Contents
Foreword
Preface
Jesuit Foundations
Gray Robes for Black 1767-68
The Archreformer Backs Down 1768-72
Tumacácori or Troy? 1772-74
The Course of Empire 1774-76
The Promise and Default of the Provincias Internas 1776-81
The Challenge of a Reforming Bishop 1781-95
A Quarrel Among Friars 1795-1808
"Corruption Has Come Among Us" 1808-20
A Trampled Guarantee 1820-28
Hanging On 1828-56
Epilogue
Abbreviations
Notes
Bibliography
|

FAR FROM THE SECURE AGENCY that was portrayed by
Herbert E. Bolton in his justly famous essay, the mission on the
Arizona-Sonora frontier was continually threatened. There had always
been detractors. Mine owner, rancher, settler, and secular clergyman
resented and lobbied against the missionary's tight-fisted,
paternalistic control over his wards and their lands, particularly when
it dragged on for generations. With the accession of Charles
IIIwho cast out the Jesuits in 1767a new breed of social
reformer joined the chorus, hurling challenge after challenge at the
Franciscans.
Yet the traditional, nearly autonomous,
Christianizing mission lived on, through the reign of enlightened
despotism, the confusion and constitutions of the Napoleonic era, and
the welter of Mexican independence, primarily because the reformers
failed to come up with a practical alternative. The mission, a cheap and
proven element of Spanish Indian policy, survived on the hostile,
economically depressed Sonora frontier because it worked. It held the
Pimas in the empire, bore the brunt of Apache assault, and satisfied the
crown's traditional obligation to do something for the native
American.
In the narrative that follows, an unprosperous but
enduring Franciscan mission, together with the nearby and perenially
undermanned presidio, provides a window on the Arizona-Sonora frontier.
The view extends for ninety years, from the Jesuit expulsion of 1767 to
the coming of the United States Army in 1856. Often it broadens to take
in Arizpe, Querétaro, Mexico City, or the court of Spain. Against
the tumultuous backdrop of Europe and New Spain, the scandals of 1815-18
in the missions loom not so bold, not so shocking.
Friars, Soldiers, and Reformers is largely
biographical. Written in the active rather than the passive, it looks
beyond the fact that a church was built, a battle fought, or a reform
imposed, to the people involved, those very human souls who did the
building, the battling, and the reforming. I have tried, so far as the
documents permit, to let missionaries, presidials, and bureaucrats live.
Nothing knocks a stereotype in the head so soundly as a dirty,
eye-gouging fight among friars.
Indians, especially as individuals, do get short
shrift, though not by design. What Josepha Ocoboa or Ramón
Pamplona thought of praying the rosary or serving in a campaign under
Spanish officers, we can only infer from Spanish sources. A friar's
lament over the persistence of native ceremonialism or a captain's
praise of his Pima auxiliaries provides some insight, but always in
another's words. Too few Indians emerge above the collectives "friendly"
and "hostile." Though I regularly assign the term hostile to the
Spaniards' enemies, whether Seris, Piatos, or Apaches, I am fully aware
that hostility was not often confined to one side or the other. When I
use "children," "wards," or "these poor souls" to describe mission
Indians, I do so to convey the friars' feelings, not my own. Soldiers
and settlers called some Apaches "tame," as they would a broken horse,
precisely because to their way of thinking the others were wild.
I have included the price of soap and wine in 1768, a
physical description of Pima Indian recruit Pablo Espinosa, as well as
the ghastly spectacle of sun-shriveled Apache heads stuck on poles
around the wall of Tucson, convinced that these details, while not
significant in themselves, help bridge the time gap that separates us
from the people of Hispanic Arizona.
Much of what has been written about the Spanish
Borderlands perpetuates the myth that they were somehow unique, that
Spanish frontiersmen who pushed north to and across the present southern
boundary of the United States found conditions unlike anything they had
experienced before. This is pure romanticism. The military and spiritual
conquests of the sixteenth century provided the precedents. The struggle
to live together and survive in Hispanic Arizona was anything but
unique.
A research contract with the National Park Service,
guardian of Tumacacori National Monument, helped make this study
possible. I am grateful to the University of Arizona Press for bringing
the book into print, and to Richard E. Greenleaf for writing a foreword.
And finally I should like to acknowledge the assistance and
encouragement of Kieran McCarty, who shared with me his own research. To
him the book is dedicated.
J.L.K.
|