natives, and for Other
Purposes, H.R. 11254, 92d Cong., 1st sess., 1971; Congressional
Record, House, October 14, 1971, pp. 36267, 36270; October 20, 1971,
p. 37075.
56. Ibid. Among the areas previously
classified were Rampart Dam withdrawal, Naval Petroleum Reserve
Numbered 4, Copper River classification, Iliamna Classification, and
proposed Brooks Range classification. The last three were classified for
multiple-use under the Classification and Multiple Use Act of 1964
(which expired December 23, 1970). The classifications placed
restrictions on the lands and removed them from operation of certain of
the public land laws. George Turcott to Asst. SecretaryPLM,
January 28, 1972, 2300 (320) ANCSA, Records of the Bureau of Land
Management, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
It must be made clear, however, that Representative Udall intended
that the overwhelming majority of lands would go to Park, Refuge, and
Wild and Scenic Rivers systems.
57. Congressional Record, House, October 20,
1975, p. 37076. Congressman Nick Begich of Alaska insisted that the
total area included was 130,000,000 acres.
58. Congressional Record, House, October 20,
1971, p. 37076.
59. Telephone Interview of Doug Scott, May 11,
1984; Interview of A. Durand Jones by Frank Williss, May 15, 1984.
60. Berry, Alaska Pipeline, p. 194;
Telephone Interview of Doug Scott, May 11, 1984.
61. Congressional Record, Senate, November
1, 1971, p. 38451.
62. Ibid.
63. Ibid.
64. Congressional Record, Senate, November
1, 1971, Pp. 38457-453; Arnold, Native Land Claims, p. 145.
65. Berry, Alaska Pipeline, pp. 210-11;
Statement of Senator Ted Stevens, Hearings on HR 39, et.
al., 1977, I: 116-17; Conference Report to accompany H.R.
10567, p. 34; Telephone discussion with Harry Crandell, March 20,
1984. Efforts to examine the notes kept by the House conferees have been
fruitless. Information from staff at the National Archives indicates
that Senate Conferees kept no notes.
Interestingly, the 80,000,000-acre figure agreed upon is the same as
that George Hartzog and Senator Bible discussed when they returned from
Alaska in August.
66. Morris Udall and John Saylor to Rogers C.B.
Morton, January 11, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, 1971-April 1972. This
view was accepted by the Interior Department. Swem Papers; Conference
Report to accompany H.R. 10367, pp. 44-46; Berry, Alaska
Pipeline, pp. 210-11. Senator Bible's amendment, it should be noted,
included no limit on the amount of land that could be withdrawn for
study.
67. Telephone Interview of Harry Crandell, December
7, 1983; Interview of Dave Hickock, November 10, 1983; Congressional
Record, House, October 20, 1971, pp. 33076; "Senator Ted Stevens s
comments at Alaska Proposals Briefing, November 8, 1973."
ANCSA-Implementation, 1974, Swem Papers.
68. Senator Lee Metcalf once said in a moment of
exasperation, "That was a lawsuit we wrote." Quoted in Hanrahan and
Gruenstein, Marketing of Alaska, p. 100.
69. P.L. 92-203, Dec. 18, 1971; Frank A. Bracken to
Secretary [of the Interior], Dec. 29, 1971, Alaska Native Claims
Settlement Act, Swem Papers; Paul Kirton, "Summary of Questions and
Answers Concerning Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act," undated [19721
MS in Ibid. The $962,500,000 would come from Congressional
appropriations ($462,500,000 over an eleven-year-period), and mineral
revenues from state and federal lands ($500,000,000).
70. Arnold, Native Claims, p. 153; Dean F.
Olson, "Native Land and CapitalAn Initial Inquiry into Alaska
Native Land Claims Settlement Act Corporation," undated MS in File
A-22-Ahtna, Mount McKinley Keyman Files, Box 31, Alaska Task Force
Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle. The corporation concept was first proposed
in a bill prepared by Governor Hickel's Task Force in 1978.
71. The 14(h)(1) provision is discussed in chapter
5. See also Melody W. Grauman "The ANCSA 14 (h)(1) Program," CRM
Bulletin vol. 3 (Sept. 1979) pp. 4-5.
72. Conference Report to Accompany HR 10367,
p. 3.
73. Ibid; "Remarks of Jack Horton . . ., September
28, 1972," A-94-FSLUPC, Box 5, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle. One of the four appointed by the governor had to be an Alaska
Native.
74. PL 92-203, December 18, 1971; Conference
Report to Accompany H.R. 10367, p. 44. Berry, Alaska
Pipeline, p. 211-12.
Chapter
Three
1. Quoted by Undersecretary William Pecora at the
first Interior Department meeting regarding ANCSA implementation.
Personal notes of Theodor R. Swem, December 22, 1971, Swem Papers;
Robert Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 12.
The quote may well be apocryphal. If Secretary Morton did not say it,
he should have, for the slogan, or some variety of it, became a symbol
in the effort to secure passage of an Alaska National Interest Lands
Act.
2. Swem, Personal Notes, December 22, 1971 .
Legislative staff in the department and in the several bureaus had
followed the progress of the legislation, and had helped, from time to
time, in drafting portions of it.
3. Reed to Hartzog and Spencer Smith, confidential
memo, December 21, 1971, ANCSA Implementation, 1971 - April 1972, Swem
Papers. Two days later the reporting date had been moved forward to
"early January." Theodor R. Swem to Assistant Director, Legislation,
et al., December 23, 1971, Ibid.
4. Swem to Assistant Director, Legislation,
et al., December 23, 1971, ANCSA Implementation,
1971-April 1972, Swem Papers; Swem, Personal Notes, January 27, 1971;
Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr., December 7, 1983; F.V. Schmidt to
Alaska Area Director [BSF&W], December 22, 1971, ANCSA
Implementation, 1971-April 1972, Swem Papers. >At this point, Swem
believed that the job would be a short-term one that would last only
through March.
5. The Bureau of Outdoor Recreation did not
participate in identifying areas at this stage. The Forest Service
proposed withdrawing 79,175,000 acres for study as multiple-use land and
an additional 1,500,000 acres for "ecological reserves" on February 3.
However, the Interior Department chose to accept the arguments of
Representatives Morris Udall and John Saylor that the 80,000,000 acres
described in the d-2 provision were intended primarily for additions to
the National Park, Wildlife Refuge, and Wild and Scenic Rivers systems.
The Forest Service proposals were substantially ignored at this time,
although Assistant Secretary Reed did consider allotting 500,000 acres
for the National Forest System. "Multiple Use Areas Proposed by the
Forest Service for Withdrawal under the Alaska Native Claims Settlement
Act," February 3, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, 1971-April 1972, Swem
Papers; "Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act, Task Force Briefing,"
February 3, 1972, Briefing Notes, ANCSA, 12/18/71-3/16/72, Richard
Stenmark Files, HFC; Morris Udall and John Saylor to Rogers C.B. Morton,
January 11, 1972, Robert Belous Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Speech of
Morris Udall, Congressional Record, House, January 4, 1977, p.
E65; Theodor R. Swem to Special Assistant for Fish, Wildlife, and Parks,
February 17, 1972, Swem Correspondence, 12/71-6/72, HFC; Swem, Personal
Notes, Jan. 10, 1972 and July 31, 1973.
6. This general impression is the result of a review
of the documentary material as well as a number of interviews with the
people involved.
7. Stenmark had recently been involved in
identifying potential areas for Interior Secretary Hickel's Alaska Parks
and Monuments Advisory Committee (see pp.- 48-51). He would have
assistance from a variety of people at this time. Bailey Breedlove gave
advice on boundaries, Merrill Mattes, Zorro Bradley, and James Husted
helped draft the justifications necessary. Primary responsibility for
the task was Stenmark's, however. Swem to Assistant Director,
Legislation, et al., December 23, 1971; Swem, Personal Notes,
December 27, 1971; Interview of Al Henson and Swem, June 9, 1983.
Interview of Richard Stenmark, July 26, 1983; "Outline Decision Process
Leading to the Morton Recommendations, December 18, 1973," April 17,
1978, Box 34, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Confidential draft
justifications of individual areas, January 1972, A-94, NPS, Box 5,
Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Draft description of NPS
activities, May 19, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, April-December 1972,
Swem Papers. The latter was prepared for use in answering
interrogatories in the state of Alaska's lawsuit against Secretary
Morton, March 5, 1972.
8. Interview of Richard Stenmark, July 26, 1983;
Suggested timetable, January 3, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, 1971-April
1972, Swem Papers.
9. Interview of Richard Stenmark, July 26, 1983;
Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III and Theodor R. Swem by Frank Williss,
January 24, 1984.
10. Interview of Richard Stenmark, July 26, 1983;
Nathaniel P. Reed to Undersecretary, January 11, 1972, Swem
Correspondence, 12/71-6/72, HFC.
11. Ibid.
12. Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act, Areas
Suggested for Withdrawal - National Park System, January 7, 1972, BOR,
Box 20, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle.
13. Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife, "Areas
of Significant Wildlife Value," June 19, 1972, A-58-GAAR, ARO Central
Files, Inactive, ARO; USDI, FWS, "Implementation of the Alaska Native
Claims Settlement Act, FY 75" (preliminary draft, January 1976),
A-94-FWS (2), Box 4, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; King
and Lensink, Migratory Birds. Total acreage on a June 19 list,
which had been compiled before passage of ANCSA was 90,355,845.5 acres.
King and Lensink had identified some 135,000,000 acres.
14. Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act, Areas
Suggested for Withdrawal, January 7, 1972, BOR, Box 20, Alaska Task
Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Statement of Lynn A. Greenwalt,
Director, BSF&W, . . Before the House of Representatives, Committee
on Merchant Marine and Fisheries, Subcommittee of Fisheries and Wildlife
Conservation and the Environment on HR 6564, . . HR 5605 [Admiralty
Island National Preserve], . . , June 10, 1977, Box 26, NPS WASO Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI.
15. Nathaniel P. Reed to Undersecretary, January
11, 1972, BOR, Box 3, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle;
"Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act (ANCSA)," January 10, 1972, map in
Swem Papers. Park Service interest areas totalled 44,090,000 acres. Most
of the increase over the January 7 recommendations came in a much larger
Wrangell-St. Elias area recommendation.
16. Jack Horton to Solicitor, et al.,
January 26, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, 1971-April 1972, Swem Papers;
Rogers C.B. Morton to Solicitor, et al., January 17, 1972, Box 3,
Cook Inlet Lawsuit Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI. Horton, then deputy
undersecretary and later federal co-chairman of the Federal-State Land
Use Planning Commission, chaired the land selection task force.
17. Swem, Personal notes, February 10, 1972; Jack
Horton to Solicitor, et al., February 9, 1972; Swem Personal
Notes, February 10, 1972; Nathaniel P. Reed to Secretary, March 2, 1972,
A. Durand Jones Personal Files, Port Angeles, Washington.
18. Jack Horton to Solicitor, et al.,
January 29, 1972, ANCSA, 12/12/71-3/16/72, Stenmark Files, HFC;
"Interior to Discuss Native Claim Plans with Alaska Officials," USDI
News Release, January 26, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, 1971-April 1972,
Swem Papers.
19. "Additional Areas Suggested for study at the
Secretary's briefing for conservation organizations, February 28, 1972,"
Swem Correspondence, Dec. 1971-June 1972, HFC; Swem, Personal Notes,
February 26, 1972, Swem Papers; Interview of Richard Stenmark, July 26,
1973. Another area considered as a result of conservationists' input was
the White Mountain Forty-Mile region.
Walter Parker, an Alaska conservationist who later served as state
co-chairman of the Federal-State Land Use Planning Commission, seems to
have first suggested including the Noatak.
20. Swem, Personal Notes, March 5 and 8, 1972, Swem
Papers; Curtis E. Bohlen III to Assistant Secretary, Public Land
Management, March 23, 1972, Mt. McKinley, Box 1, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Lappen, "Whose Promised Land?" p. 81.
21. Rogers C.B. Morton to Carl Albert, June 21,
1972, ANCSA Implementation, Box 3, Cook Inlet Lawsuit Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI. This document was the Secretary's first six month's
report on ANCSA implementation.
22. Burton Silcock, director of the Bureau of Land
Management and later federal co-chairman of the Joint Federal-State Land
Use Planning Commission, apparently first raised the issue. Silcock
suggested withdrawing all public lands in Alaska. Swem, Personal Notes,
December 22, 1971.
23. Interview of Albert Henson and Theodor R. Swem,
June 7, 1983. This idea would be examined in 1978 and some used it as an
argument against establishing national monuments after the five-year d-2
time limit expired.
24. Rogers C.B. Morton to Carl Albert, June 23,
1972; Nathaniel P. Reed to Secretary, March 2, 1972, A. Durand Jones
Personal Files; Swem, Personal Notes.
25. In both cases, Congress had failed to consider
regional, or ecosystem problems in establishing the park boundaries.
Everglades had been established without regard to water supply,
something that nearly proved disastrous for the park. At Redwoods
logging outside the park borders had a major impact on the park. The
cost of correcting that problem has proven to be enormous. The final
figure that includes acquisition of property and rehabilitation of
parklands could approach $1,000,000,000. Everhart, National Park
Service, pp. 252-54; Interview of Douglas Warnock by Frank Williss,
August 6, 1984.
26. John Saylor and Morris Udall to Rogers C.B.
Morton, January 11, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, 1971-April 1972, Swem
Papers; Alaska Senator Ted Stevens, who also had been a member of the
conference committee on ANCSA, strongly disagreed. Congressional
Record, Senate, March 1, 1972.
27. Nathaniel P. Reed to Secretary, March 2, 1972,
Box 6, Cook Inlet Lawsuit files, ANILCA Papers, USDI and Swem
Correspondence, Dec. 1971-April 1972, HFC. The increase between February
and March came from recommendations made by conservationists regarding
the Noatak and Forty Mile. Secretary Reed included no land for the
National Forest System, but indicated that if it were necessary,
1,000,000 acres should be taken from the acreage alloted the Wild and
Scenic Rivers System.
28. U.S. Department of the Interior, "Areas
Suggested for Withdrawals . . . ," March 2, 1972, Swem Correspondence,
December 1971-June 1972, HFC. Overlaps, or land identified by both
agencies, were included in the above d-2 figures and amounted to
3,891,000 acres. overlaps, within the larger 17(d)(1) withdrawals
totaled 18,782,000 acres. The total 17(d)(1) withdrawal recommended was,
as a result, 146,562,000 acres.
29. Morton to Carl Albert, June 23, 1972, ANCSA
Implementation, Box 2, Cook Inlet Lawsuit files, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
Federal Register, XXXVII, March 16, 1972, p. 5579. Actually, the
total d-1 withdrawal amounted to 127,000,000 acres. Eighty million acres
overlaid the d-2 withdrawal, giving an added measure of protection to
the d-2 lands. The 47,100,000 acres described here were outside the d-2
areas. (See Illustration 7.)
30. USDI News Release, March 15, 1972, ANCSA, Box
2, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Rogers C.B. Morton to
Carl Albert, June 23, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, December 18, 1971-June
17, 1972, Box 2, Cook Inlet Lawsuit Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
Federal Register, XXXVII, March 24, 1972, p. 6090.
31. Quoted in Swem, Personal Notes, March 9, 1972;
Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr., December 7, 1983.
32. Swem, Personal Notes, January 18 - March 18,
1972. Swem said that the Service received between seventy-five and
eighty percent of what it wanted.
33. National Park Service Study Areas in Alaska
Withdrawn under the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act, March 29, 1972,
NPS Interest Areas, Stenmark Files, HFC; National Park Service Interest
Areas Withdrawn under the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act (draft),
March 14, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, Box 36, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; "35 Million Acres Get Park Study," March 16, 1972, Belous
Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, DPL; USDI, BLM, "Alaska,"
March 1972 map showing March 1972 Withdrawals, ARO (Illustration 7).
Because the March withdrawals were completed so
hurriedlychanges in acreages were still being made on the day
before the withdrawalsthe figures shown here were at best
approximations. As time went on the figures were reviewed and revised.
By mid-July the NPS total was 44,966,882 acres. Most of the increase
came from 9,003,000 acres that was the Noatak. USDI, NPS,
Recommendations Regarding Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act
17(d)(2) Withdrawals (July 1972, Revised August 1972),
passim. No effort was made to eliminate the some 12,000,000 acres
of overlap with the BSF&W interest areas.
34. U.S. Congress, House, Committee on Interior and
Insular Affairs, Subcommittee on Public Lands, D-2 Lands Set Aside
Under the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act of 1970 [sic],
Hearings, 93rd Cong., 1st sess., December 1973, p. 5; T. R. Swem,
Presentation for the House Appropriations Subcommittee, March 26, 1973,
ANCSA Implementation, January-September 1973, Swem Papers. A tape of
this presentation, made on March 15, 1973, is in Mr. Swem's
possession.
35. Anchorage Daily Times, March 16, 1972,
Belous Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, DPL; Office of
Congressman Nick Begich, News Release, March 15, 1972; State of Alaska,
News Release, March 15, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, 1971-April 1972,
Swem Papers; Anchorage Daily News, March 19, 1972, Belous
Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, DPL. Senator Stevens'
position, the News reported, exposed him to critcism within his
own party, as well as elsewhere.
36. Brief Chronology of Events Related to State
Selections, Box 4, Alaska Coalition Papers, Conservation Library, DPL;
State of Alaska, Department of Natural Resources, "State Land Selection
Program, Its History and Guidelines," March 15, 1979, Box 7, Albert
Henson Papers, Ibid.; Anchorage Daily Times, March 15,
1972, ARO Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, Ibid.;
Map showing state selections in Anchorage Daily Times, January
23, 1972, Belous Clipping Files, Ibid. Among the areas of
conflict were some 2,700,000 acres in the Central Brooks Range,
3,000,000 acres along the Copper River, and 1,200,000 acres in the Mount
McKinley area.
37. State of Alaska vs. Rogers C.B. Morton, et
al., A-4872, U.S. District Court of Alaska, April 10, 1972.
38. Swem, Personal Notes, January 10, 1972; Ernest
J. Borgman to John Rutter, February 18, 1972, Stenmark Files, HFC;
"Possibilities for Alaska Study," January 13, 1972, ANCSA Implementation
1971-April 1972, Swem Papers; National Park Service, Alaska Native
Claims Settlement Act, Financial Plan Operations Program,
March 21, 1972 (Revised April 5, 1972), ANCSA Implementation, Box 36,
NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI. By April the Service estimated that
studies in FY '72 would cost $456,800. An additional $1,756,000 was
projected for FY '73 and $849,000 for FY '74.
39. Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr., December
7, 1983; Hartzog to Frank Bracken, undated letter [April 20-21, 1972]
Box 36, WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Swem, Personal Notes, February
2, 1972.
40. Alaska Study, Roles and Functions, April 26 and
May 12, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, April-December 1972, Swem Papers.
The Alaska office would now be headed by a state director. The Service
Center did not become involved at this stage, however.
41. Interview of Albert G. Henson by Frank Williss,
June 6, 1983; Interview of John Rutter, May 16, 1984.
42. A coordinating committee composed of state
director, ATF project leader and assistant project leader, and Denver
Service Center liaison representative would, it was hoped, overcome this
problem. Alaska Study, Roles and Functions, April 26, 1972, ANCSA
Implementation, April-December 1972, Swem Papers; Interview of George B.
Hartzog, Jr., December 7, 1983; Interview of Al Henson, June 6,
1983.
43. U.S. Congress, House, Committee on Interior and
Insular Affairs, Subcommittee on Public Lands, D-2 Lands Set Aside,
Hearings, p. 4; Bureau of Outdoor Recreation in Alaska, December 14,
1973, HCRS Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; R.L. Means to T. Swem, undated
draft [after May 23, 1973], ANCSA Implementation, January-September
1973, Swem >Papers; Interview of William Reffalt by Frank Williss,
December 9, 1983.
44. Morton to Assistant Secretaries, et al.,
April 21, 1972, HCRS Records, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Burton Silcock to
Secretary of the Interior, April 24, 1972, 1600-Planning, Programming,
Budgeting, Records of the Bureau of Land Management, ANILCA Papers,
USDI. In this memo, Silcock recommended, among other things, that the
BLM coordinate the Alaskan studies of all Interior Department
agencies.
45. "ATF Accomplishments," draft, January 9, 1973,
Belous Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Raymond Freeman to Director, PNW, May
12, 1972, Box 1, NPS WASO Files, Ibid.; Interview of Albert G.
Henson, June 6, 1983; George B. Hartzog, Jr. to Regional Directors,
April 25, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, April-December 1972, Swem Papers.
The Washington Office paid the salaries of those permanently transferred
to Alaska, as well as travel and per diem costs of all Task Force
members. Salaries of those detailed, however, were borne by the
originating office.
46. Interview of Albert G. Henson, June 6, 1983;
Alaska Task Force Staff, 1972, Box 2, Alaska, HFC; Study Area
Assignments, May 22, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, April-December 1972,
Swem Papers. For example, one team studied St. Elias-Chugach, Tanana
Hills and Yukon River-Eagle to Circle, while another studied Gates of
the Arctic, Chukchi and the Noatak. Appendix 1 is a list of the staff of
the Alaska Task Force.
47. Study Area Assignments, May 22, 1972, ANCSA
Implementation, April-December 1972, Swem Papers; Interview of Al
Henson, June 6, 983; Interview of Zorro Bradley by Frank Williss,
November 7, 1983. Additionally, certain specialistssociologist,
engineer, mining, land, and photographer, for examplewere detailed
to the Task Force.
48. National Park Service Study
CategoriesAlaska, May 26, 1972, A-74-NPS, Alaska Task Force Files,
RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Henson to Team Captains, June 16, 1972, ANCSA
Implementation, April-December 1972, Swem Papers; Henson to Swem, June
16, 1972, Ibid.
49. Ibid.; "Alaska Task Force," May 10,
1975, AAO Objectives, Denali Keyman Files, Box 28, Alaska Task Force
Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle. The Forest Service on the other hand,
intended, at least, to make recommendations by submitting preliminary
master plans indicating how the areas would be managed.
50. Robert Eastman to Deputy Assistant Secretary
Lyons, July 12, 1972, D-4225-Alaska, HCRS Records, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
Al Henson to Team Captains, May 22, 1972, Box 3, Alaska Task Force
Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Al Henson to Director, PNW, June 20, 1973,
A-94-APG, Ibid.; Swem, Personal Notes, May 18, 1972. For a brief
period, the department considered a July 1 deadline, but this was
extended.
51 . Al Henson to Team members, May 23, 1972, Box
3, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Interview of Al
Henson, °ree;June 6, 1983.
52. Alaska Task Force Briefing, June 5, 6, 7, ANCSA
Implementation, April-December 1972, Swem Papers.
53. Al Henson to Team Members, May 22, 1983, Box 3,
Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC Seattle; Interview of Al Henson,
June 6, 1983; John Kauffmann to Project Leader, [June 1972], ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Interview of Bailey Breedlove, November 10, 1983;
Interview of John Kauffmann, December 5, 1983. One reason for this
approach was logisticalthere were neither enough planes available
for all, nor office space to accommodate everyone at one time.
54. USDI, NPS, Recommendations Regarding
17(d)(2), passim. The figures included areas that overlapped several
recommended by the Bureau of Sports Fisheries and Wildlife. The
BSF&W and BOR published similar reports: USDI, BOR, Alaska Task
Force, "Summary of Alaska Rivers Recommended for Detailed Consideration
for the National Wild and Scenic Rivers System," July 1972, A-94, Wild
and Scenic Rivers, Box 5, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle,
and USDI, BSF&W, Alaska Area Office, "Recommendations Regarding
Section 17(d)(2) withdrawals, Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act,"
Edition 1, July 1972, James Pepper Files, Headquarters, Gates of the
Arctic National Park/Preserve, Fairbanks, Alaska. The Forest Service
also published recommendations, although it differed in form from those
of the Interior agencies. The report is discussed on p. 119.
55. USDI, NPS, Recommendations Regarding
17(d)(2); Interview of Al Henson, June 6, 1983. The recommendation
that Mt. Veniaminof be deleted was based primarily on limited visitor
use potential; Chukchi and Nogabahara Sand Dunes because they appeared
to have no special park values meriting protection. The Task Force did
recommend that 205,800 acres of the Mt. Veniaminof withdrawal be
retained in federal ownership as an area that possessed scenic,
recreation, or scientific values. It was understood, moreover, that the
BSF&W would recommend protection of Chukchi because of the wildlife
values of the area.
56. USDI, NPS, Recommendations Regarding
17(d)(2), pp. 116-20; Interview of Al Henson, June 6, 1983. Possible
Native selection lands in the area amounted to 865,720 acres. The Task
Force recommended cooperative studies to determine ''mutually acceptable
management and development procedures." Generally, however, it was
believed that Kenai Fjord would be a viable park only if lands were not
selected by Natives. This proved to be the case, and the three separate
units were linked together.
57. USDI, NPS, Recommendations Regarding
17(d)(2), p. 3.
58. Interview of John Kauffmann, December 5, 1983.
The Service did rescue the upper Ambler, but lost the Kogoluktuk Valley,
which is certainly among the most beautiful of the Brooks Range.
59. Ibid., passim; Francis S.L.
Williamson, "An Evaluation of the NPS Task Force Recommendations for
withdrawal of lands in Alaska, with Special Reference to Biological
Considerations," draft, 7/19/72, ANCSA Implementation April-December
1972, Swem Papers; "Alaska Studies," January 22, 1975, Swem
Correspondence, 1/75-12/76, HFC. Williamson's paper, which was completed
under a $1,000 contract with the Park Service, was the first effort to
put the Service's Alaska proposals in a general context.
60. USDI, NPS, Recommendations Regarding
17(d)(2), pp. 24-25, 68; Interview of Al Henson, June 6, 1983.
61. Edgar Wayburn to Rogers C.B. Morton, August 4,
1972, Records of the Office of Regional Law Enforcement Specialist, ARO;
"Secretarial Meeting on Alaska Land Withdrawals," August 11, 1972, Xerox
copy in Jones Files, Port Angeles, Washington. Among the areas
recommended were 13,500,000 acres in the Wrangell Mountains, 25,300,000
in the Central Brooks Range-Noatak, and 9,700,000 acres in the
Iliamna-Lake Clark-Katmai area.
62. Swem, Personal Notes, August 8, 1972; Interview
of Al Henson, June 6, 1983; Anchorage Times, July 28, 1972, ARO
Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, DPL; USDA, Forest Service,
Alaska Planning Team, New National Forests in Alaska (July 1972);
USDA, F.S., AFT, Forest Service Recommendation for Final Section
17(d)(2) Withdrawals (Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1972). Among the
proposed national forests were areas in Wrangell Mountains, Fortymile,
Lake Clark, Yukon, and Koyukuk.
63. 'Study of Areas as of August 16, 1972," ANCSA
Implementation, April-December 1972, Swem Papers. Overlapping d-2 areas
were Kenai Fjords (95,400 acres), Wrangell-Saint Elias (956,100),
Chukchi-Imuruk (701,500), Tanana Hills-Yukon River (1,139,900), and
Noatak (8,614,040). In addition, 1,010,400 acres of overlapping d-1 land
at Chukchi-Imuruk and Wrangell-St. Elias existed.
64. Alaska Native Management Report, vol. 1
(September 12, 1973), p. 1, Belous Clipping Files, Special Collections
Division, DPL.
65. USDI News Release, July 14, 1972; U.S.
Congress, Senate, Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, Land
Planning and Policy in Alaska: Recommendations Concerning National
Interest Lands, by the Joint Federal-State Land Use Planning
Commission of Alaska, 93rd Cong., 2nd Sess., June 1973, p. 3.
66. Ernest J. Borgman to Director, PNW, April 17,
1972, L7019-Northern Planning Team Meetings, ARO Central Files,
Inactive; Meetings held, BLM, 1972, Ibid; Northern Alaska
Planning Project Monthly Report, April 1972, Ibid; The Alaska
Native Management Report, vol. 1, (September, 12, 1972], pp. 4-5;
Interview with Richard Stenmark, July 26, 1983; Jack O. Horton to
Directors, BLM, BSF&W, NPS, USGS, BOR, April 9, 1971, HCRS Records,
ANILCA Papers, USDI. Coordinated by the BLM, the team had been formed to
develop a master land use plan for northern Alaska. Richard Stenmark,
who subsequently transferred to the commission's staff, was the NPS's
representative.
67. Al Henson to Theodore R. Swem, August 22, 1972,
ATF Readers File, Box 32, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle;
Swem, Personal Notes, August 12, 1972; Jack Horton and Charles Herbert
to Rogers C.B. Morton, August 12, 1972, ANCSA Implementation,
April-December 1972, Swem Papers.
68. Hunter was a federal representative, Herbert
had been appointed by Governor Egan.
69. Henson to Swem, August 22, 1972, ATF Readers
File, August 1972, Box 32, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle.
70. Jack Horton and Charles F. Herbert to Rogers
C.B. Morton, August 16, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, April-December 1972,
Swem Papers; Land Planning and Policy in Alaska, p. 3;
Anchorage Daily Times, August 12, 18, and 19, 1972, Belous
Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, DPL; Anchorage Daily
News, August 13, 1972, Ibid. Among specific changes
recommended were transfer from d-2 to d-1 status of lands in Aniakchak,
Chukchi-Imuruk, Charley River, Lake Clark, Iliamna, Gates of the Arctic,
and Mount McKinley.
71. Memorandum of Understanding Between the State
of Alaska and the United States, September 2, 1972, A-94, Alaska, State
of, Selections, Box 2, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle;
Alaska Native Management Report, vol. 1, September 12, 1972; USDI
News Release, September 5, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, April-Dec. 1972,
Swem Papers; Anchorage Daily News, September 6 and 8 and
Anchorage Daily Times, September 5, 1972, Belous Clipping Files,
Special Collections Division, DPL; USDI, Alaska Planning Group,
Master Plan, Aniakchak National Monument (Washington, D.C.: NPS,
1973), p. 27; John F. Luzader, "Litigation," (1983), typescript in
author's possession. The latter is a paper consolidating some 1400 pages
of interrogatories, briefs, complaints, and news reports on d-2
litigation.
72. USDI News Release, September 13, 1972, ANCSA
Implementation, Cook Inlet Lawsuit Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Rogers
C.B. Morton to Carl Albert, December 15, 1972, Ibid; USDI, BLM,
"Alaska," September 1972, ARO. Illustration 8 is based on this map. No
effort was made at this point to eliminate overlaps. Boundaries shown,
as a result, are approximate.
73. "National Park Service, Acreage Figures of
Study Areas (d-2 withdrawals), October 2, 1972 (Rev. ATF, 10/31/72),"
History of ATF, Papers of Al Henson, Mancos, Colo.; "Memorandum of
Understanding Between the State of Alaska and the United States,"
September 2, 1972; John Reynolds to Dick Stenmark, September 21, 1971
and Reynolds to Jerry Patten, August 31, 1972, ATF Reader Files,
September 1972, Box 32, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle;
Interview of A. Durand Jones, May 15, 1984; D-2 Land Set Aside,
Hearings, 1973, p. 4.
Portions of the proposed Mt. McKinley addition had been deleted in
departmental review. The Chelatna Lake/Sunflower Basin area in that
proposal, parts of the Alatna and John Rivers at Gates of the Arctic,
most of the deletion at Lake Clark, and areas in the Tanana Hills-Yukon
River were deleted as a result of the September 2 agreement. Some
400,000 acres of the last area had been eliminated, moreover, as a
result of departmental negotiations with Doyon Native Regional
Corporation.
74. John Reynolds to Jerry Patten, August 31, 1972
and Paul Fritz to Al Henson, August 29, 1972, ATF Readers File August
1972, Box 32, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle. On the
other hand, Bailey Breedlove wrote that we "won the first round of the
September withdrawals so conclusively in fact, that it is now called in
Alaska 'The Battle of the Overlays' [a reference to the maps used]."
Unified Support for NPS Alaska Proposals, by Bailey O. Breedlove,
November 10, 1972, ANCSA Implementation, April-December 1972, Swem
Papers.
75. NPS, Acreage Figures of Study Areas (D-2
withdrawals), October 2, 1972 (Rev. 10/31/72), Henson Papers, Mancos;
USDI, BLM, "Alaska," September 1972. Illustration 8 shows the September
withdrawals.
As early as July 1972, NPS planners studying Noatak identified Cape
Krusenstern, an area with outstanding archeological values, as having
"other resource values." The 7,874,700-acre Noatak withdrawal listed
above included Cape Krusenstern. By January 1973, however, the two had
been separated, although at that time the two acreages were still
combined. USDI, NPS, Recommendations Regarding 17(d)(2), pp.
7-8.
76. Nathaniel P. Reed to Directors, NPS and
BSF&W, September 25, 1973, Breedlove Papers, HFC; Al Henson to
Theodor Swem, September 15, 1972, Ibid.; Henson to Swem, March 1,
1973, W-38, Legislation, Box 20, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle. Legislative support data includes a broad range of material to
assist Congress in its deliberations. It includes cost data, proposed
staffing, proposed development, maps, land ownership data, minerals
data, etc.
77. Interview of James M. Lambe by Frank Williss,
December 8, 1983; See for example, "A Bill to Establish Arctic Valleys
[Noatak] National Ecological Reserve in the state of Alaska, and for
other purposes," [1973], Arctic Valleys file, ARO central files -
inactive, ARO. Lambe prepared a bill for each individual area. The
reason the Service staff prepared individual drafts for the areas was
that they were not certain, at this date, of what form the Secretary's
proposals would take, and wanted to be prepared for every
contingency.
78. Al Henson to John Rutter, June 20, 1973, A-94,
APG, Box 3, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle.
79. Interview of John Rutter, May 16, 1984;
Interview of Stanley T. Albright, June 29, 1984; Swem, Personal Notes,
June 20, 1972 and January 5, 1973; Al Henson to Swem, September 15,
1972, Breedlove Papers, HFC; Zorro Bradley to Al Hensen, January 9,
1973, "Natives," Box 1, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Bill
Everhart to Swem, January 8, 1973, Ibid.; Nome Nugget,
June 29, 1973, Belous Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, DPL.
By January 5, 1973, Zorro Bradley and Harold Gronroos, whom Swem had
hired to work with the Alaska Task Force in 1972, were working on a
Native assistance program. The first proposal was for a program of
preserving the Native cultural heritage.
80. Acreages with indefinite status on remaining
NPS proposals, September 14, 1973, ANCSA Implementation,
January-September 1973, Swem Papers; "Dual withdrawals," draft, February
13, 1978, Doc. No. 003120, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Swem to Lynn Greenwalt
and Robert Eastman, October 15, 1973, Box 33, NPS WASO Files,
Ibid.; Ira J. Hutchinson to Assistant Secretary, FWP, November
20, 1978, d-2 Positions and Options, ARO Central FilesInactive,
ARO; Al Henson to T. Swem, September 15, 1972, Breedlove Papers,
HFC.
81. Loren W. Croxton and Al Henson to Assistant
Secretary Fish, Wildlife and Parks (Nathaniel P. Reed), January 10,
1973, BSF&W Overlaps, Henson Papers, Mancos; "Alaska Native Claim
Settlement Act - List of Study Areas Showing where Overlaps Exist,"
January 19, 1973, ANCSA Implementation, January-September 1973, Swem
Papers; Interview of Al Henson, June 6, 1973; Interview of Henson and
Theodor Swem, June 7, 1983. Prior to this time, both agencies agreed
that overlapping claims would actually strengthen the case for any
proposal.
82. Theodor R. Swem to Doug Wheeler and Jim Ruch,
April 12, 1973, HCRS Records, ANILCA Papers USDI; USDI, BLM, Alaska
State Office, A Proposal, Wrangell Mountains National Conservation
Area (Anchorage: Bureau of Land Management, 1973); Lappen, "Whose
Promised Land?" p. 93. The BLM'S "fifth system" proposal for Wrangells,
for example, was similar to multiple-use proposals it had made for the
area prior to ANCSA.
83. T. Swem to Curtis E. Bohlen, III, November 5,
1973, Box 36, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI. Deputy Assistant
Secretary Bohlen had primary responsibility for Alaska affairs in
Assistant Secretary Reed's office. Until August 1977 he played a major
role in determining the direction of the Interior Department's Alaska
effort. At that time he joined the staff of the House Merchant Marine
and Fisheries Committee where he continued to work on the Alaska
national interest lands issue.
84. Loren W. Croxton and Al Henson to Swem, June
10, 1973, BSF&W Overlaps, Henson Papers, Mancos.
85. Swem, Personal Notes, January 6, 24, and 30,
1973; Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, Ill by Frank Williss, October 10,
1983; Interview of Al Henson and Theodor R. Swem, June 7, 1983;
Interview of A. Durand Jones, May 15, 1983; Robert Utley to Bryan Harry,
February 26, 1976, A-16, Advisory Council, Box 1, Alaska Task Force
Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle.
86. Nathaniel P. Reed to Directors, NPS, BSF&W,
and BOR, February 15, 1973, ANCSA Implementation, January-September
1973, Swem Papers; USDI News Release, March 23, 1973, Ibid.;
Curtis E. Bohlen to John McGuire, February 25, 1973, HCRS Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Bob Utley to Bryan Harry, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79,
FARC, Seattle. In 1973 membership was expanded to include
representatives of BLM and Forest Service. Appendix 2 is an organization
chart of the Alaska Planning Group.
87. Reed to Directors, February 15, 1973; Rogers
C.B. Morton to Undersecretary, Assistant Secretaries, et. al.,
January 9, 1973, A-94, Box 3, Alaska Task Force Files, FARC, Seattle;
"Support Documentation for Statement of Nathaniel P. Reed, November 18,
1975," Box 16, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI. A working arm of the
departmental Alaska Task Force was the Department Work Group on Alaska.
The relationship of that group with the APG was the same.
88. Henson to John Rutter, June 20, 1973, A94-APG,
Box 3, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; "Bureau of Outdoor
Recreation Involvement in Alaska," December 4, 1973, HCRS Records,
ANILCA Papers, USDI; Jules Tileston to Wild and Scenic Rivers
Participants, March 9, 1973, A-94, Wild and Scenic Rivers, Box 5, Alaska
Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle. The reconnaissance surveys made
by the NPS Alaska Task Force and those of other agencies are a story in
themselves. For a fascinating account of one on the Salmon River in the
Brooks Range, see McPhee, Coming into the Country, pp. 5-97.
89. Dennis, Moorhead, Streveler, and Weisbrod to Al
Henson, draft memo, November 10, 1972, ANCSA Implementation,
April-December 1972, Swem Papers; "Alaska Studies," January 22, 1975,
Swem Correspondence, 1/75-12/76, HFC; Al Henson to Team Captains, June
22, 1972, L-58, Correspondence to Team Captains, Box 17, Alaska Task
Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle.
90. "Alaska Studies," January 22, 1975; Al Henson
to Ted Swem, January 18, 1973, Bailey O. Breedlove Papers, HFC; "Noatak
River Drainage Project," The Raven the Quarterly Newsletter of the
Center for Northern Studies, II (July 1973). The cost of these
studies were, respectively, $24,000, $131,000 and $123,000.
91. Henson to Swem, January 18, 1973.
92. John G. Dennis, "National Park Service Research
in Alaska1972-76," Arctic Bulletin (1977) pp. 275-84; NPS,
"Natural, Historical, and Cultural Resource Studies in Alaska," January
1978, Xerox copy in library, Rocky Mountain Regional Office; Alaska
Implementation Planning Team, "Fish and Wildlife and Parks Current and
Interim Activities for Alaska," 11/20/78, Box 18, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; "Answers to Sen. Stevens," draft, 2/13/78,
Ibid.
Other agencies and groups, as well, sponsored
research on the d-2 lands during this period. The JFSLUPC, for example,
prepared a series of studies, including a multi-volume Alaskan
Resources Inventory (1974) and Alaska Regional Profiles
(1974). "Land Use Planning Commission Publications" and "Publications
and Studies, Federal-State Land Use Planning Commission for Alaska,"
Breedlove Papers, HFC.
93. USDI, APG, NPS, Gates of the Arctic National
Wilderness Park and Nunamiut National Wildlands (Washington, D.C.,
1973); NPS Briefing Statement, "Proposed Gates of the Arctic National
Wilderness Park," June 22, 1973, ANCSA Implementation January-September
1973, Swem Papers; NPS Briefing Statement, "Proposed Noatak National
Ecological Reserve," June 22, 1973, Ibid.; Interview of John
Kauffmann, December 5, 1983.
94. USDI, APG, NPS, Yukon-Charle National Rivers
A Master Plan (Washington, D.C.: APG, 1973 , p. 40; USDI, APG, NPS,
A Master Plan, Aniakchak Caldera National Monument, (Washington,
D.C.: 1973), p. 24. See also Lappen, "Whose Promised Land?" pp.
98-99.
95. Al Henson to Ted Swem, January 18, 1973,
A-94-NPS, Box 5, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Henson
to Director, NPS, January 19, 1973, Denali Keyman Files, Box 33,
Ibid.; Interview of Al Henson and Theodor Swem, June 7, 1983.
96. Interview of Al Henson and Theodor Swem, June
7, 1983; Bruce >Blanchard to Assistant SecretaryProgram
Development and Budget, April 13, 1973, ANCSA Implementation,
January-September 1973, Swem Papers.
97. Interview of Bill Reffalt, December 9, 1983;
Ted Swem to Deputy Assistant Secretary Bohlen, May 21, 1973, Swem
Correspondence 1/73-6/73, HFC; Bill Reffalt to all K Street Personnel,
August 16, 1973, ANCSA Implementation, January-September 1973, Swem
Papers. Recipients of Draft Staffing Plan, September 26, 1973, ANCSA
Implementation, January-September 1973, Ibid.; Swem, "Outline
History," pp. 12-13; USDI, FWS, Programs Related to the Alaska Native
Claims Settlement Act (Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1976), p. 5; "Summary
of [NPS] Alaska People involved in K Street Operation," [December 1973],
NPS Personnel-AK, Henson Papers, Mancos.
98. T. Swem to Asst. Sec., FWP, May 1, 1973 [APG
Monthly Report, April 1973], HCRS Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
99. Team Three to Al Henson, December 5, 1973,
BSF&W Overlaps, Henson Papers, Mancos; John Kauffmann to Project
Leader, April 6, 1973, Arctic Valleys, ARO Central Files - Inactive,
ARO.
100. John Reynolds to Al Henson, May 1, 1973, doc.
no. 000262, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
101. Interview of Al Henson and Theodor Swem, June
7, 1983; Chronology, Implementation Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act,
National Park Service, October 14, 1975, Box 14, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Briefing Statement, Chukchi-Imuruk National Wildlands,
June 22, 1973 ANCSA Implementation, January-September 1973, Swem
Papers.
102. Briefing Statements, NPS, BSF&W, and BOR,
June 14-22, 1973, ANCSA Implementation, January-September 1973, Swem
Papers. The Noatak was included in both the National Park and Refuge
Systems, Chukchi-Imuruk National Wildlands would have been jointly
managed by the NPS and BSF&W. Approximately 90 percent of the
Harding Icefield-Kenai Fjords proposal was on Native deficiency lands.
The viability of the proposal depended on cooperative agreements with
the Natives, or non-selection of these lands by the Natives.
103. Secretarial Meetings on Alaska Land
Withdrawals, August 11, 1972, transcript in Jones Files, Port Angeles,
Washington; John Saylor and Morris Udall to Rogers C.B. Morton, January
11, 1972, Belous Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
For an opposite view see: U.S. Congress, House, Committee on Interior
or Insular Affairs, D-2 Lands Set Aside, Hearings, pp. 14-15.
104. Theodore Swem, Personal Notes, July 26, 1973;
Interview of Al Henson and Theodore Swem, June 7, 1983; Interview of A.
Durand Jones, May 15, 1984.
105. JFSLUPC, News Release, February 7, 1973,
A-94-JFSLUPC, Box 4, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle;
"People Planning for a Better Alaska Tomorrow," Newsletter of the
Federal State Land Use Planning Commission for Alaska, vol. 1, nos. 3
and 4, March-April, 1973; U.S. Congress, Senate, Land Planning and
Policy in Alaska, pp. 7-8. The latter is a reprint of the
Commission's preliminary recommendations. In addition the Forest Service
held a series of "listening session," on its proposals, much to the
displeasure of the Interior Department staff. Interview of Al Henson and
Theodor Swem, June 7, 1983; Interview of A. Durand Jones, May 15,
1984.
106. USDA, USFS, Alaska Planning Team, New
National Forests in Alaska Anchorage, 1973); D-2 Lands Set Aside,
Hearings, December 6, 1973, p. 35; Hearings on H.R. 39, et
al., 1977, II: 266, 278-79; Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 14;
Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III, October 5, 1983; Interview of Al
Henson and Theodor Swem, June 7, 1983.
107. USDA, USFS, Alaska Planning Team, New
National Forests in Alaska (Anchorage, July 1972); "Secretarial
Meeting on Alaska Land Withdrawals," August 11, 1972, transcript in
Jones Papers. The 1972 proposals amounted to 44,100,000 acres.
108. "Suggested Balanced System," August 9, 1973,
ANCSA Implementation, January-September 1973, Swem Papers. The Forest
Service recommended, among other things, a 6,200,000-acre Wrangell St.
Elias National Park, a reduced Gates of the Arctic (5,200,000), and
proposed deleting the Noatak, Lake Clark, and Yukon-Charley
proposals.
109. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 14, and
"Alaska," p. 11; "Notes of Assistant Secretary Nathaniel P. Reed taken
at meeting 8-3-73, with Assistant Secretary of Agriculture Long with
Assistant Secretary Lynn of Interior also present. Meeting Relating to
implementing of ANCSA," August 5, 1973, ANCSA
ImplementationJanuary-September, 1973, Swem Papers; T.R. Swem to
Ron Walker, September 25, 1973, September 27, 1973, October 16, 1973,
and October 25, 1973, Alaska Status Reports, Swem Papers.
110. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 14 and "Alaska",
p. 11; Interview of Curtis Bohlen III, October 10, 1983. Additionally,
Bohlen indicates the need to resolve the question before the proposal
could go to OMB for review was another factor.
111 . Swem to Ron Walker, September 25, 1973
(includes a September 21 list of areas), and October 16, 1973, Alaska
Status Reports, Swem Papers; Interview with Al Henson and Theodor Swem,
June 7, 1983.
112. Among the other agencies that reviewed the
proposals were Departments of Defense and Commerce, Federal Power
Commission, and OMB. D-2 Lands Set Aside, Hearings December 1973,
p. 13; T. Swem to Ron Walker, October 25, 1973 and October 26, 1973,
Alaska Status Reports, Swem Papers.
113. T. Swem to Nathaniel P. Reed, October 24,
WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Nathaniel P. Reed to T. Swem, Lynn
Greenwalt, and Curt Burklund, November 6, 1973, Box 41, Alaska Task
Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle. On Nov. 6, Reed indicated that no
further adjustments would be made, pending an agreement by BSF&W and
BLM to protect the bears.
114. Chronology, December 13-14 and 17-18, ANCSA
Implementation, October-December 1973, Swem Papers; Wilfred H. Rommel to
Rogers C.B. Morton, December 13, 1973, Ibid.; J.M. Lambe (for
Stanley Hulett) to Deputy Assistant Secretary, FWP, December 14, 1973;
Ibid.; "Proposals authorized by Alaska Native Claims Settlement
Act," October 31 and December 18, 1973, Ibid.; Russel E.
Dickinson to Legislative counsel, 11/14/73, Doc. No. 002108, ANILCA
Papers, USDI. The latter was a cover letter, forwarding NPS formal
proposals. Despite reservations on OMB's part, the Department
successfully defended joint management of the area.
115. Press ConferenceRogers C.B. Morton,
Secretary, Department of the Interior, December 18, 1973, transcript in
Jones Files. Wilderness, according to the Wilderness Preservation Act of
1964, is an area "where the earth and its community of life are
untrammeled by man, where man himself is a visitor who does not remain."
Generally, the act prohibited uses inconsistent with wilderness
preservationcommercial enterprises, motor vehicles and motorized
equipment, roads, and structures and installations, for example. The
term "instant wilderness" refers to establishment of wilderness areas
without formal wilderness studies. It was believed, however, that
sufficient studies of the area had been completed to warrant wilderness
designation.
116. Rogers C.B. Morton to Gerald Ford, December
17, 1973, ANCSA Implementation, October-December 1973, Swem Papers;
Press ConferenceRogers C.B. Morton, Secretary, Department of the
Interior, December 18, 1973, pp. 4, 7, Transcript in Jones Papers.
117. "A Bill to provide for the addition of
certain lands in the state of Alaska to the National Park, National
Wildlife Refuge, National Forest, and the Wild and Scenic Rivers systems
and for other purposes," (Alaska Conservation Act of 1974), December 17,
1973, ANCSA Implementation, October-December 1973, Swem Papers.
118. Morton to Ford, December 17, 1973. The
Proposed Harding Icefield-Kenai Fjords consisted of three small,
separate units. The bill provided that if the native corporations did
not select the land between, it could be added to the monument. The NPS
Alaska Task Force was convinced that it would happenas it did.
Interview of Al Henson, June 6, 1983. Illustration 9 is a map of the
Morton proposal.
119. Although BLM would be the lead agency, the
Noatak would be managed as part of the Wildlife Refuge system. A 20-year
moratorium on developmental activities would "preserve land use options
while allowing time for comprehensive analysis of this intact, arctic
ecosystem." USDI, FWS, Noatak National Arctic Range, (Washington,
D.C.: FWS, 1974).
120. The policy sections were essentially those
developed by the Park Service and ratified by the Alaska Planning Group.
Mike Lambe to Ted Swem, July 25, 1973, ANCSA Implementation,
January-September 1973, Swem Papers; Swem to Deputy Assistant Secretary
Bohlen, FWP, November 5, 1973, Swem Correspondence, July-December 1973,
HFC.
121. The exception was Yukon-Charley National
Rivers. Here the Park Service recommended allowing sport hunting.
Briefing statementProposed Yukon-Charley National Rivers, National
Park Service, June 22, 1973, ANCSA Implementation, January-September,
1973, Swem Papers.
122. Statement of Nathaniel P. Reed, in
Hearings on H.R. 39, et. al., 1977, V:20; Interview with Theodor
R. Swem and Al Henson, June 6, 1983; Interview with Curtis E. Bohlen,
III, October 10, 1983; Interview of William Reffalt, December 9, 1983;
Interview with A. Durand Jones, May 15, 1984.
123. D-2 Lands Set Aside, Hearings,
December 1973, p. 42.
124. "Senator Ted Stevens Comments at Alaska
Proposal Briefing November 8, 1973," June 1, 1974, ANCSA Implementation
- 1974, Swem Papers; Norman C. Gorsuch to Curt Berklund, April 25, 1974,
Swem Correspondence, February-December 1974, H FC [letter delivering
summons and complaint for State of Alaska vs. Rogers C.B. Morton, et.
al.]; Anchorage Times, November 30, 1973; "Egan Hits Land Plan,"
"Gruening says Morton to be 'man who wrecked Alaska,"' "Gravel Plans
Land Package Aid," "Land Look Vital says Stevens," in Anchorage Daily
Times, December 19, 1973 and March 30, 1974, Belous Clipping Files,
Special Collections Division, DPL. In addition, a number of Natives
issued objections to the bill arguing that it would prevent their
receiving full land entitlements. "Native Chiefs Object to Morton's
Proposal," Anchorage Daily Times, Dec. 19, 1973.
125. "Is Alaska Worth 8 cents?" Washington
Post, May 29, 1973; "What ever happened to the Canada geese? and the
Mallards? . . . ," Washington Post, November 30 and December 3,
1973; "Rogers Morton lost his chance at a place in history," NPS,
Editorial Briefs, December 31, 1973; Edgar Wayburn to Henry M.
Jackson, November 6, 1973, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle; Harry Crandell to Ted Swem, November, 1973, Conservationists
Involvement in Alaska - TWS thru 1975, Swem Papers. The package included
44,000,000 acres for refuges, 12,000,000 for national forests and
1,600,000 for wild and scenic rivers.
126. William C. Everhart said that most NPS
employees would have been delighted with half the amount. Interview by
Frank Williss, June 29, 1984.
127. Williamson, "Evaluation of NPS Task Force
Recommendations"; T.R. Swem to Ron Walker, October 16, 1973, Alaska
Status Reports, Swem Papers; "Alaska Studies," 1/22/75, Swem
Correspondence, HFC; Swem, "Outline History," p. 11; Interview of A.
Durand Jones, May 15, 1984; Interview of Al Henson and Theodor Swem,
June 7, 1983.
"The decision on the Noatak, Swem wrote NPS Director Walker, "is an
ironic one because the National Park Service has been the agency mainly
involved in keeping that proposal alive and, also, has done most of the
study work and research within the basin."
128. Swem, "Outline History," p. 11; Interview
with Al Henson and Swem, June 7, 1983; Interview of A. Durand Jones, May
15, 1954.
The bill did provide for a much watered-down regional planning at Mt.
McKinley. One reason regional planning was not included was a proposal
already before Congress for national land use planning. That bill did
not pass, as was expected.
129. Franklin K. Lane to Stephen T. Mather, May
13, 1918, quoted in Unrau and Williss, Expansion of the NPS, p.
25. Precedents existed, however, for allowing hunting in parks. At Grand
Tetons, for example, an annual hunt to control the elk population
occurred. Cahn, "Alaska A Matter of 80,000,000 acres," Audubon 76
(July 1974), p. 12; Robert T. Dennis to John Kauffmann, December 12,
1972, L-3035 Hunting Subsistence, Box 16, Alaska Task Force Files, RG
79, FARC, Seattle; Roger Ernest to Mr. Goldsworth, September 2, 1960,
vol. 1, May 1, 1953-December 31, 1960, Records of the Office of Regional
Director, Region 4, RG 79, FARC, San Bruno.
130. Testimony of Nathaniel P. Reed in
Hearings on H.R. 39, et al., 1977, V:20; Jack Hession to
Claudia Martin, Bob Weedon, Jim Kowalsky, November 15, 1974, "To do
eventually" file, Henson Papers, Mancos.
131. See, for example, Roger J. Contor to
Director, January 3, 1977, Box 17, WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; John
T. Nicol to Theodor Swem, July 17, 1974, Ibid.; Review of
Wrangell-St. Elias Environmental Impact Statement by Jack (John T.)
Nicol, Director General, Parks Canada, July 1, 1974, Belous Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI; Interview of Al Henson and Theodor Swem (June 7,
1983), John Cook (January 26, 1984), and Stanley T. Albright (June 29,
1984). At the same time many NPS employees of Alaska, and this included
Alaska Task Force members, had concluded that some accommodation to
sport hunting advocates would have to be made. The next year, for
example, John Kauffmann, after participating in a guided "fair chase"
hunt of DalI sheep in the Brooks Range, wrote that the experiences
"confirmed by personal experience our conviction that this form of
recreation is a valid wilderness experience appropriate to certain of
the larger park proposals for Alaska." John Kauffmann to Acting Project
leader, ATFO, August 15, 1974, L3- 35-Hunting, Box 18, Alaska Task Force
Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle. See also, Interview of John Kauffmann,
December 5, 1983; Interview of Richard Stenmark, July 26, 1983.
Interview of James Pepper by Frank Williss, November 8, 1983; Interview
of Celia Hunter, November 7, 1983; "A Proposal," by Richard J. Stenmark,
February 14, 1973, Stenmark Files, HFC; Conservation Foundation,
National Parks for the Future, An appraisal of the National parks as
they began their second century in a changing America (Washington,
D.C.: The Conservation Foundation, 1972), pp. 19-20.
132. Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III and
Theodor R. Swem, January 24, 1984; John Kauffmann to Roger Contor, April
7, 1977, Correspondence, 1977, GAAR Keyman Files, Box 35, Alaska Task
Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle. In 1978, when the department studied
administrative alternatives in the face of the expiration of the d-2
provision, it found that the 1974-75 EIS's, which included discussions
of the areas of ecological concern, adequately covered the composite
boundaries of all proposed legislation as of that date. Only a
supplement, therefore, would be necessary.
133. [ ______] to T. Swem, Follow-up slip,
December 3, 1973, ANCSA Implementation, Swem papers. A considerable
amount of that time was uncompensated.
134. S. 2198; Congressional Record, Senate,
January 30, 1974, p. 747 and passim. Congressman Hosmer
introduced a similar bill on February 4.
135. 5. 2198; Congressional Record, Senate,
January 30, 1974. The bill, which was a companion to that introduced by
Morris Udall on March 18 (H.R. 13564), called for 43,200,000 acres in
new parklands, 59,700,000 in refuges, 1,594,000 in wild and scenic
rivers, and 1,600,000 in national forest.
136. S. 3599, Henry Jackson; H.R. 15856, Dingall,
et al., July 11, 1974. S. 3599 had been introduced at the behest
of the Arctic Slope Regional Corporation.
137. For example, "Alaska Professional Hunters
Association, "Proposals for Disposition of 80 million acres under Terms
of the Alaska Native Land Claims Settlement Act," [May 1974], L-3035,
Wildlife Management, Box 16, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle; Anchorage Daily Times, December 19, 1973, ARO Clipping
Files, Special Collections Division, DPL.
Chapter
Four
1. Hearings on S. 1687, et. al., 1975, p.
240; Interview of Al Henson, June 6, 1983; Cahn, Wild Alaska, p.
15. Secretary Morton's proposals were introduced in 1975 as S. 1687
(Jackson and Fannin, May 8, 1975), H.R. 7990 (Haley, et. al., June 13,
1975), and H.R. 6089 (Sullivan, April 1975). H.R. 9585 (Taylor,
[November] 1975) did not include provisions for refuges and forests, but
was similar in all respects regarding the proposed national parks.
Richard Curry to Legislative Counsel, November 25, 1975, fiche 005, H.R.
2063, 94th Cong., 1st sess., Office of Legislation, WASO.
2. S.1688 (Jackson and Fannin, May, 1975), HR. 2063
(UdaIl, January 23, 1975), and H.R. 9346 (Udall, [1975]); S.2676
(Stevens, November 14, 1975); H.R. 6848 (Young, May 8, 1975); JFSLUPC,
News Release, October 25, 1975, Box 34, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers,
USDI; David S. Jackman to Jay S. Hammond, April 15, 1975
[Recommendations on Developing a State "National Interest" Lands Bill],
State d-2 Bill, Box 40, Ibid.; State of Alaska, "A Preliminary
Proposal Pertaining to National Interest ("D-2") Lands in Alaska under
the Alaska Native Claims Settlement," [1975], Ibid.; Kirk
Marckwald to Mike Lambe, May 21, 1975, fiche 004, H.R. 2063, 94th Cong.,
1st sess, Office of Legislation, WASO; "Comparison of Four Alaska Land
Bills, July 7, 1975, doc. 002671, ANILCA papers, USDI; Steve Silver to
the Commission, September 3, 1975, Land Use Planning Commission, Swem
Papers; University of Alaska, Cooperative Extension Service, Alaska's
National Interest Lands (d-2) A Summary of Current Proposals
[Fairbanks: U. of Alaska, 1975]; T. Stell Newman to Al Henson, December
3, 1975, A-22, NANA, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle.
3. Figures here are from a compilation prepared by
the NPS. They differ, slightly, from those given elsewhere. Kirk
Marckwald to Mike Lambe, May 21, 1975, fiche 004, H.R. 2063, 94th Cong.,
1st sess., Office of Legislation, WASO.
4. Ibid. National Park System units were
Gates of the Arctic N.P. (3,240,000 acres), Kobuk Valley N.M. (150,000
acres), Cape Krusenstern (440,000 acres), Mount Mckinley N.P. additions
(1,400,000 acres), and Wrangell-Saint Elias N.P. (8,640,000 acres).
5. Statement of Don Young in Hearings on S.
1687, et. al., 1975, p. 236; "State Introduces D(2) Proposal,"
[November] 1975, State's position, Swem Papers. Governor Hammond
defended the state's versioncalled the "Alaska Resource
Lands."
The Stevens-Young proposal would have created an "independent
establishment" in the executive branch to administer the areas. The
"Alaska Scenic Reserve Service" would be administered by co-directors,
one appointed by the president with advice and consent of the senate,
the other by the governor of Alaska.
6. "Alaska TripParks and Recreation
Subcommittee Itinerary August 1975," Breedlove Papers, HFC; Swem,
"Outline History," p. 12, Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 15. Additionally
Congressmen Allen Steelman and William Alexander were along part of the
time.
7. "Background," May 10, 1975, Material for meeting
with Director, Henson Papers, Mancos, Colo. Chapter five is a
description of the Service's activities in Alaska from 1974 to 1980.
What follows here is only a brief summary to illustrate actions taken in
preparation for the legislative struggle over Alaska's national interest
lands.
8. Al [Henson] to Ted [Swem], November 9, 1973,
Breedlove Papers, HFC; Theodor Swem to APG, June 12, 1974, L-58,
Environmental matters, Box 17, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle; "National Park Service, Objectives and Goals for Alaska,"
October 18, 1974, D-18, Planning, Programs, and Master Plans, Box 6,
Ibid; "Alaska Planning Group, Goals," October 31, 1974, ANCSA,
1974, Swem Papers; Organization chartAlaska Task Force, [1974] Box
2, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; "Procedures Leading to
the Morton Proposals of 1973 and the September 15, 1977 Andrus Report on
H.R. 39," undated MS, Box 38, NPS, WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Ted
Swem to Ron Walker, October 22, 1974, Alaska Status Reports, Swem
Papers.
9. "Background," May 10, 1975, Material for meeting
with Director, Henson Papers, Mancos; Al [Henson] to Ted [Swem] November
9, 1973, Breedlove Papers, HFC; "National Park Service Objectives and
Goals for Alaska," October 18, 1974, D-18, Planning, Programs, and
Master Plans, Box 6, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle;
Interview of John Kauffmann, December 5, 1983.
10. Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III, October 10,
1983; Al Henson to Ted Swem, March 15, 1973; NPS Recommendations
Regarding ANCSA, Box 5, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle;
National Park Service's Objectives and Goals for Alaska, October 15,
1974, D-18, Planning, Programs, and Master Plans, Box 6, Ibid.;
Russ Dickinson to John Rutter, April 19, 1974, Alaska Organization, NPS,
Swem Papers; Ted Stevens to William J. Whalen, June 22, 1977, Senator
StevensCosts for Lectures on ANCSA, Breedlove Papers, HFC; Cecil
D. Andrus to Don Young, December 1977, Anti-lobbying, NPS WASO Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI; G. Bryan Harry to Roger Contor, July 1, 1977,
Ibid.
Federal Agencies may conduct educational campaigns. They may not, by
law, lobby. It is believed that the Park Service, and Interior
Department, generally observed the spirit as well as the intent of the
law in this case. In 1978, however; the Senate appropriations committee
deleted a House increase of $356,000 for Department of Interior public
affairs, limiting that activity to $454,000. The committee indicated
that it had been done to emphasize the distinction between attempting to
inform and attempting to influence opinion.
11. Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III, October 10,
1983; National Park Service Objectives and Goals for Alaska, October 18,
1974, D-18, Planning, Programs, and Master Plans, Box 6, Alaska Task
Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Ted Stevens to William J. Whalen,
June 22, 1977, Senator StevensCosts for Lectures on ANCSA,
Breedlove Papers, HFC; Interview of A. Durand Jones, May 15, 1983; John
Kauffmann to Area Director, July 1, 1977, GAAR Keyman Files, Box 33,
Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; John Kauffmann, "Noatak,"
The Living Wilderness (Winter 1974-75), pp. 17-33; Eugenia
Horstman Connally, ed., Wilderness Parklands of Alaska
(Washington, D.C. : National Parks and Conservation Association,
1975).
An important example of the combined efforts of the Service and
private sector was "Alaska the Greatland," a collection of NPS color
photographs shown in different cities by the Squibb Company in 1975.
12. Swem, "Outline History," p. 11; Ted Swem to
Gary Everhardt, January 16, 1976, Alaska Status Reports, Swem Papers;
Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III and Theodor R. Swem, January 24,
1984; Interview of A. Durand Jones, May 15, 1983.
13. Harrison Loesch and Nathanial P. Reed to George
Miller, Jr. and Larry M. Oskoloff, December 15; 1972, Doc. no. 002595,
ANILCA Papers, USDI; Royston Hughes to Lee Metcalf, February 10, 1975,
ANCSA-1975, Swem Papers; Michael C.T. Smith to Guy Martin, December 6,
1975, doc. no. 002768, ANILCA Papers, USDI; "Chronology of State
Selections Within Cook Inlet Region," Cook Inlet Lawsuit Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; John Luzader, "Cook Inlet Region, et. al. vs.
Rogers C. B. Morton," 1984. The latter is a distillation of the case
prepared for the author s use by Mr. Luzader.
14. Luzader, "Cook Inlet Region vs. Morton";
"Presentation Before Department of the InteriorCook Inlet,"
December 12, 1972, doc. no. 002700, ANILCA Papers, USDI; USDI, APG, NPS,
Lake Clark National Park A Master Plan (Washington, D.C. : NPS,
1973), p. 73. Cook Inlet claimed on December 17, 1972 that Secretary
Morton had withdrawn 3,894,000 acres. This figure, according to Mr.
Luzader, more closely correspondents to the amount required for
withdrawal, not the amount the Secretary actually withdrew.
15. Luzader, "Cook Inlet Region vs. Morton"; Loesch
and Reed to Miller and Oskoloff, December 15, 1972; "Presentation before
Department of InteriorCook Inlet," December 12, 1972.
16. "ANCSA Related CasesPending,"
RegulationsANCSA, BLM Records, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Douglas
Wheeler to Mr. Johnson, December 3, 1973, doc. 002704, Ibid.;
Paul Kirton to Members, ANCSA Task Force, March 15, 1973, doc. 002712,
Ibid.
Apparently, the Cook Inlet Region filed for summary judgement when
the Interior Department rejected a proposal to release areas within
Kenai National Moose Range. A suit brought by Bristol Bay Regional
Corporation against Cook Inlet Regional Corporation also played a
role.
17. Ted Swem to Ron Walker, July 3, 1974, Alaska
Status Reports, Swem Papers; Status - Cook Inlet Law Suit, March 17,
1974, doc. 002707, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Michael C.T. Smith to Guy
Martin, December 6, 1975, doc. 002768, Ibid.
18. Luzader, "Cook Inlet vs. Morton;" Michael C.T.
Smith to Guy Martin, December 6, 1975, doc. 002768, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
Cook Inlet Region, et. al. v. Rogers C.B. Morton, Memorandum of
Decision, doc. 002729, Ibid.
19. Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III, October 10,
1983; Interview of A. Durand Jones, May 15, 1984; Michael C. T. Smith to
Guy Martin December 6, 1975, doc. 002768, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Roy
Huhndorf to Lloyd Meeds, September 29, 1975, doc. 002749, Ibid.;
Terms and Conditions for Land Consolidation and Management in the Cook
Inlet Area, December 10, 1975, doc. 002772, Ibid.; Federal-state
Land Use Planning Commission for Alaska, Cook Inlet Report
(Anchorage, 1976); U.S., Congress, House, Committee on Interior and
Insular Affairs, Legislative History P.L. 94-204, 94th
Cong., 1st sess., 1975. House Report No. 94-729; U.S., Congress, Senate,
A Bill to Provide Under or by Amendment of the Alaska Natives Claims
Settlement Act, for the Late Enrollment of Certain Natives, to
Establishment of an Escrow Account for the Proceeds of Certain Lands,
the Treatment of Certain Payments and Grants, and the Consolidation of
Existing Regional Corporations, and for other purposes, 94th Cong.,
2nd sess., 1976, S.1469.
20. Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III, October 10,
1983; Interview of A. Durand Jones, May 15, 1984; Memorandum of
Agreement Between the Secretary of the Interior and Cook Inlet Region,
Inc., September 29, 1975, doc. 002750, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Roy Huhndorf
to Roy Taylor, April 1, 1976, doc. 002196; A. Durand Jones to Deputy
Director, April 15, 1976, Legislation, Stenmark Files, HFC; Ted Swem to
Gary Everhardt, January 16, 1976, Alaska Status Reports, Swem
Papers.
21. Ben Thompson to Regional Directors, September
15, 1958, L-58, Box 001221, RG 79, FARC, San Bruno; untitled MS by
Richard Gordon, March 12, 1969, ARO Central Files - Inactive, ARO.
22. Jack Hession to Bob Weedon and Jim Kowalsky
(with copy to the Alaska Task Force), November 15, 1974, "To do
eventually" file, Henson Papers, Mancos.
23. Ibid.
24. USDI, NPS, Alaska Area Office, "Lake Clark
National Park Alternative Study," January 20, 1976, pp. 1,S, Lake Clark
misc., Lake Clark Keyman Files, Box 43, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79,
FARC, Seattle. Mining in the listed areas was guaranteed by the proposed
1976 legislation. New mining entries would not be allowed.
25. Ibid., Interview of John Kauffmann,
December 5, 1983; G. Bryan Harry to Special Assistant to the Director,
January 20, 1976, Lake Clark misc., Lake Clark Keyman Files, RG 79,
FARC, Seattle; John Kauffmann to Area Director, January 31, 1977, doc.
002665, ANILCA Papers, USDI. Al Henson agreed with Harry regarding
subsistence.
26. Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III and Theodor
R. Swem, January 24, 1984. Byron, it will be recalled, was one of the
Congressmen who traveled to Alaska with Congressman John Seiberling the
previous summer.
It has not been possible to determine the exact date that WASO
accepted the recommendations, nor the date Swem and Bohlen approached
Byron. The latter occurred, however, only a short time before Swem
retired on the last day of February 1976.
27. Richard C. Curry to Legislative Counsel, March
29, 1976, Legislative Support Data Books, Aniakchak Caldera National
Monument, ARO; "A Bill to Establish the Lake Clark National Park and
Preserve, Aniakchak Caldera National Monument and Preserve and Harding
Icefield-Kenai Fjords National Monument and other purposes," draft,
March 18, 1976, Ibid.; "Acreage with indefinite status on
remaining NPS Proposals," September 14, 1973, ANCSA Implementation,
January-September 1973, Swem Papers.
In all areas, land problems had only recently been solved. At
Aniakchak, PL 94-204 had resolved the 300,000-acre dual withdrawal (NPS
and Koniag Corporation). At Kenai Fjords the Chugach Natives had decided
not to select the acreage reserved for that purpose. The land between
the three separate units of the proposed monument, as a result, became
available. The proposal here was for a 1,000,000-acre monument.
28. Representative William Alexander introduced a
similar bill the next year, providing for a 7,500,000-acre Lake Clark
National Park. In 1977 Congressman John Seiberling and Senator Abourezk
introduced bills providing for the establishment of Admiralty Island
National Preserve (H.R. 5605, March 24, 1977 and S.1546 May 17, 1977).
The Carter administration first raised the possibility of using the
preserve category in Alaska when Secretary of the Interior Cecil D.
Andrus and Curtis Bohlen appeared before the House Subcommittee on
General Oversight and Alaska Lands on April 25, 1977. As late as
September 1977, long debates regarding the utility of the preserve went
on in the administration. Hearings on H.R. 39, et. al.,
1977, II: 152; Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III, October 10, 1983;
Interview of Roger Contor by Frank Williss, November 2, 1983; John D.
Hough to Secretary [Andrus], July 8, 1977, Box 23, NPS WASO Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI; Daily LogAssistant to the Director for Alaska
[Roger Contor], December 6, 1976, Office of the Regional Director, ARO;
James A. Joseph to APG members, July 26, 1977, doc. no. 000569, ANILCA
Papers, USDI.
29. Deputy Assistant Secretary Bohlen took over
Swem's job as chairman of the APG. In May James M. Lambe of the
Service's Office of Legislation became NPS representative on the APG
until a new assistant to the director for Alaska could be named.
Interview of Theodor R. Swem, June 8, 1983; Interview of William C.
Everhart, June 29, 1984; Interview of James M. Lambe, December 8, 1983;
Nathaniel P. Reed to Directors, NPS, BOR, FWS, March 3, 1976, ANCSA
Implementation 1975-76, Swem Papers; WASO Directorate to Acting
Assistant to the Director for Alaska, July 1, 1976, A-58, Proposed
Areas, ARO Central Files-Inactive, ARO.
30. See for example, Bob Utley to Bryan Harry,
February 26, 1976, A-16, Advisory Council, Box 1, Alaska Task Force
Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Interview of John Rutter, May 16, 1984;
Interview of John Cook, January 26, 1984; Interview of Stanley T.
Albright June 29, 1984. This problem is discussed in chapter V.
31. WASO Directorate to Acting Assistant to the
Director for Alaska, July 1, 1976, AK-58, Proposed Areas, ARO Central
Files-Inactive, ARO; Gary Everhardt to All Employees, November 26, 1976,
Ibid.; Interview of Roger J. Contor, November 2, 1983; Activity
Report No. 22, Assistant to the Director for Alaska, November 2, 1977
[Alaska Program 1978 Goals], Box 23, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers,
USDI.
32. FWP Weekly Report, June 20, 1979, Box 14, NPS
WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Interview of Roger J. Contor, November
2, 1983.
33. Bob Belous to Al Henson, November 18, 1976, Box
38, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
34. Federal-state Land Use Planning Commission for
Alaska, Tentative Recommendations for National Interest Lands (D-2)
in Alaska (Anchorage: FSLUPC, April 21, 1976) p. 3. The twelve park
system units recommended included an Alatna National Preserve (470,000
acres), Chitina National Preserve (1,090,000 acres), and a 30,000-acre
addition to Glacier Bay. Noatak, Chukchi-Imuruk, and Harding
Icefield-Kenai Fjords were not included.
35. The wilderness study areas were included as
part of the 31,300,000 acres of National Land Reserves.
36. Harry B. Crandell to Stewart Brandborg,
December 7, 1974, Conservationists Involvement in Alaska-TWS thru 1975,
Swem Papers; Rich Gordon to Conservationists, February 23, 1975, Box 1,
Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; A Report of the Second
Alaska Coalition Meeting on the National Interest Lands, McKinley Park
Hotel, Mckinley Park Alaska, May 15-16, 1976, Alternative Proposals,
Yukon-Charley Keyman Files, Box 46, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79,
FARC, Seattle; Swem Diary, January 15, 1976; Saving Our Alaska
Heritage, The Wilderness Society's Action Plan, April 18, 1977, Box
19, Alaska Coalition Papers; Cahn, Wild Alaska, pp. 13-14.
37. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 15; Lappen, "Whose
Promised Land?" pp. 128-29; Interview of Harry Crandell, December 7,
1983. President Carter reaffirmed this position in his first message on
the environment when he said "No conservative action of the 95th
congress could have a more lasting value than this." U.S. Congress,
House, Message From the President of the United States Transmitting
Proposals for Dealing with a Variety of Environmental Issues, House
Doc. 95-160, 95th Cong., 1st sess. May 23, 1977. House Doc. no.
95-160.
38. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 15.
39. Daily Log, Assistant to the Director for
Alaska, April 4, 1977; Interview of Cynthia Wilson by Frank Williss,
December 6, 1983; Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III, October 10, 1979;
Interview of Theodor R. Swem, June 8, 1983; Interview of A. Durand
Jones, May 15, 1983; Interview of Al Henson, June 6, 1983; Jack Hession,
Ted Whitesell and David Finklestein to Alaska Coalition, October 26,
1976 [Resource data supporting conservationists' proposals], Box 12,
Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle.
40. Cahn, Wild Alaska, P. 15; Alaska
National Interest Lands Conservation Act, The Conservationists' Alaska
Coalition Bill, January 1977, Lake ClarkConservationists'
proposals, Park Files, Headquarters, Lake Clark National Park and
Preserve, Anchorage.
41. U.S. Congress, House, A Bill to designate
certain lands in the state of Alaska as units of the National Park,
National Wildlife Refuge, Wild and Scenic Rivers, and National
Wilderness Preservation System, and for other purposes H.R. 39, 95th
Cong., 1st sess., 1977; Congressional Record, House, January 4,
1977, p. 261; Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 16. The large number of
co-sponsors was a result, largely, of the work of the Alaska Coalition.
The conservationists hoped to convince Congress of broad support for a
strong Alaska lands bill by the large number of co-sponsors. Some
believe that this tactic is a mistake that telegraphs the support for a
bill.
42. S.1500 (Metcalf, May 12, 1977); S.500 (Jackson
and Hansen, January 28, 1977). Also H.R. 2876 (Udall, et. al., February
1, 1977), H.R. 1974 (Udall, January 17, 1977), and H.R. 5505 (Quillan,
March 23, 1977); Robert Cahn, "The Race to Save Wild Alaska," Living
Wilderness, (July-Sept 1977), p. 16. Senator Metcalf's bill went
beyond H.R. 39, to propose establishment of four additional wilderness
units, and protection of other areas until studied.
43. Both Katmai and Glacier Bay would be
re-designated national parks.
44. Evidence suggests that the preserves outlined
in H.R. 39 differed from those already in existence in the "Lower
48"Big Thicket and Big Cypress. The latter were areas set aside
for preservation of the natural values they contained, while allowing
for other uses as long as those uses did not affect these values. In
H.R. 39, preserves, with the possible exception of Noatak, seem to have
been essentially national parks that allowed sport hunting.
45. Included in forest wilderness areas were Nellie
Juan (1,000,000) Yakutat Foreland (300,000), West Chichagof-Yakobi
(400,000), Admiralty Island (1,000,000), Stikine-Le Conte (300,000), and
Misty Fjords (2,400,000).
Wilderness studies had been conducted at existing NPS areas, although
these studies did not include all lands within those parks designated
for wilderness in H.R. 39. Bryan Harry to Chief, Office of Legislation,
March 3, 1977, ANCSA-1977, Swem Papers.
46. Congressional Record, House, January 4,
1977, E261; Morris Udall to Bob Georgine and Executive Council, November
15, 1977, AK-5, Crandell Papers .
47. This is not to suggest that Alaskan
conservationists were of one mind. Quite the contrary is true. A number
professed shock at the scale of the bill. Dale Bondurant, of the
Anchorage Izaak Walton League spoke out forcibly against the protection
of hunting for what he called a "special group" [Native
subsistence].
48. Tundra Times, April 20, 1977, Belous
Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, DPL.
49. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 19; Fairbanks
Daily News-Miner, October 17, 1978, Belous Clipping Files,
Special Collections Division, DPL; "Statement of Policy for Citizens for
Management of Alaska Lands," undated MS, A-94, CMAL, Box 3, Alaska Task
Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle.
50. Statement by U.S. Senator Ted Stevens, June 30,
1977, Congressional and committee membership and governors, Box 21,
Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Tentative 17(d)(2) Lands
Proposal presented by: Governor Jay Hammond, Senator Ted Stevens,
Congressman Don Young, March 1977, Belous Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
Senator Mike Gravel, who called it a "Republican d-2 bill" refused to
co-sponsor. According to Senator Stevens, however, Senator Gravel
favored the co-management approach embodied in the bill. S.E. Alaskan
Empire, June 30, 1977, AK-7, Ibid.
51. U. S. Congress, Senate, A Bill Relating to
the Classification of Certain Lands within the state of Alaska and for
other Purposes, S.1787, 95th Cong., 1st. sess., 1977; Statement of
U.S. Senator Ted Stevens, June 30, 1977, Congressional and Committee
membership and Senators, Box 21, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle; Summary of Tentative d-2 Position, presented by Governor Jay
Hammond, et. al, March 26, 1977, AK-5, Crandell Papers; Federal State
Land Use Planning Commission, Area Maps of Proposals Affecting
National Interest Lands (d-2) in Alaska, January 1978, Belous Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI. The core park areas, as well as those of other
agencies were to be designated, but not formally dedicated, until the
year 2000. The delay would allow for uses not allowed under traditional
management.
52. NPS-managed federal cooperative lands would be
Katmai (1,590,000), Gates of the Arctic (3,550,000), Mt. McKinley
(1,960,000), Wrangell-St. Elias (8, 740,000), Lake Clark (3,490,000) and
Charley River (900,000).
53. J. Fred Eubanks to Bryan Harry, February 23,
1977, doc. no., 003340, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Marcus P. Malik to Bryan
Harry, Feb. 18, 1977, doc. 003347, Ibid.; Bob Belous to Bryan
Harry, Feb. 18, 1977, doc. 003346, Ibid.; Interview of Robert
Belous by Frank Williss August 6, 1984; Bryan Harry to Chief, Office of
Legislation, March 3, 1977, ANCSA1977, Swem Papers; Interview of
Roger Contor, November 2, 1983.
54. Statement of Cecil B. Andrus, Secretary of the
Interior to the House Subcommittee on General Oversight and Alaska
Lands, April 25, 1977, Belous Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
Hearings on H. R. 39, et. al., 1977, II:152; ANCSA (d-2)
Proposals, 5/20/77, Box 38, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI. The
Morton Proposals had been reintroduced as S.499 (Jackson, January, 28,
1977), H.R. 6564 (Murphy, April 22, 1977). Additionally, Representative
John Dingall had introduced H.R. 1652, a bill proposing to set aside
some 68,000,000 acres in wildlife refuges in Alaska.
55. Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III, October 10,
1983; Interview of Harry Crandell, December 7, 1983; Swem, "Outline
History," p. 13; Daily LogAssistant to the Director for Alaska
[Roger Contor], Office of the Regional Director, ARO. By Sept. 1,
Crandell indicated Secretary Andrus was "shooting for 95 million acres.
"
56. James A. Joseph to Solicitor, et. al.,
May 4, 1977, doc. no. 000540 ANILCA Papers, USDI; Chris Farrand to
Curtis Bohlen and Heather Ross, March 3, 1977, Box 38, NPS WASO Files,
Ibid.; Richard A. Baenen to Cecil D. Andrus, March 21, 1977, doc.
no. 000530, Ibid.; Raymond Butler to Cecil D. Andrus, February
25, 1977, doc. no. 000488, Ibid.; USDI, News Release, April 22,
1977, ANCSA Implementation1977, Swem Papers; Harry Crandell to
John Seiberling, May 23, 1977, AK-5, Crandell Papers; Interview of
Curtis E. Bohlen, III, October 10, 1983; Interview of James M. Lambe,
December 8, 1983.
The scope of the activities of the APG was considerably reduced by
April. Originally, Andrus indicated that its jurisdiction would go
beyond d-2. Nevertheless, one indication of the importance of the
decision to control the Interior's d-2 effort at the departmental level,
came when James M. Lambe, a long-time NPS official and presently chief
of the NPS's WASO Division of Legislation, temporarily left the Service
to become Bohlen's assistant. Lambe took the job, recognizing that the
most significant activities would take place at the departmental
level.
57. "Efforts by Assistant Secretary Herbst and
staff on behalf of the National Interest in Alaska Natural Resources, "
undated MS [after October 2, 1980], Box 38, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Curtis Bohlen to Director, U. S. Fish and Wildlife
Service, March 30, 1977, doc. 000753, Ibid.; Bohlen to Assistant
Secretary of Agriculture for Conservation, Research, and Education [with
identical letters to Bureau of Mines, Geological Survey, Bureau of Land
Management, and Bureau of Indian Affairs], May 20, 1977, doc. no.
000752, Ibid.
58. M. Rupert Cutler to Curtis Bohlen June 8, 1977,
doc. 000543, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Daily LogAssistant to the
Director for Alaska [Roger Contor], Office of the Regional Director,
ARO. One reason for this approach was to avoid the lengthy formal review
process required by OMB. The Department did conduct briefings for
OMB.
59. "Management of Federal Lands in Alaska,"
January 24, 1977, 2650-Alaska Native Selections, BLM Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; "Summary Alaska Conservation Areas," March 18, 1977, Box
21, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; "Criteria for Federal
Land Use Determinations in Alaska," March 11, 1977, Ibid.
National Park System areas proposed were: Gates of the Arctic (5,400,000
acres), Kobuk Valley (140,000 acres), Cape Krusenstern (200,000 acres),
Wrangell-Kluane (10,000,000 acres), Lake Clark (3,500,000 acres),
Aniakchak Caldera (400,000), and Marsh Fort-Chamberlain [portion of
Arctic National Wildlife Range] (1,100,000 acres).
60. Chris Carlson to the Secretary [Cecil Andrus],
March 24, 1977, doc. no. 000535, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Interview of
Curtis E. Bohlen, III, October 10, 1983; Interview of A. Durand Jones,
May 15, 1984; "BLM Plan Draws Ire," Fairbanks Daily News Miner,
March 28, 1977; Legislation 1977, Box 21, Alaska Task Force Files, RG
79, FARC, Seattle; "End Run by BLM on D-2," Anchorage Daily News,
March 26, 1977, Ibid; "BLM details its d-2 Land Plan," Fairbanks Daily
News Miner, March 25, 1977, Ibid. The premature release of
the BLM's plan was not accidental.
61. Daily LogAssistant to the Director for
Alaska, December 1-3, 1976, Office of the Regional Director, ARO;
Interview of Roger Contor, November 2, 1983; Interview of James Pepper,
November 8, 1983. "Keyman" was the title of the NPS planner responsible
for a given area. They had been hired during late spring 1975. See pp.
246-48; 256-58.
62. Stell Newman to Roger Contor, April 4, 1977,
0060-Boundaries, Box 25, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle;
WEB [William E. Brown], Ideal Boundary for YUCL Proposal, February 16,
1977, Resources, Cape Krusenstern (1977), and Gates of the Arctic,
(1977), Breedlove Papers, HFC. Similar maps were prepared for all
areas.
63. Interview of Al Henson, June 6, 1983; Interview
of A. Durand Jones, May 15, 1984; Interview of James Pepper, November 8,
1983; Activity Report No. 20, Assistant to the Director for Alaska,
September 27, 1977. Roger Contor, Assistant to the Director for Alaska,
was traveling in Alaska when the presentations were made to Director
Whalen, and had no opportunity to participate in the decision
making.
64. William J. Whalen to Assistant Secretary, FWP
[Herbst], August 12, 1977, Breedlove Papers, HFC. Two reports were
forwarded to Herbst on August 12. One addressed an Alaska d-2 Issue
Paper drafted by the Special Assistant to the Secretary for Alaska
[Curtis Bohlen]. The second was a report on H.R. 39.
The Service recommended that Mount McKinley National Park be renamed
Denali National Park" (as did H . R 39), a Native name for the mountain,
and the park name first suggested by Charles Sheldon. Bering Land Bridge
had been previously Chukchi-Imuruk. The name change, which was suggested
by T. Stell Newman, keyman for the area, was designed to better describe
park values in the area. At the same time, it is unlikely that Newman
could have missed the fact that the name "Bering Land Bridge" had a
public relations appeal that Chukchi-Imuruk would never have.
65. Theodor R. Swem to Curtis Bohlen, November 5,
1973 [Policy issues relative to Alaska proposals], Swem Correspondence,
July 1973-December 1973, HFC; Robert Belous, "Subsistence Use of New
Parklands in Alaska (An Interim Report)," November 10, 1973,
L3505-Subsistence, Box 16, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle.
>66. See, for example, Theodor R. Swem to Curtis
Bohlen, November 5, 1973, Swem Correspondence, July-December 1973, HFC;
Robert Belous, "Subsistence Use of New Parklands in Alaska (An Interim
Report)," November 10, 1973, L3505-subsistence, Box 16 Alaska Task Force
Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Robert Belous to Planners and Professional
Staff, ATO [position working paper on subsistence policy], September 9,
1975, Ibid; T. Stell Newman to Roger Contor, April 13, 1977, Box
1, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
67. Interview of Roger Contor, November 2, 1983;
Interview of Bill Reffalt, December 9, 1983.
68. Interview of Roger Contor, November 2, 1983;
Interview of Bill Reffalt, December 9, 1983; Interview of Curtis E.
Bohlen, III and Theodor R. Swem, January 24, 1984; Interview of James
Pepper, November 8, 1983; Interview of A. Durand Jones, May 15, 1984;
Harvey K. Nelson to Deputy Director, et. al., April 22, 1977, Box
38, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
In addition, a February 27, 1976 amendment to the National Wildlife
Refuge Administration Act, included a provision that ruled out joint
administration of wildlife refuge lands. This brought into question the
joint management proposals in the Morton recommendations. Interview of
Christine Enright by Frank Williss, August 17, 1983.
69. Interview of Roger Contor, November 2, 1983;
Interview of Bill Reffalt December 9, 1983; Interview of A. Durand
Jones, May 15, 1984; Interview of James Pepper, November 8, 1983; Daily
Log-Assistant to the Director for Alaska, August 17, 1977; Bill Reffalt
to Harvey, Gene, and Mike, September 22, 1977, Box 39, NPS WASO Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI; Reffalt to Clay Hardy, July 13, 1977, Ibid;
[ ] Nadeau to Bill [Reffalt], July 6, 1977, Ibid; Bob Herbst's
Blackboard Decisions, August 18, 1977, Jones Files; Richard Myshak to
Directors, NPS, BOR, FWS, August 7, 1977; Ibid. It has not been
possible to locate the Fish and Wildlife Service's August 1977
recommendations. However, estimates of the total acreage vary between
69,000,000 and 79,000,000 acres.
At one point in the process of reevaluating management systems,
moreover, the FWS had considered a boundary of Iliamna that included
nearly half of the proposed Lake Clark National Park.
70. Interviews of Contor, Reffalt, Pepper, and
Jones; Bob Herbst's Blackboard Decisions, August 18, 1977; Myshak to
Directors, NPS FWS, August 19, 1977; Daily Log, Assistant to the
Director for Alaska, August 17, 1971. On August 17, the Park Service had
agreed to give up the Noatak. This decision was reversed.
71. Robert L. Herbst to Secretary Andrus, et.
al., August 23, 1971, doc. no. 000584, ANILCA Papers, USDI. Herbst
recommended setting aside 49,619,000 acres for inclusion in the National
Wildlife Refuge System, and 2,000,000 acres in the Wild and Scenic
Rivers System. No final recommendation was presented for Admiralty
Island (813,000 acres), although three options were listed: 1)
Management by the NPS as a National Preserve, 2) Wildlife Refuge, 3)
Forest Service Wilderness area. The options were listed in priority
order, subject to discussions with the Secretary of Agriculture.
72. "Efforts by Assistant Secretary Herbst and
staff on behalf of (the National Interest) in Alaska Natural Resources,"
undated MS [after October 10, 1980], Box 38, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Guy Martin to Cynthia Wilson, August 26, 1977, doc. no.
000591, Ibid.; "FWP Rebuttal to 8/2S LW Comments," undated MS,
doc. no. 000594, Ibid; USDI, Alaska Policy Group, Decision
meeting, Alaska D-2," August 26, 1977, doc. no. 000604, Ibid;
Cynthia Wilson to Solicitor, et. al., August 29, 1977, Box 12, NPS WASO
Files, Ibid.; Ronald K. Peterson to Federal-State Land Use
Planning Commission, Departments of Interior, Transportation, Justice,
et. al., September 9, 1977, doc. no. 000685, Ibid.; Commissioner
of Natural Resources, State of Alaska to Alaska Planning Group, August
25, 1977 [state comments on Herbst proposal], doc. 000596, Ibid.;
"Department of the Interior Recommended Amendments to H.R. 39, Proposed
Alaska National Interest Lands Act," September 13, 1977, Box S, NPS WASO
Files, Ibid.; USDI, News Release, September 15, 1977, doc. no.
000709, Ibid; Cecil D. Andrus to Undersecretary, et. al., Box 12,
NPS WASO Files, Ibid.
73. USDI, News Release, September 15, 1977; Summary
Sheet National Park Service Proposals for Alaska, September 15, 1977,
doc. no. 000709, ANILCA Papers, USDI; "Administration Recommendations
for National Wildlife Refuges, Parks, Forests, and Wild and Scenic
Rivers, in Response to H.R. 39, September 15, 1977", (Illustration 12), map in Technical
Information Center, Denver Service Center.
74. Department of the Interior Recommended
Amendments to H.R. 39, proposed "Alaska National Interest Lands
Conservation Act," September 20, 1977, Box 38, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; "Analysis of Andrus D-2 Package," undated MS, AK-5,
Crandell Papers; Interview of James M. Lambe, December 8, 1983.
75. See Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 20.
76. Governor Hammond called the plan a "centerpiece
upon which those seeking a responsible solution to d-2 can focus, " and
the JFSLUPC gave its "general backing." On the other hand, the U.S.
Chamber of Commerce, urged on by the Citizens for the Management of
Alaska's Land, sought unsuccessfully to prevent the Department from
testifying on H.R. 39 without completing additional environmental impact
statements. Anchorage Daily News, October 14, 1977, ARO Clipping
Files, Special Collections, DPL; Fairbanks Daily News-Miner,
November 18, 1977, ARO Clipping Files, Ibid.; Activity Report no.
20, Assistant to the Director for Alaska, September 27, 1977, Box 39,
ANILCA papers, USDI.
77. Presidential Option Paper, September 10, 1977,
doc. no. 000707, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Department of the Interior,
Proposed Additions to the National Park System, September 12, 1977, Box
3, d-2 Legislation, NPS WASO Files; Department of the Interior, Proposed
Additions to the National Park System, September 13, 1977, Briefing
Book-1977, Box 4, Ibid; Interview of Roger Contor, November 2,
1983; Interview of James Pepper, November 8, 1983.
The Interior Department had unsuccessfully negotiated with the
Agriculture on this matter, and had proposed the same compromise during
meetings with OMB on September 10. The Department of Agriculture refused
the proposed compromise. The issue was one of several carried to
President Carter, who decided in favor of Secretary Andrus on September
14.
78. Comments by John F. Seiberling,
Congressional Record, House, December 15, 1977; Hearings
on H.R. 39, V:21, XII:15 and XIII:221-22. See also Cahn, Wild
Alaska, pp. 18-19; Lappen, "Whose Promised Land?" pp. 143-44.
79. Hearings on H.R. 39, et. al., 1977,
passim; Cahn, "Fight to Save Wild Alaska," p. 19; "Juneau
D-2 Testimony Balanced Between Pro and Anti-Wilderness," S.E. Alaska
Empire, July 8, 1977, AK-5, Crandell Papers; "Mixed views on d-2,"
Anchorage Daily News, August 22, 1977, Ibid; "A d-2 field
Journal," Alaska Advocate, August 25, 1977, Ibid. In
Anchorage, some fifty-one percent generally favored the general
principles in H.R. 39, while in Fairbanks two-thirds opposed. Activity
report No. 20, Assistant to the Director for Alaska, September 27, 1977,
Box 23, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
80. Interview of Harry Crandell, December 7, 1983;
Seiberling Plans D2 Amendments," Anchorage Times, July 8, 1977,
AK-5, Crandell Papers; Seiberling will Amend law to allow wilderness
mining," Ketchikan Daily News, July 8, 1977, Ibid.; "Udall
'we probably chewed off too much instant wilderness,'" Fairbanks
Daily News-Miner, August 20, 1977, Ibid.; "D2 Hearing
Ended; Udall Says Bill to be Scaled Down," Anchorage Times,
August 22, 1977, Ibid.
81. Cynthia Wilson to Alaska Working Group, October
14, 1977, doc. no. 000808, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Cynthia Wilson to
Undersecretary, et. al., October 25, 1977, doc. no. 000764,
Ibid.; H. R. 39 [Committee Print, October 12, 1977]; H.R. 39
[Committee Print], October 18, 1977; [Alaska National Interest Lands
Print no. 2, October 28, 1977]; Comparison of the House Interior Print
Neptune for H.R. 39 with the Administration Position of September 15,
1977, Legislation, Box 4, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; U.S.,
Congress, House, Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, Alaska
National Interest Lands Conservation Act of 1978, Report of the
Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, . . . together with
Additional, Dissenting, and Supplemental Views and Additional Comments
to Accompany H.R. 39, 95th Cong., 1st sess., 1978, part 1, p.
77.
82. Don Young to Members, Subcommittee on General
Oversight and Alaska Lands, October 17, 1977, Legislation,
September-October 1977, Box 4, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; John
F. Seiberling, Teno Roncalio, and Philip Burton, "Supplemental
ViewsWrangell-St. Elias Park/Perserve in Report to Accompany
H.R. 39, April 7, 1978, part 1, pp. 389-89; Statement of John F.
Seiberling, Congressional Record, House, December 15, 1977,
reproduced in John F. Seiberling to "Dear Colleague," January 12, 1978,
Crandell Papers.
83. Other interest groupsconservationists,
Natives, state, and JFSLUPCalso had input. See, for example,
Deborah von Hoffman to James Joseph, February 6, 1976, Doc. no. 000261,
ANILCA Papers, USDI.
84. Cecil B. Andrus to John F. Seiberling, January
13, 1978, Crandell Papers; H.R. 39 [Committee Print No. 2] October 28,
1977.
85. Activity Report No. 23, Assistant to the
Secretary for Alaska, November 22, 1971, Box 23, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Report on H.R. 39, April 7, 1978, part 1, p. 77;
John F. Seiberling to "Dear Colleague," January 12, 1977, Crandell
Papers; Cynthia Wilson to Under-secretary, et. al., February 13,
1978, doc. no. 000775, ANILCA Papers, USDI; National Park System
Proposals, Summary of Subcommittee Recommendations, January 25, 1978,
Box 18, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; H. R. 39,
[Subcommittee Print showing the substitute adopted by the Subcommittee
on General Oversight and Alaska Lands], February 10, 1978.
86. Meeds 'd-2' Proposal," undated MS, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; "An Alaskan Brawl Envelops Meeds," Seattle
Post-Intelligencer, December 24, 1977, Ibid.; "Young Loses
on d-2 vote," Fairbanks Daily News-Miner, January 18, 1978 and
"Panel Rejects Meeds' Proposal." Anchorage Times, January 18,
1978, Crandell Papers; Alaska Briefing Papers-Alaska Lands Legislative
History, undated MS, [1979], Belous Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
Interview of James Pepper, November 8, 1983. Meeds proposal, which was
written in close cooperation with the staff of the JFSLUPC, would be
subsequently introduced as H.R. 10467 (January 19, 1978), H.R. 10888
(February 9, 1978), and H.R. 12703 (May 12, 1978). It was intended as a
compromise between the Alaska congressional delegation's position and
H.R. 39. In addition to establishing a "national wildlands category,
Meeds attempted to reduce "instant wilderness" to 10,000,000 acres, give
the Secretary of the Interior discretionary authority to allow
transportation corridors, and allow the "carefully controlled"
exploration and extraction of oil and gas on all lands except parks,
monuments and wilderness areas.
87. Congressional Record, House, May 18,
1978, p. 4234-235.
88. Briefing Papers-Alaska Lands Legislation
Legislative History, undated MS, [1979], Belous Files, ANILCA Papers,
USDI; Congressional Record, House, May 18, 1978, p. 4237.
89. Report on H.R. 39, April 7, 1978, pp.
388-89. Cecil Andrus to Morris Udall, March 2, 1978, ANILCA Papers,
USDI. The committee did place Kantishna Hills in Denali National
Preserve rather than in the park, and transferred 1,000,000 acres from
park to preserve status in the Wrangells, opening, according to John
Seiberling, Teno Roncalio, and Phillip Burton, most of the usable,
accessible area to sport hunting and possibly other incompatible
uses.
90. Morris K. Udall to James J. Delaney, April 16,
1978, Crandell Papers; Report to Accompany on H.R. 39, pp.
253-55. The total acreage recommended for preserves was some 2,500,000
acres more than that recommended by the administration
91. Report to Accompany H.R. 39, April 7,
1978, part 1, pp. 137, 146, and passim; Interview of Harry
Crandell, December 7, 1983.
92. U.S. Congress, House, Committee on Merchant
Marine and Fisheries, Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act
of 1978: Report Together with Additional, Dissenting, and Supplemental
Views and Additional Comments to Accompany H.R. 39, 95th Cong., 2d
sess., 1978, H.R. 96-1045, Part II, pp. 31-34; John Seiberling and
Morris Udall to Thomas P. O'Neil, Jr., February 9, 1978, AK-S Crandell
Papers. The 1973 Morton proposals had been jointly referred to the two
committees.
93. Report to Accompany H.R. 39, May 4,
1978, Part II, pp. 3-5, 35. Included among the refuges were a
22,500,000-acre North Slope National Wildlife Refuge (National Petroleum
Reserve-Alaska), and Copper River National Wildlife Refuge, an area the
Interior Department had recommended be managed by the Forest
Service.
94. U.S. Congress, House, A Bill to Designate
Certain Lands in the State of Alaska as Units of the National Park,
National Wildlife Refuge, Wild and Scenic Rivers and National Wilderness
Preservation Systems, and for other Purposes, H.R. 12625, 95th
Cong., 2nd sess., 1978; speech of Morris Udall, Congressional
Record, House, May 17, 1978, p. 4090. Substitutes are often given
the number of the original bill, depending upon a ruling from the chair.
Because H.R. 39 was identified around the nation with the Alaska lands
issue, it was particularly important to supporters to maintain that
number.
95. Congressional Record, House, May 17,
1978, p. 4088; Cahn, Wild Alaska, pp. 19-21; Interview with James
Pepper, November 9, 1983.
96. Congressional Record, House, May 18,
1978, pp. 4235-4256. Among deletions in the Young amendment, which
failed by a vote of 251-141, were 200,000 acres in Gates of the Arctic,
150,000 in Lake Clark, and 150,000 in Noatak.
97. Congressional Record, House, May 19,
1978; pp. 4238-4239.
98. Additionally, lands adjacent to the proposed
Noatak National Preserve east of the main channel of the Noatak River
would automatically become part of that proposal if not conveyed to the
village of Noatak.
99. The figures given for additions to the refuge
system are approximate, and involved a north slope wildlife refuge
(National Petroleum Reserve-Alaska) that totalled some 23,300,000
acres.
100. U.S., Congress, House, An Act to Designate
Certain Lands in the State of Alaska as Units of the National Park, . .
. and for other Purposes, H.R. 39, 95th Cong., 2nd sess., May 19,
1978; Richard O. Curry to Director, May 24, 1978, Secretary of the
Interior, Denali Keyman Files, Box 28, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79,
FARC, Seattle.
101. Ibid.
102. Ibid.
103. U.S., Congress, Senate, A Bill to
designate certain lands in the State of Alaska as units of the National
Park, . . . to establish a Federal-state Land Use Planning Commission,
to establish procedures for the management of fish and wildlife on
public lands in Alaska, and for other purposes, S.2944, 95th Cong.,
2nd sess., April 19,1978; Anchorage Daily News, May 11, 1978,
Crandell Papers; Fairbanks Daily News-Miner, June 28, 1978, ARO
Clipping File, Special Collections Division, DPL: Fairbanks Daily
News-Miner July 12, 1978, Ibid.; The Washington Post,
May 20, 1978, Crandell Papers.
104. "Stevens sees no rush on new federal parks,"
Anchorage Daily News, August 9, 1977 and the Washington
Post, May 20, 1978, Crandell Papers.
105. Anchorage Daily News, May 11, 1978,
Ibid. ; Fairbanks Daily News Miner, June 6, 1978, ARO
Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, DPL; Anchorage
Times, September 8, 1978, Box 1, Alaska Coalition Papers.
106. Hearings on S.1787, . . . et.
al., 1975; U.S. Congress, Senate, Alaska Natural Resource Issues and
Alaska National Interest Lands Legislative Hearings on S. 499 . . ,
et. al., 95th Cong., 2nd sess, 1978; U.S., Congress, Senate,
Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, Alaska National Interest
Lands Workshops, 95th Cong., 2nd sess., 1978.
107. Report to Accompany H.R. 39, 1978, p.
112.
108. U.S., Congress, Senate, Designating
Certain Lands in the State of Alaska as Units of the
National Park, National Wildlife Refuge, National Wild and Scenic
Rivers, and National Wilderness Preservation Systems, and for
other purposes, Report together with Minority, Additional and
Supplemental Views to Accompany H.R. 39, 95th Cong., 2nd sess., 197
S. Rept. 95-1300, p. 112. In addition to H.R. 39, other bills before the
Senate were S.499, S.500 (Jackson, January 28, 1977), S.1500 (Metcalf,
May 12, 1977), Amendment no. 2176 to S. 1500 (Durkin, May 16, 1978), 5.
1783 (Stevens, June 30, 1977), S.2944 (Gravel, April 15, 1978), and S.
2465 (Jackson, January 31, 1978 [proposals of the Carter
Administration]). Related bills were S.1546 (Abourezk), S.3016 (Gravel
and Stevens), and S.3303 [proposed by the Administration, containing
provisions to improve implementation of ANCSA].
109. Ibid.; Fairbanks Daily
News-Miner, June 28, 1978, ARO Clipping Files, Special Collections
Division, DPL.
110. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 21. The
privilege, which is often given senators whose state is affected by
pending legislation, did not extend to voting on the committee.
111. In fact Senator Gravel actually made the work
of the committee more difficult. Invoking a rule that forbade a
committee from meeting while the full Senate is in session, Gravel
forced the committee to hold meetings in early morning and in the
evening in order to complete work before adjournment. The tactic
certainly did not endear him to committee members. Interview with James
Pepper, November 8, 1983.
112. Report to Accompany H.R. 39, October
9, 1978, passim; Alaska d-2 Lands Senate Briefing #3, Summary of
Key Issues, FWP Weekly Report, October 11, 1978, Box 8, NPS WASO Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI.
113. Ibid. Additionally the committee
recommended a 386,000-acre National Recreation Area in the Kelly River
watershed in the Noatak.
114. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 22; Cecil Andrus
and Bob Bergland To Walter Mondale, November 19, 1978, doc. no. 001787,
ANILCA Papers, USDI; "Deadline near for Alaska Lands Bill,"
Washington Post, September 17, 1978, Crandell Papers; John
Sieberling to Henry Jackson, August 1, 1978, Box 34, NPS WASO Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI [letter stating House position on H. R. 39] .
115. So sure were Interior Department staff that
nothing more would be done, Secretary Andrus had left for vacation. Jim
Pepper, an NPS employee then working as Cynthia Wilson s assistant had
taken a plane to New York City. When he arrived a message waited
directing him to return to Washington to work on a possible compromise.
Interview of Pepper, November 8, 1983.
116. Interview of Harry Crandell, December 7,
1983.
117. Briefing Paper-Alaska Lands Legislation,
Legislative History, undated MS [1979], Belous Files, Box 38, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; "Ad Hoc Negotiations, '78," Box 32,
Ibid.; "Alaska Lands Legislation, What Happened. What Next?" FWP
Weekly Report, October 18, 1978, Box 6, Ibid. ; Interviews of
Harry Crandell, Cynthia Wilson, Jim Pepper, Richard Stenmark.
118. "Here's Gravel's Account of the D2 Meetings,"
and " 'I kept my word to Stevens,' " Anchorage Times, October 15
and 20, 1978, ARO Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, DPL. On
the 12th, Interior Department officials met with Senator Stevens to
discuss possible areas of compromise. Bob [Herbst] to Secretary Andrus,
October 12, 1978, Ad Hoc Negotiations, '78, Box 32, NPS WASO Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI.
119. Bill Horn, Briefing Paper, H.R. 39
Legislative History: 95th Congress, January 23, 1978, Box 31, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Interview of Cynthia Wilson, December 1983;
Interview of James Pepper, November 8, 1983. Representative Young also
participated, and after the 12th, Senator Clifford Hansen, minority
leader of the Senate Energy Committee attended.
The presence of Secretary Andrus and his assistant, Cynthia Wilson,
as full partners in a congressional conference was most
extraordinary.
120. D. Michael Harvey to Cynthia Wilson, January
1979, Pepper Files, Gates of the Arctic National Park and Preserve.
121 . Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 22; "Ad Hoc
Negotiations 78," Box 32, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Senator
Mike Gravel Reports to Alaskans, November 1978, Belous Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI.
Interestingly, the transportation corridors Gravel listed, save that
across the Stikine River, had been identified by the Interior Department
in 1974. Secretary. Morton shelved the plan at that time, following
outcry from conservationists and Natives. See, USDI, Multimodel
Transportation and Utility Corridor Systems in Alaska. Generalized
Description of the 40 Primary Corridors: Locations, Modes, Identifying
Agencies, Purposes, Environmental Impacts, and Status of Lands
Crossed (Washington, D.C.: USDI, November 1974); Arnold, Native
Land Claims, pp. 270-71.
122. "Ad hoc" bill, undated [October 14, 1978],
Xerox copy provided the author by Cynthia Wilson; "Ad Hoc Compromise,"
October 14, 1978, Box 35, NPS WASO Files, USDI; "Compromise D-2 Bill
Summary Outline," Ibid.
123. D. Michael Harvey to Cynthia Wilson, January
1979, Pepper Files, Gates of the Arctic National Park/Preserve; John F.
Seiberling to Bruce Vento, January 29, 1979, in U.S. Congress, House,
Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, Alaska National Interest
Lands Conservation Act of 1979: Report together with Dissenting
Supplemental and Separate Views to Accompany H.R. 39, 96th Cong.,
1st sess., H. Report 96-97, part 1, pp. 609-10; Congressional
Record, House, May 8, 1979, p. 2851; Statement of . . . Cecil Andrus
Before the House Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs on H.R. 39, .
. . February 13, 1979, Box 23, NPS WASO Files, USDI; Interviews of Harry
Crandell, Cynthia Wilson, James Pepper and Dick Stenmark.
Senator Stevens and Representative Young, on the other hand, believed
that an agreement had been reached. Fairbanks Daily News-Miner,
May 10, 1979, ARO Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, DPL;
Bill Horn, Briefing Papers-H. R. 39, Legislative History: 95th Congress,
January 23, 1979, Box 31, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
124. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 23; Interviews
of Crandell, Wilson, Pepper, and Stenmark; Congressional Record,
House, October 14, 1978, p. 12978; Congressional Record, Senate,
October 14, 1978, pp. 19135-141
As a sidelight, John Seiberling, fearful that Gravel might attempt to
curtail the President's authority to act under the Antiquities Act,
stayed on the floor of the House to examine every piece of legislation
from Saturday afternoon until 7:00 p.m. Sunday night, a stretch of
thirty-one hours. The importance of preventing such an action
follows.
125. "Here's Gravels's Account of the D2 Meeting,"
Anchorage Times, October 15, 1978, ARO Clippings Files, Special
Collections Division, DPL.
126. Interview of Harry Crandell, December 7, 1983
and Chuck Clusen, December 6, 1983.
Even had the bill gone forward a series of strengthening amendments
had been introduced in the Senate, and were lying on the table. This
suggests that reaching a successful conclusion in the few remaining
hours would have been difficult in any case. For example, U.S. Congress,
Senate, To Extend statutory protection under the 1964 Wilderness Act
to critical lands in Alaska, Amdt. No. 4523, Calendar No. 1215, 95th
Cong., 2nd sess., October 10, 1978.
127. As late as September 15, for example,
Secretary Andrus had promised "to make sure that the National Treasures
of Alaskan Wilds are protected. . . . We have no intention of letting
Alaska become a private preserve for a handful of rape, ruin and run
developers." USDI, News Release, September 15, 1978.
128. Richard C. Curry to Assistant Director,
Planning and Development, July 15, 1978, Box 39, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI.
129. Sue Kemnitzer to Alaska Policy Group, July 7,
1978, Box 32, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; John D. Leshy to
Kemnitzer, July 14, 1978, Ibid.; Bill Reffalt to Kemnitzer, July
14, 1978, Ibid., Robert Herbst to Kemnitzer, July 20, 1978,
Ibid.; James Moorman to Kay A. Oberly and Jacques B. Gelin,
August 1, 1978, Ibid.; Moorman to Kathy Fletcher, August 8, 1978,
Ibid. ; Guy Martin to Secretary Andrus, November 27, 1978, Box
14, NPS WASO Files, Ibid.; Cynthia Wilson to Secretary Andrus,
November 27, 1978, doc. 001162, Ibid.
130. Task Directive, Alaska Administrative
Alternatives Analysis, undated [1978] MS, material in possession of Jon
Haman, Denver Service Center; Terry Carlstrom to Sue Kemnitzer,
September 21, 1975, Ibid.; Robert Herbst to Director, NPS,
September 12, 1978, Ibid.; Alaska D2 Administrative Alternative
Action Task Force responsibilities, undated MS [1978], Ibid. The
NPS was the lead agency in this undertaking, and Terry Carlstrom, of the
NPS's Denver Service Center, served as task force leader.
131. FWP Weekly Report, September 13, 1978, Box 6,
NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; USDI, Draft Environment
Supplement, Alternative Administrative Actions Alaska National Interest
Lands (Washington, D.C. . 1978); Cynthia Wilson to Dear Reviewer,
October 25, 1978, Box 28, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers; USDI, Final
Environmental Supplement Alternative Actions Alaska National Interest
Lands (Washington, D.C.: USDI, 1978).
132. William J. Whalen to Assistant Secretary for
Fish and Wildlife and Parks, November 9, 1978 and November 20, 1978,
doc. no. 003040, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
133. Ibid. ; Cynthia Wilson to Dear
Reviewer, October 25, 1978, Box 38, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
Draft Environmental Supplement, p. 1-4; Harry Crandell to Cynthia
Wilson, September 25, 1978, Crandell Papers.
134. "Andrus vows he will 'protect' Alaska land,"
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner, August 1 , 1978, ARO Clipping File,
Special Collections Division, DPL; "Carter may issue edict on parks,"
Anchorage Daily News, August 19, 1978, Ibid.; "Andrus set
to Invoke 1906 Act," Anchorage Times, October 17, 1978;
Ibid.; John Seiberling to Cecil D. Andrus, August 17, 1978, Box
13, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; John M. Murphy, et. al.
to President Carter, November 15, 1978, AK-5, Crandell Papers [letter
from over 100 congressmen encouraging the President to take
comprehensive action to protect Alaska lands]; Lawrence Rockefeller et.
al. to President Carter, November 30, 1978, Ibid; Alaska
Coalition, Special Report on: Presidential Action to Protect Alaska's
Wilderness, December 6, 1978, Ibid.
135. William J. Whalen to Assistant Secretary for
Fish Wildlife and Parks, July 18, 1978 and November 9, 1978, doc. no.
003040, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
136. Interview of Cynthia Wilson, December 6,
1983.
137. "State selections within 1979 Administration
Proposals for Parks," February 22, 1979, Breedlove Papers, HFC; USDI,
Report for Alaska Land Withdrawals, Section 204(e) of PL 94-587
(Washington, D.C. : USDI, November 16, 1978) p. vi. Calculations of the
amount of state selection land within conservation areas differs. The
latter indicates the figure was in excess of 14,000,000 acres.
138. USDI, News Release, November 16, 1978;
Anchorage Times, November 16, 1978, ARO Clipping Files, Special
Collections Division, DPL; Alaska National Interest Lands Administrative
Withdrawals, undated MS, Box 24, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers USDI;
USDI, USGS, "Alaska Administrative FLPMA Withdrawals," January 1, 1979,
map in ARO. NPS acreage amounted to 44,030,000 acres, while refuges
totaled 63,140,000, and wild and scenic rivers, 3,580,000 acres.
139. USDI, News Release, December 1, 1978, Box 38,
NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Office of the White House Press
Secretary, Statement by the President, December 1, 1978, Ibid.;
Monuments, February 1, 1979, Box 17, Ibid [comparison of the
administration's 1978 recommendations and monument boundaries]. Illustration 13 is a map of the
monuments.
140. Statement of the President, December 1, 1978,
Box 38, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Roger Contor to Files,
January 16, 1979, L3215, Public land (204(e)) withdrawals, ARO Central
Files, Inactive, ARO; "Withdrawals," draft by Roger Contor, January 26,
1979, Box 26, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
141. State of Alaska vs. Carter, et. al.,
Civ. no. A 78-291, October 30, 1978; Luzader, "Litigation"; Statement of
Cecil Andrus, Secretary of the Interior before the Senate Energy
National Resources Committee, Concerning S.1176, A Bill to Amend the
1906 Antiquities Act and Federal Land Policy Management Act, 1976,
September 13, 1979, doc. no. 001189, ANILCA Papers, USDI. The state's
suit was only one of a number that challenged executive actions in
Alaska. Anaconda Copper Company, CMAL, Bristol Bay Native Corporation,
Alaskans for Independence, Cominsco, Inc. , and several hunters who
faced prosecution for illegal hunting in the national monuments also
challenged the withdrawals.
142. "Our View: The real root of the freeze,"
Anchorage Daily News, December, 1978, ARO Clipping Files, Special
Collections Division, DPL; December 12, 1978, January 13, 1979,
Ibid. ; Fairbanks Daily News-Miner, February 1, 1979 and
March 13, 1979, Ibid.; David F. McAllister, Case Report, January
11, 1979, L-58, Great Denali Trespass, Park Files, Denali National
Park/Preserve. Zorro Bradley, who directed the Park Service's
Cooperative Park Studies Unit at the University of Alaska at Fairbanks,
could not get the road to his home plowed. Interview, December 7,
1983.
143. Resolution of City of Eagle, December 11,
1978, Box 18, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI. For a fascinating
description of Eagle and the Alaska Bush, see McPhee, Coming into the
Country, pp. 183-438.
144. Douglas Warnock, "Recollections of First Trip
to Eagle, Alaska," 1983, Xerox copy given author by Mr. Warnock;
Interview of John Cook, January 25, 1984; Interview of Douglas Warnock,
August, 6, 1984; Interview of William E. Brown, March 15, 1983; Personal
Observation, July 1983. Mr. Cook's visit to Eagle was one of several
trips to areas where resentment of the monuments and NPS ran
particularly high.
This particular sign, which was attached to a building on the only
road into Eagle, was still there in the summer of 1983. This is not to
imply that it then reflected anything more than the views of the
individual who owned the building to which it was attached.
145. Jerry Gilliand to Robert Herbst, February 26,
1979, Box 18, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
146. Roger Contor to Regional Director, Pacific
Northwest Region, November 30, 1978, Box 18, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Interview of G. Ray Bane by Frank Williss, July 15, 1983.
Bane, a NPS anthropologist, lived for years in bush Alaska before
joining the Service. He experienced first-hand the problems when some
long-standing acquaintances would no longer speak to him or his wife,
Barbara, after designation of the monuments.
147. Contor to R.D., PNW, November 30, 1978; David
A. Watts to Juanita Alvarez, December 5, 1978, Box 23, NPS WASO Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI.
148. Federal Register, vol. 44, June 28,
1979, part II, pp. 37732-37751; Part III, pp. 37784-37785; Robert Herbst
to Cecil Andrus, June 8, 1979, Monument Regulations, Box 2, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Hearings on Proposed "National Park Service
Regulations," Anchorage, August 15, 1979, Office of Regional Law
Enforcement Specialist, ARO; Summary of proposed regulations in Alaska,
June 1979, doc. no. 000215, Ibid [comparison of NPS and USFS
proposed regulations with those in lower 48."]. Both the FWS and USFS,
on the other hand, allowed sport hunting in the four monuments under
their control.
149. "Uphill fight for state in Alaska lands
battle," Anchorage Daily News, December 28, 1978, ARO Clipping
File, Special Collections Division, DPL.
150. Ibid.; Anchorage Times, January
29, 1979, Ibid.; Esther C. Wunnicke and Walter B. Parker to Mike
Gravel, December 29, 1978, AK-6, Crandell Papers; Testimony of Terry
Miller, Lieutenant Governor of Alaska before the House Committee on
Merchant Marine and Fisheries, Subcommittee on Fisheries and Wildlife
Conservation, February 22, 1979, Box 30, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers,
USDI; Jerry Gilliand to Robert Herbst, February 26, 1979, Box 18, NPS
WASO Files, Ibid.
151 . Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 24; Anchorage
Daily News, June 24, 1979, ARO Clipping Files, Special
Collections Division, DPL. State officials had drawn up seven basic
points they insisted must be met: title to all land selected, including
the November 14, 1978 selections; state management of fish and wildlife;
exclusion of viable resources from conservation units; guaranteed access
across those units; a "no more" clause that would prohibit future
withdrawals by executive action; guarantees for "the continuation of
traditional Alaskan lifestyles," and revocation of all actions taken by
the Carter administration in 1978.
152. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 4.; Anchorage
Daily News, May 8, 1979, ARO Clippings File, Special Collections
Division, DPL. CMAL had spent $650,000 the previous year. The amount was
five times that spent by the Alaska Coalition. Most of the lobbying by
the Coalition, however, came from nonpaid volunteers, however.
153. Congressional Record, House, January
15, 1979, pp. 43, 129; May 8, 1979, p. 2851. Eventually 150 members had
signed on as co-sponsors. The bill was referred jointly to the Interior
and Insular Affairs and Merchant Marine committees.
154. H.R. 39, Section Analysis, January 31, 1979,
Box 17, NPS WASO Files, USDI; FWP Weekly Report, January 17, 1979, Box
6, Ibid.; William J. Whalen to Robert Herbst, January 24, 1979.
Alaska Legislature96th Congress, Box 18, Ibid.; Summary of
Provisions of Alaska National Interest Lands Act of 1979 [1979], Box 1,
Alaskan Coalition Papers; Anchorage Daily News, February 9, 1979,
ARO Clippings Files, Special Collections Division, DPL [an article
describing Representative Don Young's analysis of the differences
between the 1978 and 1979 versions of H.R. 39.].
Additionally, the new bill did not include a mechanism for creating a
cooperative management area in the Bristol Bay region.
155. Cynthia Wilson to Secretary, January 3, 1979,
Box 9, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
156. Ibid. ; William J. Whalen to Assistant
Secretary for Fish, Wildlife and Parks [Robert Herbst], January 24,
1979, Box 32, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Robert Herbst to
Secretary, January 26, 1979, Ibid.; Cynthia Wilson to Alaska
Policy Group, February 1, 1979, Crandell Papers; Cecil D. Andrus to
Morris K. Udall, February 26, 1979, Box 38, NPS WASO Files, USDI; Morris
K. Udall to all members, Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs,
February 23, 1979, Box 4, Alaska Coalition Papers.
157. H.R. 39Detail Status Steps, January-May
1979, Box 2, Alaska Coalition Papers; U.S. Congress, House, Committee on
Interior and Insular Affairs, Alaska National Interest Lands
Conservation Act of 1979: Report together with dissenting Supplemental
and Separate Views to Accompany H.R. 39, 96th Congress, 1979, H.
Rept. 96-97, Part I, p. 144; Morris Udall and John Seiberling to
Cosponsors of H.R. 39, March 13, 1979, Box 23, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI.
158. FWP Weekly Report, March 7, 1979, Box 6, NPS
WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Cecil Andrus to John M. Breaux, March
21, 1979, Doc. No. 001748, Ibid.; Andrus to John M. Murphy, March
29, 1979, Box 17, Ibid.; [Committee Print] [March 28, 1979]
[Amendment to H.R. 39, as introduced, offered by Mr. Breaux]; John
Breaux to members, Subcommittee on Fisheries and Wildlife Conservation
and the Environment, March 25, 1979, Box 34, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; U.S., Congress, Committee on Merchant Marine and
Fisheries, Alaska National Interest Lands Act, 1979, Report
Together with Supplemental and Dissenting Views to Accompany H.R.
39, 96th Cong., 1st. sess., 1979, H.R. 96-977, Part II, pp. 171;
National Wildlife Federation, Conservation Report, part 2, April 13,
1979, Crandell Papers.
159. Alaska Coalition, Alaska Status Report,
Critique of the Huckaby Substitute, February 27, 1979, Box 38, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; FWP Weekly Report, March 7, 1979, Box 6,
Ibid., Comparison of Pending Alaska Legislation, April 27, 1979,
Ibid.; Alaska Coalition, Impact of Huckaby Substitute on H.R. 39,
February 28, 1979, Box 23, Ibid.; Joint Federal-State Land Use
Planning Commission, "Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation
Legislation, H.R. 2199 (Huckaby)1979," map provided author by
Richard Stenmark; James M. Lambe to Chief, Office of Legislation, April
11, 1979, Box 34, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
160. Anchorage Daily News, March 9, 1979,
ARO Clippings Files, Special Collections Division, DPL; Morris Udall and
John Seiberling to Co-Sponsors, March 13, 1979, Box 23, NPS WASO Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI.
161. U.S. Congress, House, A Bill to Provide
for the Designation and Conservation of Certain Public Lands in the
State of Alaska . . . , H.R. 3651 , 96th Cong., 1st sess., May 23,
1979; Congressional Record, House, May 23, 1979, p. 2509.
162. Anchorage Times, and Anchorage
Daily News, May 17, 1979; ARO Clippings Files, Special
Collections Division, DPL. For an excellent account of the lobbying
efforts of the Alaskan Coalition prior to and during House action in May
1979, see Cahn, Wild Alaska, pp. 23-27.
163. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 25; Neal Knox to
NRA Members, April 26, 1979, AK-7, Crandell Papers; Speech of Ted
Stevens, Congressional Record, Senate, May 14, 1979, p. 5717;
Fairbanks Daily News-Miner, May 11, 1979, ARO Clipping Files,
Special Collections Division, DPL; Washington Post, May 17, 1979,
Box 4, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI. Emergence of gun control as
a principal issue was certainly one of the most improbable occurrences
in the entire legislative history of the Alaska national interest lands.
The question revolved around the amount of land to be closed to sport
hunting in the bill. Yet, by the Department of the Interior's
calculations, the Breaux-Dingell proposal would have closed 5.3 percent
of the lands to hunting, Huckaby, 5.5 percent, and Udall-Anderson, only
slightly more at 7.5 percent. Cynthia Wilson to Secretary, et. al, April
27, 1979, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
164. Congressional Record, House, May 16,
1979, p. 3291; Cahn, Wild Alaskan, p. 25.
165. FWP Weekly Reports, May 9, 1979, Box 14, NPS
WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Congressional Record, House, May
15, 1979, p. 3132; May 16, 1979, pp. 3385-3386; Anchorage Times,
May 17, 1979. A ruling from the chair gave the Udall-Anderson substitute
the original number H.R. 39. The final margin of victory may have been
at least partially due to a "bandwagon" effect. The margin of difference
was generally ten to twenty votes in favor of Udall-Anderson until the
total reached about 200 votes. At that time, the margin grew
considerably.
166. S-9, January 15, 1979; Ted Stevens to John C.
Culver, January 10, 1979, Box 38, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
Cecil Andrus to Henry Jackson, July 17, 1979, Ibid.; U.S.,
Senate, Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, Alaska National
Interest Lands: Report Together with Additional Views to Accompany H.R.
39, 96th Cong., 1st sess., 1979, S. Rept. 96-413, p. 135.
On January 25, Senator John Durkin with twenty co-sponsors had
introduced a counterpart to H.R. 39 (S-222).
167. S. Report to Accompany H.R. 39, 1979,
p. 134; Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 25.
168. Ted Stevens to John Culver, Box 38, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
169. S. Report to Accompany H.R. 39, 1979,
p. 134; Secretary [Andrus] to Assistant Secretary for Fish and Wildlife
and Parks, September 12, 1979, doc. no. 001849, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
William J. Whalen to Assistant Secretary, Fish and Wildlife and Parks,
August 30, 1979, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
All potential parklands to be withdrawn under section 204(c)
(described on p. 218) would, according to Secretary Andrus, continue to
be managed by the BLM in close cooperation with the Park Service.
170. S. Report to Accompany H.R. 39, 1979,
pp. 135-36; S.9 As Reported by the Senate Committee on Energy and
Natural Resources on October 30, 1979, undated MS, Box 27, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Senate Energy and Natural Resources
Committee Mark-up of S-9 Adopted, October 31, 1979, Box 38,
Ibid.; Robert Herbst to Cecil Andrus, November 19, 1979, Box 9,
Ibid.; Cecil D. Andrus to Walter F. Mondale, November 19, 1979,
Ibid.; Congressional Record, November 15, 1979, p. 32622.
One difference between the 1978 and 1979 versions, was a provision
eliminating 100,000 acres from proposed wilderness in Misty Fjords
National Monument to allow U.S. Borax Co. to develop its molybdenum
claim. This was, said Tsongas, the most hotly debated issue in the
mark-up sessions.
171. "NPS Amendments to H.R. 39 as Reported by
Senate, November 1979 (S.9), undated Ms, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers,
USDI; Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 25.
172. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 25;
Congressional Record, Senate, November 15, 1979, p. 32622;
Amendment No. 626, Calendar 442, November 15, 1979; "Tsongas-Roth
Substitute," undated MS, Box 8, Alaska Coalition Papers.
173. Congressional Record, Senate, February
8, 1980, p. 1378; Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 26, Anchorage
Times, January 23 and 30, 1979 and Fairbanks Daily News-Miner,
February 5 and 8, 1979, AK-7, Crandell Papers. Senator Tsongas
apparently hoped to avoid a filibuster when the bill came before the
full Senate. Nevertheless the agreement was a clear victory for Alaskan
senators, who wanted to delay a vote as long as possible and who clearly
indicated that the final bill would be written in conference. Senator
Stevens, at least, believed that it would have been virtually impossible
to block a stronger bill early on in the session.
174. USDI, News Release, February 12, 1980, Office
of the Regional Director, ARO; USDI, USGS, "Alaska, Administration FLPMA
withdrawals, February 11, 1980," map in ARO.
175. Ibid.; USDI, Report for Alaska Land
withdrawals Section 204(c) of FLPMA (P.L. 94-579) (Washington, D.C.
: USDI, February 11, 1980), Chapter 3, pp. 1-38.
176. USDI, New Release, February 12, 1980; Ira J.
Hutchinson to Director BLM, March 11, 1980 [encloses draft cooperative
agreement for management of the four natural resource areas], Box 38,
NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
177. Cahn, Wild Alaska, pp. 26-27; "Alaska
Shifts d-2 Blitz into High Gear," Anchorage Daily News, June 14,
1980, Crandell Papers; New York Times, May 14, 1980,
Ibid.; Jay Hammond to Joseph P. Teasdale, March 11, 1980, doc.
no. 001944, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Neal Knox [Executive Director, National
Rifle Association] to Patrick Leahy, June 16, 1980, doc. no. 001980,
Ibid.; Mike Gravel, News Release, April 17, 1980, AK-7 Crandell
Papers.
178. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 27; Amendment
no. 1782. Others ready to follow were: No. 1779 - National Parks
Amendment (Tsongas and Mathias), No. 1780 - Rivers and Transportation
(Proxmire and Eagleton), No. 1781 - Wilderness (Nelson and Levin), and
No. 1783 - National Forests (Tsongas, Roth, and McGovern).
179. Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 27; Edgar
Wayburn, "Alaska Lands Bill in Senate, Slowdowns and Showdowns," undated
MS, Crandell Papers.
180. "Open Letter to Senator Stevens," July 17,
1980, Anchorage Daily News, July 17, 1980, ARO Clipping Files,
Special Collections Division, DPL; "The GOP Position," Fairbanks
Daily News-Miner, May 7, 1980, Republican position, state
convention resolution, AK-7, Crandell Papers; Cahn, Wild Alaska,
p. 27; Interview of James Pepper, November 8, 1983; Colloquy on
Tsongas-Jackson Compromise Amendment, undated MS, Box 27, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI. The last is a draft of a series of questions
and answers, designed to clarify provisions of a amendment, and to
establish some form of legislative history on key provisions.
181. Congressional Record, Senate, August
18, 1980, pp. 11050, 11140; August 19, 1980, p. 11203. Both senators
Gravel and Stevens voted against the bill.
182. Quoted in Cahn, Wild Alaska, p. 29;
Seattle Post Intelligencer, August 22, 1980, K-34, Press
Releases, ARO Central Files - Inactive, ARO; Interview of James Pepper,
November 8, 1983.
183. Committee Staff to Morris K. Udall, September
29, 1980, Ibid. [detailing a counter-offer from Senator Stevens];
Oliver Leavitt to John F. Seibering, September 17, 1980, Ibid.;
Interview of Curtis E. Bohlen, III, October 10, 1983, James Pepper,
November 8, 1983, Chuck Clusen December 6, 1983. Among the changes
suggested by the House were transfer of the 300,000-acre N.E. preserve
of Gates of the Arctic to a park, modified language on the
transportation corridor across the "boot," transfer of nearly 900,000
acres from preserve to park in Denali, addition of a Copper River
Wildlife Refuge, and the addition of some 6,000,000 in wilderness
acreage (1,000,000 of it in the National Park System).
184. Morris K. Udall to President Carter, October
14, 1980, doc. no. 002072, ANILCA Papers, USDI; U.S. Congress, House,
To Amend the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act, and for
other purposes. H. R. 8311 , 96th Cong. , 2nd sess. , October 3,
1980; News from Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, October 1,
1980, Crandell Papers; H.R. 8311: Summary Provisions to Amend the
Senate-Passed Alaska Lands Bill, October 2, 1980, Box 4, Alaska
Coalition Papers; Interview of Harry Crandell, December 7, 1984.
Designed to appeal to a broader audience, the bill would have, among
other things, added 3,700,000 acres of wilderness to Senate's bill,
while providing for seismic oil exploration of the coastal plain of
Arctic National Wildlife Range, and opening an additional 1,000,000
acres of national park land to sport hunting in Wrangell-St. Elias
(635,000 acres), Denali (235,000 acres), and Lake Clark (140,000
acres).
185. Nash, Wilderness and the American
Mind, p. 300; "Grim Reality Comes to Victims of Tuesday's Massacre,"
Washington Post, November 6, 1980, Crandell Papers; News from
Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, November 12, 1980,
Ibid.; Congressional Record, House, November 18, 1980, pp.
10527-552.
186. Weekly compilation of Presidential Documents,
vol. 16, no. 49, December 8, 1980, pp. 2753-2787. The bill President
Carter signed differed from the bill passed by the Senate on August and
the House on November 12 as a result of H. Concurrent Resolution 452 and
453, passed by the House on November 21 and the Senate on December 1 .
Most of the changes were technical or perfecting. Others, a majority of
which dealt with Native issues, were more extensive. Among other things
the resolution prohibited the collection of entrance fees for National
Park System units in Alaska, protected the Alaska pipeline from being
affected by conservation units, and deleted a ten-year phase-out period
for cabin permits in Tongass National Forest. Congressional
Record, House, November 21, 1980, pp. 11111-11115; Congressional
Record, Senate, December 1, 1980, pp. 15129-15132; Anchorage Daily
News-Mirror, December 1, 1980, Crandell Papers.
187. Cahn, Wild Alaska, pp. 20, 29;
Congressional Record, House, November 12, 1980, pp. 10530 and p.
5012; Interview of Chuck Clusen, December 8, 1983; P.L. 94-487, December
2, 1980 [ANILCA]; The Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation
ActA summary [December 1980], Box 24, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Great Falls [Montana], Tribune, September 29, 1980,
Crandell Papers.
188. P.L. 96-487, December 2, 1980. Nearly five
and a half million acres of wilderness were in the National Forest
System, 18,200,000 in Wildlife Refuges, and 37,400,000 in national park
areas. Illustration 14 is a map of lands set aside under ANILCA.
189. P.L. 96-497, December 2, 1980;
Congressional Record, House, November 17, 1980, pp. 10532-
passim. In the absence of a House or Senate Report on the bill,
Representative Udall presented the "explanation of those aspects of the
legislation that affect the National Park system as to official
legislative history of the 'Alaska National Interest Land Conservation
Act.'"
The boundaries shown on official maps included federal, state,
Native, and private lands. The acreage figures shown here were estimates
of the probable ultimate federal acreages within the areas. Those
figures are being revised as more accurate data becomes available and
state and Native claims are adjudicated.
190. Congressional Record, House, November
17, 1980, p. 10528.
191. Ibid., p. 10530; Cahn, Wild
Alaska, p. 30. In 1983 Senator Stevens and Representative Young
would introduce legislation to redesignate portions of the parks to
preserves in Katmai, Gates of the Arctic, Lake Clark, Wrangell-St.
Elias, Denali, and Glacier Bay to open more land for hunting.
Additionally, Kenai Fjords National Park would be redesignated as Kenai
Fjords National Preserve. U.S. , Congress, House, A Bill to Designate
Public Land in Alaska to Allow Hunting, H.R. 1493, 95th Cong., 1st
sess. February 15, 1983. Senator Stevens and ten co-sponsors had
introduced a similar bill (S. 49) on January 2, 1983. To date the bills
have not enacted into law.
192. Hearings on H.R. 39, 1977, XII:
p.83.
Chapter
Five
1. Keith Trexler to Ted Swem, February 16, 1974, ARO
Goals, Denali Keyman Files, Box 28, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79,
FARC, Seattle.
2. Al Henson to Ted Swem, March 5, 1974, Alaska
Organization - NPS, Swem Papers; Alaska Task Force Organization, April
12, 1974, History of ATFO, Henson Papers, Mancos; 'Meeting Regarding
Support Data for Alaska Areas," May 7, 1974, W-38, Box 20, Alaska Task
Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Al [Henson] to Ted [Swem], [February
1974], Box 3, Ibid.; ATFO Employees as of 2/1/75, NPS Personnel -
ARO, Henson Papers, Mancos. Professionals were Project Leader (Henson),
Management Assistant (Keith Trexler), Park Planner (John Kauffmann),
Landscape Architect (Bailey Breedlove), Public Information Officer (Bob
Belous), and Special Research Analyst (Amy Paige).
3. Al [Henson] to Ted [Swem], [February 1974], A-94,
Box 3, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Interview of Al
Henson and Theodor R. Swem, June 7, 1973; Ron Walker to Assistant
Secretary, FWP, October 24, 1974, Alaska Organization, Swem Papers.
Henson's concerns were shared by a number of people. On March 7,
1974, for example, Celia Hunter wrote Theodor Swem, warning him that the
Service's efforts to promote its proposals in Alaska were far inferior
to other agencies, and would serve to convince people that it was not
capable of managing the new areas. Celia Hunter to Theodor R. Swem,
March 7, 1974, Alaska Organization, Swem Papers.
4. Gary Everhardt to Directorate, May 6, 1975,
Alaska Task Force, A-94, Box 2, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle; Interview of William E. Brown, by Frank Williss, November 10,
1983; Interview of Donald Follows by Frank Williss, November 3, 1983;
Organizational Chart - Alaska Task Force, [1975], History of ATFO,
Henson Papers, Mancos; Donald S. Follows, "Conceptual Interpretive Plan
for Proposed Park Lands in Alaska," May 10, 1977, D-18, Planning,
Programs, and Master Plans, Box 6, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle; Goals - Yukon-Charley Keyman, [1976], AAO: Goals, etc., Denali
Keyman Files, Box 28, Ibid. Originally other keyman were Fred
Eubanks (Lake Clark), John Kauffmann (Gates of the Arctic), Mark Malic
(Mount McKinley), Gerald Wright (Wrangell-St. Elias), Ralph Root (Katmai
and Aniakchak), and Robert Nichols (Cape Krusenstern).
Additionally task force members, particularly Al
Henson, Bob Belous and Stell Newman, along with people like Zorro
Bradley and Ray Bane were called back to Washington from time to time to
lend their expertise on various issues.
5. Sketch of organization of Alaska Task Force,
[1975], History of ATF, Henson Papers, Mancos; Biographical Sketches -
ATF, November 12, 1976, Box 1, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Roy
Sanborn to Project Leader, March 9, 1976, NPS Personnel - AK, Henson
Papers, Mancos.
The Cooperative Park Studies Unit, which was directed by Zorro
Bradley, is discussed on pp. 258-59.
6. The Fish and Wildlife Service (formerly
BSF&W) employed the opposite approach in these years, using its
existing Alaska office, supplemented by people detailed from the "Lower
48". That approach proved somewhat cumbersome, and that bureau later
established a separate ANCSA office. Interview of William Reffalt,
December 9, 1983.
7. Interview of John Cook, January 26, 1984;
Interview of Stanley Albright, June 29, 1984; Interview of John Rutter,
May 16, 1984; John Rutter to George B. Hartzog, Jr., June 19, 1972 and
John C. Rumburg to John Rutter, June 29, 1972, ANCSA Implementation,
April-December 1972, Swem Papers; John Rutter to Associate Director,
Legislation [Richard Curry], June 21, 1974, Ibid.; Al Henson to
Dr. Curry, June 26, 1974, ANCSA Implementation, 1974, Ibid; John
Rutter to Deputy Director, October 7, 1974, Denali Keyman Files, Box 30,
Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle.
For a discussion of relationship between the Park Service and the
Department of the Interior in the 1970s, see Ronald A. Foresta,
America's National Parks and Their Keepers (Washington, D.C.:
Resources for the Future, 1984), pp. 84-87.
8. Interview of John Rutter, May 16, 1984.
9. Franklin K. Lane to Stephen Mather, May 13, 1918.
Quoted in Unrau and Williss, Expansion of the NPS, p. 27.
10. John Kauffmann, "Noatak," The Living
Wilderness vol. 38 (Winter 1974-75), p. 18; Interview of John
Rutter, May 16, 1984. See also, Foresta, America's National Parks and
Their Keepers, pp. 112-15.
11. This view comes from a number of interviews
with Alaska Task Force personnel, as well as former PWW Regional
Director Rutter, former Alaska State Office Director Stanley Albright,
and former Alaska Regional Director, John Cook. Cook, NPS Associate
Director in the mid-1970s, recalls spending a considerable amount of
time mediating disputes between the two offices.
12. In general the Advisory Board supported the
Services's proposals, despite previous comments to the Alaska press that
they would recommend that some of land earmarked for National Parks
should be managed for other uses. Anchorage Daily News, June 21,
1975, A-16, Advisory Board, Box 1, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle.
13. Melvin M. Payne [Chairman, Advisory Board on
National Parks] to Secretary of the Interior, April 24, 1974, Advisory
Board, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
14. Peter C. Murphy, Jr., Steven Rose, et.
al. to Stanley K. Hathaway, confidential telegram, June 28, 1975,
Advisory Board, Box 2, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
15. Ibid.
16. J.L. Norwood to Director, December 4, 1975,
Swem Correspondence, January 1975-December 1976, HFC; Gary Everhart to
Assistant Secretary, FWP, December 15, 1975, Advisory Board, Box 2, NPS
WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI. Norwood's audit included a thorough
examination, and subsequent dismissal, of board member Steven Rose's
charge that a conflict of interest, or at least a compromise of position
existed in the Task Force's acceptance of NANA Regional Corporation's
offer of $5,000-10,000 in manpower and equipment toward a study of
subsistence for the Kobuk Valley.
17. Al [Henson] to Ted [Swem], [February 1974],
A-94, Box 3 Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Interview of
Henson, June 6, 1983.
18. Ron Walker to Assistant Secretary, FWP, October
25, 1974, Alaska Organization, NPS, Swem Papers; Comments on New
Alaska Area Office Organization and Operation (Presented by members
of Park Planning Staff,) May 10, 1975, Denali Keyman Files, Box 30,
Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; "Statement for Gary
Everhardt on changes in Alaska Organization", October 4, 1975, Advisory
Board, Box 2, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Alaska Area Office,
Alaska Task Force - Permanent Personnel, 12/75, NPS Personnel-AK, Henson
Papers, Mancos; Russell Dickinson to Bryan Harry, June 16, 1976,
Proposed Areas, 1976-77, Park Files, Denali National Park/Preserve.
19. "Statement for Gary Everhardt on changes in
Alaska Organization," October 4, 1975; Gary Everhardt to Steven L. Rose,
December 17, 1975, Denali Keyman Files, Box 27, Alaska Task Force Files,
RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Bob Utley to Bryan Harry, February 26, 1976, A-16,
Advisory Council, Box 1, Ibid.; Interview of Bryan Harry by Frank
Williss, November 14, 1983; Bailey Breedlove to All Task Force
Personnel, October 7, 1975, Box B, Old Federal Building Warehouse,
ARO.
20. Ted Swem to Gary Everhardt, October 4, 1975,
and Special Assistant to the Director [Swem] to Director [Everhardt],
October 28, 1975, October 28, 1975, Alaska Organization, Swem Papers; Al
Henson to Gary [Everhardt], March 26, 1976, doc. no. 002178, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Director, NPS, to Assistant Secretary, FWP, May 25, 1976
[draft], doc. no. 002204, Ibid.; WASO Directorate to Acting
Assistant to the Director for Alaska, July 1, 1966, A-58, Proposed
Areas, ARO Central Files, Inactive, ARO.
21 . Bryan Harry, for example, felt that such an
action would be unnecessarily expensive, and would make the Park Service
in Alaska more vulnerable to political pressure. Interview, November 14,
1983.
22. [Roger J.] Contor, Discussion PaperFuture
Administrative Plans for Alaska," March 9, 1978, Box 40, NPS WASO Files,
ANILCA Papers, USDI; Juanita Alvarez, Notes, Alaska Planning Meeting,
May 19, [1978], Box 18, Ibid.; Alaska Planning Meetings, May 11,
1978, Ibid.; Bryan Harry to Roger Contor, June 6, 1978, Box 1,
Ibid.
23. Interview of John Cook, January 26, 1984;
Interview of Douglas Warnock, August 6, 1984. Time and again, the
political volatility of the Alaska situation had forced the NPS director
to make decisions without consulting subordinates in the line
organization. Evidence suggests that Director Whalen's decision was made
without informing the Washington Office or Pacific Northwest Regional
Office. See Assistant to the Director for Alaska, September 20, 1978,
Box 89, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI and Talking Paper for
November 6 Meeting with Mr. Herbst, draft, Contor, 11/5/78,
Ibid.
24. Interview of John Cook, Jan. 26, 1984;
Interview of Douglas Warnock, August 15, 1984. Janet McCabe and Keith
Shreiner became area directors for the Heritage Conservation and
Recreation Service and Fish & Wildlife Service at the same time.
25. Secretary [Cecil Andrus] to Solicitor, et
al, December 2, 1980 [ANILCA Implementation Directive], ANILCA
Papers, USDI.
26. Interview of John Cook, January 26, 1984; "ARO:
A Regional Office," Courier, The National Park Service
Newsletter, vol. 4, no. 1, (January 1981), p. 2.
27. Albert G. Henson to Area Director, June 15,
1976, ANCSA Implementation, 1975-76, Swem Papers.
28. Biographical Sketches", November 12, 1976, Box
1, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Summary of Interview of Gerald
Wright by Michael Lappen, February 13, 1984, typescript in author's
possession; R. Gerald Wright to Assistant to the Director, for Alaska,
June 1, 1979, Box 16, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; R. Gerald
Wright, "Sport Hunting in the Proposed Alaskan Parks - A Philosophical
Discussion," June 22, 1977, L-58, ARO Central Files, Inactive, ARO. Both
Gordon and Shaine were Alaska residents and familiar to residents of the
Wrangell-Saint Elias area.
29. Interview of William E. Brown, November 10,
1983; Trip Reports - Yukon-Charley Keyman, August 28-September 2, 1976,
September 6-9, 1976, September 9-14, etc., Box 46, Alaska Task Force
Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Goals - Yukon-Charley [1976], AAO: Goals,
etc., Denali Keyman File, Box 28, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC,
Seattle; Quoted in Everhart, National Park Service (1982
edition), p. 140.
30. Interview of John Kauffmann, December 5, 1983;
Goals - Keyman, Gates of the Arctic, AAO: Goals, etc., Box 28 Alaska
Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle. After 1973 when the Noatak
proposal once again came under NPS auspices, Kauffmann assumed
responsibility for that area.
31 . Al Henson to Jerome Trigg [Director, Bering
Straits Native Corporation], October 3, 1975, Box 26, Alaska Task Force
Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Goals - Keyman - Chukchi-Imuruk [1976],
AAO: Goals, etc., Denali Keyman Files, Box 28, Ibid.; T. Stell
Newman, "Bering Land Bridge, Arctic Causeway to the New World," in
Wilderness Parklands in Alaska, ed. by Connolly, p. 46. Dr.
Newman left Alaska to become superintendent of the new War in the
Pacific National Historical Park. He was killed in an automobile
accident there.
32. National Park Service, Inventory of Reports
and Publications Relating to Alaska, undated MS [ca. 1972],
Breedlove Papers, HFC. The figure does not include the natural landmark
studies. Some forty-six areas were studied as potential natural
landmarks before 1972.
33. John Dennis to Al Henson, March 1, 1974, L-48,
Wilderness, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Answers to
Senator Steven's Questions, draft, February 1978, Box 18, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; National Park Service, "Natural, Historical,
and Cultural Resource Studies in Alaska," January 1978, Library, Rocky
Mountain Regional Office; "Task Force Research", undated MS [ca. 1976],
Senmark Files, HFC; Al Henson to Roger J. Contor, undated MS [1977], ARO
Files - Old Federal Building Warehouse, ARO; Dennis, "National Park
Service's Research in Alaska - 1972-76," passim; USDI, NPS,
Proceedings of the First Conference on Scientific Research in the
National Parks, November 9-12, 1976 ed. by Robert M. Linn,
(Washington, D.C.: GPO, 1976).
34. Report in Box 47, Alaska Task Force Files, RG
79, FARC, Seattle; Origin and Geologic Setting of the Maars Near Cape
Espenberg, Alaska (1976); The Raven, Quarterly Newsletter of the
Center for Northern Studies (July 1973); Dennis, "National Park
Research in Alaska," 281-82. A similar multi-disciplinary resource study
at Chukchi-Imuruk was produced.
35. John Kauffmann to Dan Strickland, February 24,
1977, Field Reports, Park Files, Gates of the Arctic National
Park/Preserve; Interview of G. Ray Bane, July 15, 1983; Fairbanks
Daily News-Miner, April 1, 1978, Belous Clipping Files, Special
Collections Division, DPL. Bane, who is an anthropologist by training,
later participated in subsistence studies of the Kobuk and Koyukuk. He
joined the NPS and played a crucial role as the only NPS employee
permanently in any of the new areas before 1980. After passage of ANILCA
he coordinated subsistence at Gates of the Arctic and northwest areas
and is today management assistant at the latter.
36. Gordon Watson to Al Henson, Bill Thomas, et.
al., July 30, 1975, A-94, FWS, Box 4, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79,
FARC Seattle; Distribution and Density of Bald Eagle Nests, Katmai
Area, Alaska (1974) and Distribution and Density of Brown Bear
Denning, Katmai Area, Alaska (1974) in Box 2, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; William R. Powers, "North Alaska Range Early Man Survey,"
in USDI, NPS, Fourth Annual National Park Service Pacific Northwest
Region Science/Management Conference ed. by Shirley A. Scott (1977),
p. 41; Briefing Papers - Early Man Studies Program, November 1977, Box
17, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Proposed Research Strategy for
NPS-NGS Early Man Studies, draft, 3/12/79, Box 26, Ibid.; N.W.
Ten Brink to D.H. Scovill, T. Dale Stewart, and E.W. Snider, October 12,
1979, Box 23, Ibid.; John F. Hoffecka, "A Report to the National
Geographic Society and National Park Service. The Search for Early Man
in Alaska: Results and Recommendations of the North Alaska Range
Project," 1979, Ibid.
37. T. Stell Newman to Assistant to the Director
for Alaska, April 13, 1977, Box 31, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
John Dennis to Al Henson, March 1, 1974, L-48, Wilderness, Box 17,
Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle.
38. "Subsistence Activities in Proposed National
Parklands, undated MS [1977], 2850-Subsistence Policy and Comments, ARO
Central Files, Inactive, ARO; T. Stell Newman to Assistant to the
Director for Alaska, April 13, 1977, Box 31, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Newman to Roger Contor, August 11, 1977 [Preliminary
Reports on Subsistence Research], ARO Central Files, Inactive, ARO; Task
Force Research, undated MS [1977], Stenmark Files, HFC; "Publications
and Occasional Papers," Anthropology and Historic Preservation
Cooperative Park Studies Unit, University of Alaska, Fairbanks, Alaska,
undated MS, [1981], TIC, DSC; Richard K. Nelson, "Subsistence in Future
Alaska Parklands: An Overview," July 1977, Subsistence, Box 1, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers USDI.
The studies mentioned above were all published as occasional papers
by the Cooperative Park Studies Unit: Merry Allyn Tuten, A
Preliminary Study of Subsistence Activities on the Pacific Coast of the
Proposed Aniakchak Caldera National Monument, Occasional Paper No. 4
(1977); Richard A. Caulfield, Subsistence in and Around the Proposed
Yukon-Charley National Rivers, Occasional Paper No. 20 (1979);
Richard K. Nelson, Kathleen Mautner and G. Ray Bane, Tracks in the
Wildland: A Portrayal of Koyukon and Nunamiut Subsistence,
Occasional Paper No. 9, (1978).
39. Interview of George B. Hartzog, Jr., December
7, 1983; Interview of Zorro Bradley, November 7, 1983; Earl E. Chase to
K.M. Rae, August 28, 1972 [enclosed contract for $35,000 for
establishment of CPSU and preparation of certain reports], S7215,
University of Alaska, ARO Central Files, Inactive, ARO; Biology and
Resource Management Unit, Final Report on the Establishment and First
Year's Activities of Alaska Cooperative Park Studies Unit (Contract
4-9000-3-0041) (Fairbanks: University of Alaska, 1974) and Final
Report on Calendar Year 1978 (Fairbanks: University of Alaska,
1979); David Libbey, "The Cooperative Park Studies. Its birth, death and
distribution," undated MS [1983-84], typescript in Brown Files, ARO.
40. Contract 9000-3-0041, August 2, 1972, enclosure
in Chase to Rae, August 28, 1972; Final Report on the Establishment
and First Year's Activities of the Alaska Cooperative Park Studies
Unit, p. 1; Alaska Studies, National Park Service, Publications
Conference Papers, Reports and Thesis, undated MS, Brown Files, ARO.
41. "Cooperative Research Unit (Zorro Bradley's
operation at Fairbanks), in "Background," May 10, 1975, File 27-ANCSA,
Park Files, Kenai Fjords National Park, Seward, Alaska; Zorro Bradley to
Dr. Harvey J. Carlson, December 11, 1973, Swem Correspondence,
July-December 1973, HFC. "During the past two years," an obviously angry
Bradley wrote, "there has been very little evidence of NPS support for
this activity."
42. Proposed regulations regarding Native land
selections published in 1973 indicated that 14(h) selections could also
be made on lands withdrawn under sections 17-d-2. By 1975, however,
questions had been raised within the Interior Department whether d-2
lands included in Secretary Morton's legislative proposals were
available for selection. Despite eloquent appeals from people like Zorro
Bradleywho wrote that exclusion of d-2 lands seemed "legally
indefensible and morally reprehensible"the department took the
position that d-2 lands included in Secretary Morton's 1973 proposals
were not available for cemetary and historic site selection. It did
indicate, however, that "a withdrawal made pursuant to section 17(d)(1)
of the Act which is not part of the Secretary's recommendation to
Congress of December 18, 1973, on the four national systems shall not
preclude a withdrawal pursuant to section 14(a) of the Act." Federal
Register, Vol. 38 Part 2 (March 9, 1973), p. 6510; Zorro Bradley to
Assistant Director, Park Historic Preservation, September 8, 1975, L-30
- Native Claims Regulations, Box 9, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79,
FARC, Seattle; Bradley to Assistant Director, Park Historic
Preservation, Sept. 30, 1975 [encloses an Analysis of the Legislative
Development and Intent Behind Sections 14(h)(1) and 17(d)(2) of the
Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act," that was primarily the work of Dr.
Gary Stein], 14(h) Files, ARO; Deputy Solicitor to Secretary of the
Interior, November 5, 1975, Cultural Resources, Katmai Keyman Files, Box
37, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Federal
Register Vol. 40 (December 9, 1975), p. 57365 and Vol. 41 (April 7,
1976), p. 14737.
43. For example, William Schneider indicated that
for the Inupiat, historic sites are not only the tangible physical
remains left after settlement and use, but also included the "natural
features that first attracted settlement activities and that today make
the sites desirable for hunting, fishing, and trapping." "Activities and
Opportunities for Cultural Anthropologists," CRM Bulletin, III,
(September 1979), p. 5.
44. Roger C.B. Morton to Commissioner of Indian
Affairs, Director, National Park Service, and Director, Bureau of Land
Management, December 12, 1974, H3405-14(h), Selections Box 8, Alaska
Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Federal Register, vol. 4
(April 7, 1976), pp. 14734-14740; Theodor Swem to Gary Everhardt,
January 16, 1976, Alaska Status Reports, Swem Papers; Zorro Bradley to
State Director, October 19, 1977, H32 Historic and Cemetery Sites, ARO
Central Files, Inactive, ARO; Grauman, "The ANCSA 14(h)(1) Program," p.
4. There is considerable evidence indicating that things did not go
smoothly between the agencies. Roger Contor, memo to Files, October 2,
1978, Box 2, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, UDSI.
45. Al Henson to Theodore Swem, Jan. 6, 1975
[December 1974 Monthly Report], A-58, ARO Central Files, Inactive,
ARO.
46. Earl E. Chase to A.B. Froi, June 23, 1975,
14(h) Files, ARO. The amount of the original contract was $99,000.
47. Zorro Bradley to State Director, October 18,
1977, H32 - Historic and Cemetery Sites, ARO Central Files, Inactive,
ARO; Grauman, "The ANCSA 14(h)(1) Program," p. 4.
48. Bradley to State Director, October 19, 1977. In
addition Bradley indicated that over 1,100 of the sites would be
nominated to the National Register of Historic Places. Nominations would
be submitted by the Corporations, but at their request, the 14(h) staff
would prepare the necessary documentation.
49. Bradley to State Director, October 19, 1977;
Grauman, "The ANCSA 14(h) Program," pp. 4-5; Wendy H. Arundel - "Report
on Current Research," May 22, 1980, Box 1, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI.
50. John Bligh to John Cook, March 24, 1982, 14(h)
Files, ARO; Ira J. Hutchinson to Assistant Secretary, FWP, January 13,
1982, Ibid.; John Cook to Area Director, BIA, February 23, 1983;
Ibid; J. Craig Potter [Acting Assistant Secretary, FWP] to
Assistant Secretary for Indian Affairs, April 19, 1983, Ibid.
Talk of having HCRS take over the Service's role surfaced in 1979.
Nothing came of it, however. Paul C. Pritchard to Director, HCRS, August
6, 1979, HCRS Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
51 . Al Henson to Theodor Swem, January 6, 1975,
A-58, ARO Central Files, Inactive, ARO; Swem to Gary Everhardt, January
16, 1976, Alaska Status reports, Swem Papers.
52. Bradley to State Director, October 19, 1977.
Andrews' and Stein's Reports were published as Report on the Cultural
Resources of Doyon Region: Central Alaska (1977) and Report on
the Cultural Resources of the Aleut Region (1977).
53. USDI, APG, Final Environmental Statement,
Proposed Yukon-Charley National Rivers, Alaska (Washington, D.C.:
GPO, 1974), pp. 13-14; William Brown, Richard Caulfield and Robert
Howell, "Plan Up-date - Revision Yukon-Charley National Rivers
Proposal," undated MS [1976], Denali Keyman Files, Box 30, Alaska Task
Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Brown, "Yukon-Charley: Rivers to
Yesteryear," in Wilderness Parklands in Alaska, p. 64.
Apparently, the earlier statements regarding the potential for float
trips on the Kandik and Nation Rivers were based on a report of a BOR
reconnaissance survey made in 1972-73 (see pp. 127-28). Residents of the
area disagreed with those recommendations.
54. Not all agreed that Alaska was all that
different as to require new management approaches. This continues to be
the subject of some debate within the Service today.
55. William E. Brown, This Last Treasure: Alaska
National Parklands (Anchorage: Alaska Natural History Association,
1982), p. 6; John Kauffmann, in Position Papers and Reflections on GAAR
by Keyman John Kauffmann, compiled from files by Bill Brown; Brown,
Caulfield, and Howel, "Plan update - Revision Yukon-Charley National
Rivers," [1976]; "Statement for Management Proposed Gates of the Arctic
Wilderness National Park, Alaska," November 1977, GAAR Keyman Files, Box
32, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle.
56. This shift away from recreational development
was certainly not confined to Alaska, but reflected a shift in NPS
approaches elsewhere. The movement toward preservation was however,
considerably more pronounced in Alaska.
57. Activity Reports No. 19 and 22, Assistant to
the Director for Alaska, July 14 and November 2, 1977, Box 23, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Richard J. Myshak to Directors, NPS, BOR,
FWS, February 27, 1978, Box 12, Ibid.; [Roger] Contor, Discussion
Paper - Future Administration Plans for Alaska, March 9, 1978, Boyle,
Ibid.; John Kauffman to Area Director, April 6, 1978, GAAR Keyman
Files, Box 35, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle;
Implementation Tasks for New National Park Units in Alaska, May 4, 1978,
Alaska Background, Box 23, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Ira J .
Hutchison to Regional Director, Pacific Northwest, et al.,
September 21, 1978, Box 40, Ibid.; Interview of William E. Brown,
November 11, 1983.
A considerable amount of the Department of the Interior's effort was
directed toward establishing some form of cooperative planning and
management. Along these lines, Fish and Wildlife and Park Service staffs
worked during 1978 and 1979 to develop an "Alaska Management Guide,"
described by one participant as a holistic approach to planning and
management. The effort came to naught, however, when other assistant
secretaries complained that the "covering was too broad and its
implications were so comprehensive." Although the Park Service had been
involved in cooperative planning efforts at Mount McKinley as early as
1973 and recognized, with their colleagues in the Fish and Wildlife
Service, the importance of moving ahead to some coordinated fashion,
they too objected to the guide as an effort to centralize
decision-making power in an Interior Department Alaska office. John
Reynolds to Ted Swem, May 25, 1973, Denali Keyman Files, Box 33, Alaska
Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Department of the Interior,
"Cooperative Planning and Management in Alaska," November 28, 1979, A-40
- Alaska Cooperative Planning Group, ARO Central Files, Inactive, ARO;
Richard Myshak to Undersecretary, September 5, 1973, Box 31, NPS WASO
Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Robert Herbst to Directors, NPS, FWS, BOR,
January 15, 1979; Box 17, Ibid.; Fish and Wildlife and Parks,
Alaska Management Guide, draft, June 25, 1979, Ibid.;
Robert Herbst to Asst. Secy-LW, et al., July 25, 1979,
Ibid.; Guy Martin to Robert Herbst, April 11, 1978, L204 E
Management, Box 17, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle;
Interview of Hugh Mueller (October 3, 1983), Roger Contor (November 2,
1983), John Cook (January 26, 1984), and Bill Reffalt (December 9,
1983).
58. G. Bryan Harry to Regional Director, PNW, June
21, 1977, A6435 - Organization, ARO Central Files, Inactive, ARO;
Activity Report, Assistant to the Director for Alaska, September 27,
1977, Box 23, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Interview of Bill
Brown, November 11, 1983. Henson's primary job was to assist service
center staff in preparing for the anticipated special design and
planning work load. However, in the two years before retiring he
continued to be active in the Service's Alaska affairs, advising the
director, participating in writing the supplemental environmental impact
statements, preparing information for Department of Interior testimony
at legislative hearings, and assisting in drafting national monument
proclamations.
59. Task Force Leaders - FWS, BOR and NPS to Alaska
Planning Group, December 4, 1974, L3014d, Permits, Surface d-2, Box 9,
Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Memorandum of
Understanding Between the Bureau of Land Management and Department of
Agriculture, United States Forest Service, and the Department of the
Interior, National Park Service, Fish and Wildlife Service, Bureau of
Outdoor Recreation, Regarding Interim Management of Four Systems Areas
under the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act, July 30, 1975, Swem
Correspondence, 1/75-12/76, HFC; Curt McVee to DM's, August 5, 1975,
2650-03, Authority and Directives - ANCSA FY '76, BLM Files, ANILCA
Papers, USDI; Keith Trexler to Thomas Dean, October 25, 1974, L30146 -
Permits, Box 9, Alaska Task Force Files, RG 79, FARC, Seattle; Carl D.
Johnson to Al Henson, August 25, 1975; Ibid.; Roy Sanborn to M.
Thomas Dean, December 12, 1975, Ibid.; Al Henson to M. Thomas
Dean, June 27, 1974, Ibid; Ralph Root to Al Henson, July 24,
1975, L30236, Oil Wells - Kurupa, Box 12, Ibid.
60. William J. Whalen to Robert Herbst, November 9,
1978, doc. no. 003040, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
61. James A. Joseph [for Cecil Andrus] to Mike
Gravel, December 3, 1979, Box 18, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
Secretary to James T. Mcintyre, Jr., January 2, 1979 [unsigned draft],
Ibid.; NPS Alaska Framework - Proposed Level of Funding and
Activity for Alaska under Executive Action, November 6, 1978, Planning,
Box 3, ARO Files, Old Federal Building Warehouse, ARO. The Fish and
Wildlife Service, on the other hand, assigned fourteen people to assist
in the administration, planning, and enforcement in the monuments under
its control.
62. Interview of John Cook, January 26, 1984;
Interview of William E. Brown, November 11, 1984; Douglas Warnock,
"Recollections of a First Trip to Eagle, Alaska," 1983; Temple A.
Reynolds to Regional Director, PNW, February 28, 1979 [Critique of
"Great Denali Trespass"], W3415, Great Denali Trespass, ARO Central
Files, Inactive, ARO; Interview of Dave Mihalic by Frank Williss, May
17, 1983. In addition members of regional special events team flew to
Seattle, where they waited should additional help be needed. These
special events teams are groups of rangers within a region who are
trained as a unit with an assigned leader and who are able to respond to
any law-enforcement problem.
63. William J. Whalen to Assistant Secretary, FWP
[Robert Herbst], November 9, 1979, doc. no. 003040, ANILCA Papers, USDI.
Whalen wrote that a major conflict with monument regulations would come
from sport hunting interests. If Congress acted to establish preserves,
the problem would not exist.
64. Interview of John Cook, October 27, 1983 and
January 26, 1984; Anchorage Daily News, October 21, 1979
[Interview of NPS Director William J. Whalen], ARO Clipping Files,
Special Collections Division, DPL; W.T. Tanner to Alaska Area Director,
October 18, 1979 [Operational Outline, Alaska Detail, June Through
September 1979], W-34, Law Enforcement, ARO Central Files, Inactive,
ARO. Tanner had recently spent three years in the Service's WASO office.
For two of those years he was agency representative to the Federal Law
Enforcement Center, and during the third year was staff Park Ranger in
the Division of Ranger Activities.
65. W.T. Tanner to Alaska Area Director, October
18, 1979, and Rick Smith to John Cook, October 18, 1979, W-34, Law
Enforcement, ARO Central Files, Inactive, ARO; Enforcement Plan for the
1979 Sport Hunting Season in Alaska, undated MS [June 1979], Box 19, NPS
WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Suggested Public Affairs Program for
the National Park Service Sport Hunting Plan - July-August 1979, undated
MS [1979], Ibid.; Douglas Warnock to Assistant to the Secretary
for Alaska, September 10, 1979, Ibid.; Robert Herbst to Ted
Stevens, August 20, 1979, Ibid.
66. Funds on monuments, September 11, 1979, Box 18,
NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; James A. Joseph for Cecil Andrus to
Mike Gravel, December 3, 1979, Ibid.; Interview of John Cook,
January 26, 1984; Interview of Bill Tanner, July 20, 1983. Home parks
were given funds to hire seasonals to fill the slots of those detailed.
Because the rangers in the 1978 task force came largely from
high-visibility positions in the park, this did not prove satisfactory,
and was one reason for change in personnel detailed in the summer of
1980.
67. Tanner to Cook, October 18, 1979; Rick Smith to
Cook, October 18, 1979; Enforcement Plan for the 1979 Sport Hunting
Season in Alaska, [June 1979], Box 18, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers,
USDI.
68. Tanner to Cook, October 18, 1979; Interview of
Stuart Coleman by Frank Williss, January 26, 1984; Interview of Don
Utterback by Frank Williss, January 26, 1984; Interview of Dave Mihalic,
May 17, 1983; Interview of Mack Shaver by Frank Williss, November 11,
1983. The 1979 Task Force reported directly to the Area Director. In
1980, the task force became a part of the on-going regional operations
division.
69. Tanner to Cook, October 18, 1979; Entry for
August 21, 1979, Wrangell-St. Elias N.M. Record, Park Files,
Wrangell-St. Elias National Park/Preserve. In addition the three Rangers
assigned to Wrangell-St. Elias spent several short periods at Eagle,
Circle and the Charley River in Yukon-Charley.
70. Interviews of John Cook (Jan. 26, 1984), Dave
Mihalic (May 17, 1983), Stuart Coleman (Jan. 26, 1984), Don Utterback
(Jan. 26, 1984), Mack Shaver, and Larry Van Slyke (November 2, 1983);
J.W. Tanner to Alaska Area Director; Dave Mihalic to John Cook, October
9, 1979, Walt Dabney to Cook, December 10, 1979, WaIt Gale to Cook,
October 18, 1979, Don Sholly to Cook, October 14, 1979, Roger Rudolph to
Cook, October 9, 1979 [Final Reports of Visiting Task Force], Box A, ARO
Files, Old Federal Building Warehouse, ARO. At Seward, for example, Mary
J. Karracker became deeply involved in the community
affairsplaying on a local softball team, and serving with a
voluntary ambulance crew.
71. Interview of Dave Mihalic, May 17, 1983;
Interview of Bill Tanner, July 20, 1983; Tanner to Cook, October 18,
1979; Copper Valley Views, August 8 and 22, 1979, ARO Clipping
Files, Special Collections Division, DPL; Interview of Stuart Coleman,
January 26, 1984. An embarrassed staff did make an appointment with
another dentist for Coleman. In no condition to take chances, Coleman
did not indicate that he worked for the National Park Service the next
time.
72. Interview of Dave Mihalic (May 17, 1983), Bill
Tanner (July 20, 1983), John Cook (January 26, 1984), and Don Utterback
(January 26, 1984); Tanner to Cook, October 18, 1979; Dave Mihalic to
John Cook, October 9, 1979, Box A, Old Federal Building Warehouse, ARO;
Walt Dabney to Cook, Ibid.; Walt Gale to Cook, October 18, 1979,
Ibid.; Ibid.; Don Sholly to Cook, Roger Rudolph to Cook,
Ibid; Weekly Activity Report, NPS, September 10-14, 1979; Case
Incident Report, October 22, 1979, Case Incident Reports, 1979-81, Law
Enforcement File, Park Files, Gates of the Arctic National Park and
Preserve. On October 22, after the task force rangers had returned to
their permanent assignments, vandals inflicted approximately $2000
dollars damage on an NPS plane in Bettles.
73. While it would be too much to say that violence
brought about a reversal in attitudes toward the monuments or NPS
employees, it did convince many Alaskans that protests over the monument
proclamations had gone too far. Even in the Wrangell area, which was a
hotbed of opposition, signs warning rangers to stay away came down after
the burning of the NPS plane. Tanner to Cook, October 18, 1979.
Telephone discussion with William E. Brown, November 15, 1984.
74. Tanner to Cook, October 18, 1979; Douglas G.
Warnock to Assistant to the Secretary for Alaska, September 10, 1979,
Ranger Task Force, Box 19, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI. The
Rangers at Wrangell-St. Elias brought the body of a climber down from
Mt. Sanford, an act that won considerable goodwill.
75. Anchorage Daily News, September 18,
1979, ARO Clipping Files, Special Collections Division, DPL; Interviews
of Bill Tanner (July 20, 1983), John Cook (January 26, 1984), Don
Utterback (January 26, 1984), and Dave Mihalic (May 17, 1983). The
charge of excessive force came out of an investigation of possible
illegal hunting in Gates of the Arctic. Citizens who took part in a
camp-in in Wrangell-Saint Elias (Camp Tradition) claimed that rangers
looked the other way to avoid issuing citations. Evidence does not
substantiate either claim.
76. The 1980 Ranger Task Force differed from that
in 1979 in that the fifteen rangers were generally lower-graded and
generally younger, and had fewer years' experience. Although there were
instances of violence (a NPS plane at Bettles was again vandalized) the
1980 group met less hostility and certainly less publicity. Ranger II
Task Force to Sourdoughs of Yesteryear, July and August 1980,
Secretary's files, Office of Associate Regional Director, Operations,
ARO; Interviews with Bill Tanner (July 20, 1983), John Cook (January 26,
1983), and Don Utterback, (January 26, 1983).
Dave Mihalic, Mack Shaver, and Mike Tollefson, for example, all
became superintendents. Mihalic went to Yukon Charley Rivers National
Preserve, Shaver became superintendent of the northwest areas, and
Tollefson is superintendent of Glacier Bay.
Epilogue
1. With the addition of the d-2 lands, the Park
System in Alaska totalled 51,256,000 acres. This amounted to just over
sixty-three percent of the National Park System. By 1983, NPS employees
in Alaska would total less than two percent of the number of employees
in the National Park Service. Everhart, The National Park Service
(1982), p. 198; Interview of Roger Contor, November 2, 1983.
2. Cecil D. Andrus to Solicitor, et. al., December
2, 1980 [especially attachments], NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
Required Studies, Reports, and Deadlines in Alaska Lands Legislation (As
Passed by Senate on August 19, 1980), undated MS, Box 11, Ibid.;
Deputy Assistant Secretary - Indian Affairs to Undersecretary, October
23, 1980, doc. no. 001405, ANILCA Papers, USDI; USDI, NPS Final
Environmental Impact Statement for the Kantishna Hills/Dunkle Mine Study
and Report Denali National Park and Preserve (Denver: NPS, 1984);
Margaret McKeown to Solicitor, et. al., December 31, 1980
[Emergency Interim Regulations under Alaska National Interest Lands
Conservation Act], Box 23, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; Robert
Herbst to Assistant Secretary - Policy, Budget, and Administration,
January 2, 1981, Ibid.; "National Park System in Alaska, Public
Uses," Federal Register, Vol. 46, no. 116, part 3, June 17, 1981,
pp. 31836-863. To date general management plans have been completed for
Kenai Fjords, Lake Clark, and Glacier Bay. All others are on review.
The work of the Service was further complicated in 1981 when the
Heritage Conservation and Recreation Service was abolished, and that
agency's functions transferred to the National Park Service.
3. Interview of John Cook, January 26, 1984; Cecil
D. Andrus to Solicitor, et. al., December 2, 1980. Secretary Andrus
ordered the establishment of National Park Service, Fish and Wildlife
Service, and Heritage Conservation and Recreation Service regional
offices in his December 2, 1980 implementation directive.
4. 'House of Representative Committee Report, June
26, 1980," Belous Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI; U.S., Congress, House,
Department of the Interior and Related Agencies Appropriations,
Hearings Before a Subcommittee on Appropriations, House of
Representatives, 96th Cong., 2d sess., 1980, part II, pp. 548-51,
783-79; U.S., Congress, Senate, Department of the Interior and
Related Agencies Appropriations, Hearings before the Committee on
Appropriations on H.R. 7724, 96th Cong., 2d Sess., Part 3, pp.
501-503; Anchorage Times, February 28, 1980, Fairbanks Daily
News-Miner, May 17, 1980, and Ketchikan Daily News, March
6, 1980, Special Collections Division, DPL; Interview of John Cook,
January 26, 1984. Congressional anger over President Carter's use of the
Antiquities Act seems to have been the primary reason for refusing to
grant the Service's full request. Some Congressmen did argue, moreover,
that a full appropriation would place a stamp of approval on the
President's action when it was under challenge in the courts. The
Service may have hurt its own cause when it proposed the construction of
eleven 700-square-foot employee housing units at Bettles and Kotzebue at
the cost of $300,000 each. That price, which included installation of
utility systems, design and project supervision, site development, and
construction of access roads, does not seem unreasonable, and was a
reflection of the cost of doing business in Alaska. Nor was it out of
line with costs of similar housing constructed by private interests and
other agencies in rural Alaska. In retrospect, however, the request was
unfortunately timed and made reduction of the funds requested to manage
the new areas much easier to accomplish.
5. Interview of Cook, October 27, 1983; Regional
Director's Annual Report1982, Alaska Region, ARO Central Files,
ARO. In addition, the Regional Office did begin the process of
programming this, and future historical studies of the new
parklands.
6. NPS, "Summary of New Alaska Area Requirements,"
September 26, 1980, attachment to Robert Herbst to Secretary [Andrus],
September 30, 1980 [draft], Box 40, NPS WASO Files, ANILCA Papers, USDI;
"House Appropriations Committee Report," June 6, 1980, Belous Files,
Ibid. In September 1980, the Park Service indicated that
implementation of ANILCA would require sixty-nine positions in the field
areas, and an additional thirty-eight in Anchorage. FY 1981 funds
provided for thirty positions in the field areas and six more in mining
and mineral management in the Anchorage office.
7. Interviews of John Cook (January 24, 1984), Chuck
Budge (July 29, 1983), and Paul Haertel (November 2, 1983). Budge was
also acting superintendent of Denali National Monument and Haertel
served as chief of operations in the Anchorage area office.
8. Interviews of John Cook (January 26, 1984), and
Mack Shaver (November 4, 1983).
>9. Vacancy Announcement - Park Managers--Kenai
Fjords, Bering Land Bridge, Gates of the Arctic, and Yukon Charley,
December 16. Park Files, Yukon-Charley Rivers National Preserve;
Interview of John Cook, January 24, 1984). In addition to Budge,
Haertel, and Shaver, Regional Director Cook selected Dick Ring as
superintendent at Gates of the Arctic, Dave Mihalic at Yukon-Charley,
Dave Moore at Kenai Fjords, and Larry Rose at Bering Land Bridge.
10. Interview of Dave Moore by Frank Williss, July
22, 1983. Moore would not be able to put people into the field until the
1983 season.
11. C. Mack Shaver to Regional Director, Alaska
Region, March 31, 1983 [Superintendent's Annual Report, 1981 and 1982],
ARO Central Files, ARO; Interview of Mack Shaver, November 4, 1983.
The Park Service had worked for inclusion of a local-hire provision
in the Alaska Lands bill since 1972. The provision had been deleted from
the Secretary Morton proposal at the request of the OMB. Section 1308 of
ANILCA includes a provision providing for hiring of individuals who had
"lived or worked in or near a conservation system unit, has special
knowledge or expertise concerning the natural or cultural resources of
such a unit and the management thereof."
12. Interview of Dave Mihalic, May 17, 1983. As it
turned out, use of this telephone for park business at Yukon-Charley
National Rivers provided for a real example of open government. In a
complex link, phone calls went by radio from the store to a nearby earth
station three miles away for transmission outside. It was possible, as a
result, to monitor both incoming and outgoing calls. The situation no
longer exists.
13. Interview of Dick Ring by Frank Williss, July
13, 1983; "Significant Organizational Events, 1982 - Gates of the Arctic
National Park and Preserve," April 12, 1983, ARO Central Files, ARO;
Interviews of Chuck Budge (July 29, 1983) and Bill Paleck (July 27,
1983); Budge to Regional Director, Alaska Region, March 30, 1983, ARO
Central Files, ARO.
Fairbanks headquarters of Gates of the Arctic was not established
until August. At first, it was located in offices of the Cooperative
Park Studies Unit at the University of Alaska. Headquarters of
Wrangell-Saint Elias was officially in a rented room at the library. In
actuality, according to Budge, it was in the cabs of two four-wheel
drive trucks assigned Budge and Chief Ranger Bill Paleck.
14. For a particularly perceptive analysis of the
conflicting demands that National Park Service managers in Alaska will
face, see C. Mack Shaver, "Traditional National Park Values and Living
Cultural Parks: Seemingly Conflicting Management Demands Coexisting in
Alaska's New National Parklands, 1984, typescript in ARO. This paper was
presented by Mr. Shaver at the First World Conference on Cultural Parks
held at Mesa Verde National Park, September 16-21, 1984.
15. For example, USDI, NPS, Statement for
Management, Wrangell-Saint Elias National Park (Anchorage: NPS,
1983); USDI, NPS, "Draft Statement for Management, Gates of the Arctic
National Park and Preserve," 1982; USDI, NPS, "Draft Statement for
Management, Yukon-Charley Rivers National Preserve," April 8, 1983.
16. By NPS policy neither the superintendent nor
regional director is authorized to take any action which will have a
lasting effect on the resources until a general management plan is
approved.
17. As indicated Chuck Budge, Paul Haertel, and
Mack Shaver had served as rangers-in-charge of their respective areas
since 1979 and 1980. Dave Mihalic had visited Yukon-Charley briefly as a
member of the 1979 ranger task force, and earlier had been involved in
interim management of the d-2 lands while employed at the Bureau of Land
Management. Additionally, employment of several Alaska residents as
seasonal staff brought added expertise to the staffs of the new
areas.
Nevertheless, the majority of personnel in the new parks had little
experience in Alaska, and had not been a part of the pre-ANILCA planning
process. Earlier the keymen had been considered to be prime candidates
for the positions of new area managers. Most, however, had left, and
those who remainedBill Brown and Bob Belouswere assigned to
the Anchorage Office. Brown was chief of cultural resources and Belous
was special assistant to the regional director.
18. C. Mack Shaver to Regional Director, Alaska,
March 31, 1983, ARO Central Files, ARO. It must be made clear that the
people contacted were visitors to Kotzebue and should not be considered
as park visitors.
19. Interview of Dick Ring, July 13, 1983.
20. Park Service officials recognized that a
failing of the ranger task forces that manned the national monuments in
1979 and 1980 was that the people were in the field only during the
summer. Before 1980, Ray Bane, who lived in Bettles, was the only Park
Service employee permanently in the field in any of the new areas.
21. Kotzebue and Nome, for example, are reached
only by boat (in the summer) and airplane. Gates of the Arctic is some
200 miles north of Fairbanks and is reached only by air, although the
Dalton Highway does run along the eastern boundary. Eagle (headquarters
for Yukon Charley Rivers National Preserve) can be reached by what is
euphemistically called the Taylor Highway, a 161-mile-long narrow,
winding gravel road that is open from April to mid-October. During the
winter Eagle is accessible only by airplane.
22. Dave Mihalic, "But What's it Really
Like?" Newsletter of the Association of National Park Rangers,
VII (Spring, 1984), pp. 8-9; U.S., Congress, House, Department of the
Interior and Related Agencies Appropriations for 1982, Hearings before a
Subcommittee of the Committee on Appropriations, House of
Representatives, 97th Cong., 1st Sess., 1981, pp. 805-806; Interview of
John Cook, January 26, 1984. Federal employees in Alaska do receive a
twenty-five percent cost of living adjustment.
23. Interviews of Jim Hannah (July 29, 1983), Bill
Paleck (July 27, 1983), Chuck Budge (July 29, 1983), Dave Mihalic (May
17, 1983), Bryan Pittman (July 11, 1983), Mack Shaver (November 4,
1983), and John Cook (January 26, 1984); G. Mack Shaver to Regional
Director, March 31, 1983, ARO Central Files, ARO.
Housing is not provided for by the Park Service. Mack Shaver reported
that employees in Kotzebue spent five months finding permanent housing.
The expense and difficulty in finding housing in the remote areas of
Alaska could prove to be a real problem for the Park Service in the
future. It could become a barrier to the movement of Service personnel
in and out of Alaska, causing difficulties in managing the Alaska parks
and creating, in effect, a separate Alaska National Park Service.
24. Interview of Jim Hannah, July 29, 1983. Hannah
had been a member of the 1980 ranger task force.
25. "Task Directive for meeting Alaska Planning
Needs, 1981-1985," >May 18, 1981, Elizabeth Janes Files, Branch of
Planning, Western Team (TWE), Denver Service Center (DSC); G. Ray Arnett
to Directors, NPS and FWS, June 20, 1983, ARO Central Files, ARO.
In 1981, The Alaska Regional Office gave key responsibility for
general management planning in Alaska to the Denver Service Center. In
1983, that responsibility was transferred back to Alaska. Team Captains
for remaining plans (Gates of the Arctic, Bering Land Bridge, Noatak,
Kobuk Valley, and Cape Krusenstern) were hired and duty-stationed in
Alaska.
26. "General Management Plan Program," undated MS
[1984], Janes Files, DSC. It was estimated that the total cost of
producing general management plans for the Alaska areas would be
$1,396,972. The 1982 funds represented forty percent of the service-wide
general management planning funds.
27. Summary Schedule--Status Report, Region:
Alaska, FY 1982, undated MS [1982] Janes Files, DSC.
28. "Task Directive for meeting Alaska Planning
Needs, 1981-1985," Janes Files, DSC. An environmental assessment is a
brief public document used by the Federal agency proposing an
undertaking that provides sufficient information and analysis to make a
determination whether to prepare an environmental impact statement or a
finding of no significant impact. This document also provides compliance
with the National Environmental Policy Act when a longer and more
detailed environmental impact statement is not required.
29. Federal-State Land Use Planning Commission for
Alaska, Final Report of the Federal-State Land Use Planning
Commission for Alaska: Some Guidelines for Deciding Alaska's Future
(Anchorage: JFSLUPC, 1979), foreword.
30. See, for example, "Regulations are the next d-2
fight!" Anchorage Daily News, December 23, 1981, ARO Clipping
Files, Special Collections Division, DPL; "Andrus: d-2 being
'dismantled,"' Anchorage Times, April 29, 1982, Ibid.;
"Natives find much wrong with Lands Act," Ibid.; "'We're
redeeming Lands Act promises,' Horn says," Wildlife Refuges: What
Future for Alaska? Proceedings of the National Audubon Society Alaska
Regional Conference, May 7-10, 1981, (Anchorage: National Audubon
Society Alaska Regional Office], 1982); Robert Cahn, The National Parks,
The People, The Parks, The Politics," Sierra, LXVIII (May-June,
1983), pp. 47-55; Celia Hunter, "This Land is Our Land," Alaska:
Magazine of Life on the Last Frontier, L (November
1984), pp. 15, 61; Michele Strutin, "Alaska Land Scramble," National
Parks (May/June 1982), p. 29; Edgar Wayburn, "The Alaska Lands Act.
The beginning of What?" Sierra LXVII (September-October 1982),
pp. 42-44; Wayburn, "Hunters Take Aim at Alaska's National Parks S. 49
and H.R. 1493," Sierra, LXVIII (May-June, 1983), pp. 17-18.
31. Roderick M. Nash, "Comments on the Draft
Statement of Management for Gates of the Arctic National Park and
Preserve with Special Emphasis on the problem of Air Access and
Wilderness Values," September 10, 1982, Typescript in Brown Files,
ARO.
|